• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

CBO score on Senate GOP health bill released, 22M more uninsured relative to ACA

It's not even up to 22 million dead. You don't need to quantify the number of deaths to get the taking point access. How about just using "many" or "significant"?

Pretty easily, actually.

I mean, they're not hard and fast, but obamacare was a wonderful natural experiment, in that some states took the Medicaid expansion and some didn't. You can compare how far the fatality rate fell in states that took Medicaid expansion to the states that didn't, weighted for number of additional people covered by insurance. Crunching the numbers you're at a little over 1,000 deaths for every million uninsured. Vox ran the numbers here:

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.vo...17/3/14/14921962/ahca-mortality-gun-homicides

I wouldn't trust any specific number, but every estimate is on the same order of magnitude. We're talking about tens of thousands of people a year.

If Vox's estimate is correct, the federal government would save lives by dropping a nuclear bomb on Santa Fe instead of passing the bill.

In its first year it would kill more Americans than the war in Iraq, the war in Afghanistan, and every terrorist attack since the founding of the Republic.

By it's third year it will have killed more Americans than the Vietnam War.

If it's not stopped, the death toll by its twentieth anniversary will outstrip American casualties in World War II.
 

Tovarisc

Member
Full statement from @club4growth
DDWCeCFXcAEz90B.jpg

https://twitter.com/ZekeJMiller/status/879752772522061825
 

RPGCrazied

Member
Jeff Zeleny‏Verified account
@jeffzeleny

McConnell delaying health care vote until after July 4th recess. GOP senators invited to White House this afternoon to circle the wagons.

lol, guess it all fell apart. Good news.
 
Vote before recess fell apart.

Bill is still alive and going strong.

I haven't seen it corroborated yet.

But it's massive if true. Senate hopes to pull a house and ram it through before the public knew what was going on. Now we've got the entire recess to bring down the house at town halls, organize protests, and educate the public. And the more the public knows about this bill the more they hate it.
 

Tovarisc

Member
I haven't seen it corroborated yet.

But it's massive if true. Senate hopes to pull a house and ram it through before the public knew what was going on. Now we've got the entire recess to bring down the house at town halls, organize protests, and educate the public. And the more the public knows about this bill the more they hate it.

CNN also got this delay story through own sourcing: http://edition.cnn.com/2017/06/27/politics/republican-health-care-bill-vote-delayed/index.html

------

3qv3SSg.png

https://twitter.com/evanmcmurry/status/879759301006565376

b6Wg4RU.png

https://twitter.com/Reuters/status/879758861426622466

------

AARP strongly opposes Senate GOP health bill, urges senators to vote no
https://twitter.com/BraddJaffy/status/879760458047213568
 

Gruco

Banned
And studies can't find that providing people with Medicaid actually gives them better health outcomes at all:

http://theweek.com/articles/678815/medicaid-terrible-republicans-fix

Insurance is great and lack of coverage is terrifying (medical bankruptcy = bad) but aren't we supposed to be the side that believes in science, data and education, instead of superstition and bullshit? Then let's hold ourselves to that higher standard.
I mean, you're really going to explicitly misrepresent the conclusions of the Oregon study, ignore the rest of the literature completely, and then complain about how everyone else is being bad at the whole science, data, and education thing?
 
I mean, you're really going to explicitly misrepresent the conclusions of the Oregon study, ignore the rest of the literature completely, and then complain about how everyone else is being bad at the whole science, data, and education thing?

That's David's shtick. The center at any cost, even if it means fudging or ignoring evidence. And also never defend your initial post once countered. Drive bys allow you to stilll feel like you delivered a South Park "both sides r wrong I am right" ending speech.

"Insurance is great" said without a hint of irony. Because needless middle men that inflate the cost of health care are great. Single payer would be bad because that's not a centrist position. All hail insurance companies. They really care about us.
 
Top Bottom