I finally get to the computer and day two is already cracking-- I can see why, as there's a lot to discuss! Just off the top of my head:
-Christina's behavior over the last few days-- we should analyze each of his posts with the knowledge that he was mafia. Some things I noticed:
1. Christina was pretty anti-Seath, which makes me a little less suspicious of him
2. He also had a lot of suspicion for Absolut Bro (which would make sense if he was trying to protect Darryl)
3. Indeed, Christina originally claimed Anastasia for the purpose of supporting Darryl's "lost girls wendy" claim-- Christina was saying that, since he had a non-Disney character, Darryl's non-Disney claim was more likely to be true. But in fact Christina was lying-- so why did he claim Anastasia? The only reason I can think of is to make the town believe Darryl's wendy claim.
-Christina's powers. It seems clear that he used the name-finding power N1-- we would know if he had killed someone, and I assume it would be obvious if he stole someone's vote. So mafia had someone's role D2.
-Mazre is all but confirmed town to me at this point. Mafia would not introduce the case against Christina the way he did, when Christina hadn't been the focus of much previous negative attention at all.
-I would like to revisit Freakinchair at some point. His vote without reading the thread was suspicious, especially the fact that he didn't correct it (IIRC).
-Assuming weemadarthur is telling the truth about being shot at, why did mafia try to kill him? He would not have been my first choice if I were mafia-- his theories were a little off the wall and several people suspected him.
-Why no deaths last night? There are already several theories out there.
-I feel like people have gotten a little ahead of themselves with the "Seath recruited by Captain Hook" theory. Mostly I agree with Fireblend's comments on the topic. However, I did notice this comment by Seath right at the end of D1:
I think by the end of today I'm gonna have a heart attack. I can't take it!
Scum would be doing me a favor if they take me out tonight!
;_;
Reads a little differently if we consider the possibility of recruitment-- just wanted to put that out there on the record.
-Also, welcome Ayumi!
However, the most pressing issue is clearly Darryl's claimed investigation of weemadarthur. I'm going to say right up front that I don't believe Darryl is telling the truth. He's mafia, and I'm honestly beginning to lean towards the view expressed by others that we should turbo him.
vote: Darryl
To be clear, there are four possibilities:
1. Darryl and weemad are both town, and weemad is just lying for no particular reason, ie the view Darryl is currently trying to push. No way do I buy this theory. Weemad strikes me as someone who enjoys crazy theories, but he's been straightforward in his responses here.
2. Darryl is town, weemad is mafia, and lying about not being Tiana to get Darryl lynched. Doesn't make sense either. YesNo would not make Tiana a mafia role.
3. Darryl is town, a switcher switched weemad with Tiana, and Darryl had the phenomenal bad luck to investigate the same player who was switched. Don't buy this either. Darryl is now trying to make it sound like it should be obvious he would have investigated weemad, but I don't see why. Why not freakinchair, or euphemism/ayumi, or one of the other people who had come under suspicion? Why not AbsolutBro, actually?
4. Darryl is mafia. This is the only possibility that makes sense. Darryl could have planned to claim a switcher, or to throw suspicion on weemad, or any number of possible schemes. It wasn't like he had a lot to lose, as he was extremely likely to be lynched anyway-- why not draw out a few more town roles on his way down? Notice that he only mentioned getting a message about sleepwalking
after weemad confirmed that he is not Tiana. Why wouldn't Darryl mention this message right away if he is town?
I know I was somewhat in Darryl's camp yesterday, but this new evidence just makes it seem pretty clear.
arryl