EventHorizon
Member
The MMO Template kind of breaks the game for me. Halo was fun to play because it was fun to play not becuase some random rewards. The way I see it the MMO template goes against the shooter template MMO = time/grinding/rewards FPS = Skill-Feel.
The MMO template can work for shooters, the problem is that it is looking like Bungie is failing to implement one of the things that provide their hook, large amounts of exploitable content. People put up with the grinding, to various degrees, because they want to see what is in that next zone. They pay the toll of slowly powering up their characters in order to experience new content. With Destiny looking to have a much reduced amount of content at launch, that incentive to grind is gone and thus the current uproar.
None of that invalidates what you said about your personal preference in gaming. The amount of grinding people will accept is variable, and your threshold just could be very low. I am only pointing out that an MMO can be successfully paired with a FPS.