1st pick: Reggie Fils-Aime
Reggie needs some love.
17.6 rebounds per game and 2.7 blocks. The man's a pure beast. Once he got rolling, he had stretches of 5 - 6 games where he averaged 25+ rebounds per game.
http://www.courtrivals.com/showPlayerProfile.php?pid=6676
2nd pick... hmm it's between Tarpley and Booth.
On one hand, Tarpley is a more efficient scorer, and that is helpful to a team's defense because scores give the team time to get back on defense. He also was a marginally better rebounder and turned the ball over less. On the other, Booth is nearly equal to Tarpley in all categories, but far exceeds him in one: steals. 3.4 to 1.1. It's a difference in defensive philosphy. Tarpley plays 100% conservative defense and Booth plays 64% gambling (omg I'm leaking secrets).
Since I have no faith in this sim, I'm going to pick Booth. I recall reading a few posts on the messageboards about how defense doesn't actually limit another team's scoring opportunities - it just increases your own. If that really is the case, the game is fundamentally broken.
Anyway, it's a close call, but Booth because I loved watching him get 8 steals in a game.