Can't sleep, so I'm looking at the posts from the thread. Writing up a short timeline, in case it helps.
Day 0: Zatoth is "Killed"
Day 1:
We lynch Tucah, an ordinary tourist
Night 1:
The cult kills Fireblend, the Witch
Ultron kills Lone_Prodigy, a cultist
Day 2:
We kill Blargonaut, aka HP Lovercraft
MattAttack, aka Bastian Balthazar Bux, wins the game and leaves
Night 2:
Neuromancer erases Sorian
Ultron kills Darryl
The cult is unable to use the Sacrifice command, but presumably are able to use other commands.
Day 3:
We lynch Coppanuva, an Ordinary Tourist
Night 3:
Lord of Castamere, Priest of Cthulu, dies for unknown reasons. (Either killed by another cult, or the victim of his own ability backfiring)
Day 4:
We lynch Timeaisis, a Cult Leader. The Cult of Cthulu is pronounced dead.
Night 4:
NeverForever, an Ordinary Tourist, dies under unknown circumstances
As I don't for a second believe that Darryl was the only Insane Tourist, I've been looking for where someone might have been recruited. I don't see where that could have happened, but it does beg the question: When did Cult 2 start becoming able to preform night kills? We can account for just about every kill until Castamere, and even that has a logical explanation. Did this new cult only gain the power to kill once the Cult of Cthulu died out?