Just my thoughts. Not really arguing or anything. I really enjoy these types of discussions.
Goin through your post..
When i brought up marksman/assassin i meant that assassin makes it so the name doesn't appear, so it renders marksman useless. So lets say all 6 people on a team had assassin then marksman is pointless unless you are using it for longer hold breath (which nobody does xP)
I agree with you on assassin. I don't think it's a problem at all. Same with ghost in black ops. Cold-blooded MW2 and so on. I don't know why it outta nowhere became a problem for people to bitch about in black ops. People seem to they should have the right to know where the whole enemy team is at all times on radar or somethin. I use assassin on every class because there is practically uav 24/7 cause of support strike package. When i have uav up, i count the dots to know how many assassins there are.
I still haven't decided which strike package i like best (even with almost 19days ranked mutliplayer gameplay) but i never use support (it's for people that can't get killstreaks otherwise so they can help those who can with uavs etc.. in my head). Specialist is what i can use to have assassin, while still havin quickdraw and blast shield etc... and when i use assault, i can still get killstreaks without having assassin.
I have a friend who bought the game like 3 weeks ago and only got to lvl 26 about last week and i told him to not even consider any other red perk besides assassin and to pretend the others are just not there. It's a completely different game when the enemy knows where you are 24/7.
For dead silence, you said wanted a counter. I think it's not necessary. Why is there only 1 or 2 assassin people a game? Well, assassin does nothing in the minds of a casual gamer. They gain nothing. Quickdraw makes them be able to shoot quicker. Sleight of hand reload quicker. Assassin they gain no benefit. Same with dead silence. They walk quietly. That only appeals to us hardcore gamers. Even in search and destroy, 1 or 2 outta 6 people on your team usually have dead silence/ninja. Having to use a perk just to counter something is pretty bad, because it makes it so you can't use anything else. For example in MW2 if you played against a team of 6 heartbeat sensor users, you had to use Ninja. Now, you can't use any other green perk. A perk should give you a benefit, not block out the other team's benefits.
Also, you said you can't play based on sound. You can still hear gunfire, reloading, switch weapons being the main things you hear. For the majority of the community, they don't even notice dead silence and getting killed by it is nothing. Same with assassin. Personally, i'm aggressive and feel fine running around with other green perks besides dead silence.
One side always will win. You can't have a medium. Like the way sitrep is right now, soundwhoring still wins. Even if it is normal footstep lvl for dead silence people, you can still hear them. It's like having uav show everybody every scan and assassin people every other scan. It still makes them show on radar so it's kinda bs that they can always know where you are.
I consider myself a pretty good player i'd say but theres definitely a difference when i play with assassin or don't play with it. I'll still play very well, but it'll be more difficult to string together a longer life with a long killstreak. Getting killed by a soundwhorer btw is one of the most frustrating things ever when you watch killcams because they could be looking the opposite way or running away from you and then just turn around because they hear you and you die. It doesn't happen often, but it's annoying when it does. I don't bitch about it though cause i'm using a headset as well haha.
Honestly, i think the fairest thing is to get rid of the ability to soundwhore. It's really unfair and to have to waste perks on it is even more annoying to people because they have to waste a perk on something that does nothing for them besides block what somebody else is doing and it doesn't even work on sitrep pro. /end another longpost.
EDIT: I'm not arguing either. Just sharing my thoughts.