• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Don't wear a Romney shirt!

Status
Not open for further replies.
http://finance.yahoo.com/news/teacher-ridicules-student-romney-t-155305823.html

Many Republicans can't help but wonder if a student wearing a pro-Obama T-Shirt in a Philadelphia school would have been subject to the kind of humiliation that Samantha Pawlucy was forced to endure.

The 16-year old sophomore, who attends Charles Carroll High School, told CNBC's Larry Kudlow, that she was humiliated by a teacher for wearing a T-shirt in support of Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan.

She said the teacher compared her to the worst racists in history -- the Ku Klux Klan.

"It was really embarrassing, and I think she did it because she's against Mitt Romney," Samantha said.

"I was really nervous," she added, "and I was worried that after class, people were going to come up to me and say something."
Events unfolded last Friday. Nothing out of the ordinary happened until the student arrived at her geometry class -- before that time the shirt didn't raise any objections.

However, the offending teacher saw the Romney / Ryan shirt "and told me to get out of the classroom, I said no," Samantha explained on "The Kudlow Report." (Read More Below the Video.)

When she stood her ground and refused to change, Samantha said the teacher pulled her into the hall and encouraged others to make fun of her. And according to news reports, the teacher attempted to scribble on the shirt.

Samantha also admitted to Kudlow that she was so embarrassed by what happened she hasn't returned to class. "I don't want to be threatened and I want the teacher to be fired."

Samantha's father Richard Pawlucy is beside himself. He told Larry Kudlow that he wouldn't tolerate his daughter being bullied by anybody let alone a teacher.

Although they've met with school officials about the incident, neither Samantha nor her father are satisfied. "The teacher told us it was a joke. That she jokes around with students. There's nothing funny about what she did."

The school district confirmed to CNBC that an incident occurred and it is conducting an investigation to determine whether disciplinary action is necessary.

I know that GAF is majority pro-Obama but seriously this is ridiculous. This is just straight up bullying from a teacher.
 

Mariolee

Member
Hopefully this is just one single occurrence and isn't happening elsewhere. I mean, I have teachers that joke around a lot, but this was just too far.
 

xxracerxx

Don't worry, I'll vouch for them.
Really sounds like this could be a huge exaggeration without other students coming forward.

Hell I am surprised the school even allows political shirts on campus, with all the stink they throw about for other shit on t-shirts these days.
 
wow, what a little whiney girl. "I want the teacher fired"

A school has policy, most of those policies revolve around being distastefull and distracting of other students. I think the instructor had every reason to see the shirt as something that could be disruptful and the girl should've listened to her instructor.
 
Although they've met with school officials about the incident, neither Samantha nor her father are satisfied. "The teacher told us it was a joke. That she jokes around with students. There's nothing funny about what she did."
The teacher lives for laughter.
 

Guevara

Member
These kinds of stories, that helpless Republicans are getting bullied for their beliefs/t-shirts/bumper stickers, come out every election like clockwork.

Remember the girl who carved a backwards "B" in her forehead? yeah
 
wow, what a little whiney girl. "I want the teacher fired"

A school has policy, most of those policies revolve around being distastefull and distracting of other students. I think the instructor had every reason to see the shirt as something that could be disruptful and the girl should've listened to her instructor.

When she stood her ground and refused to change, Samantha said the teacher pulled her into the hall and encouraged others to make fun of her. And according to news reports, the teacher attempted to scribble on the shirt.
 

pigeon

Banned
The Ku Klux Klan are not the worst racists in history. How can you take anything this article claims seriously?
 
wow, what a little whiney girl. "I want the teacher fired"

A school has policy, most of those policies revolve around being distastefull and distracting of other students. I think the instructor had every reason to see the shirt as something that could be disruptful and the girl should've listened to her instructor.

Her instructor compared her to the KKK, dude.
 

Emitan

Member
If you're not a rich white male you shouldn't be supporting him in the first place.

Doesn't mean she should be mocked like that though.
 

Slurmer

Banned
wow, what a little whiney girl. "I want the teacher fired"

A school has policy, most of those policies revolve around being distastefull and distracting of other students. I think the instructor had every reason to see the shirt as something that could be disruptful and the girl should've listened to her instructor.
Well if the teacher really did any of those things with any kind of the malicious intent that the student is insinuating...I think it's okay for her to be fired.
 

shira

Member
Schools should just implement dress codes.

cooper-barton-michigan-fan.jpg
 
wow, what a little whiney girl. "I want the teacher fired"

A school has policy, most of those policies revolve around being distastefull and distracting of other students. I think the instructor had every reason to see the shirt as something that could be disruptful and the girl should've listened to her instructor.

wut? :)
 

Apath

Member
When she stood her ground and refused to change, Samantha said the teacher pulled her into the hall and encouraged others to make fun of her. And according to news reports, the teacher attempted to scribble on the shirt.
Sounds like grounds for firing to me. If the teacher cannot handle a student's political viewpoint, they have no business being in a classroom.
 
When she stood her ground and refused to change, Samantha said the teacher pulled her into the hall and encouraged others to make fun of her. And according to news reports, the teacher attempted to scribble on the shirt.

This 16 year old girl who wore a Romney-Ryan t-shirt to school also claimed she didn't know if her parents were Republicans or not.

Her parents fly 2 "Tea Party" flags in their front yard, and have a daughter who wears Romney-Ryan t-shirts to school.

These parents also claimed their 16 year old is too young to understand jokes.

And that she felt "ashamed" and believed she'd "done something wrong."

It's a pile of intellectual dishonesty, mixed with outright lies, mixed with a teacher probably telling a joke they shouldn't have told. Maybe even taking it too far.

But outright believing every word the girl says in this situation?

Oh, and another detail.. the parents for their first TV interview wore t-shirts advertising their own business.
 

char0n

Member
Yeah, whatever your political beliefs or bias there should be no tolerance for this type of behavior from a teacher. If another student had done the same thing to her, there would be no arguments that it was bullying plain and simple, down to the uber lame "I was just joking around! It was a joke! No need to punish me." excuses (I can't believe anyone would buy that).

Edit: to clarify further, that is the most common "Shit I've been caught" bullying excuse used. "No no no I wasn't beating him up, we were just play fighting, no one got hurt, right billy?" "No no I was cutting her hair to help her! It was uneven and I was just trying to fix it!" "I didn't steal it, he let me borrow it and I just forgot to give it back" "No no I wasn't trying to scribble on her shirt for real I was just pretending to as a joke, honest!"

The fact that the teacher didn't deny it and instead tried to spin it that way is way more damning than any personal unrelated circumstances around the girl or her family people seem to be grasping at.
 

CoryCubed

Member
Sure there's a teacher here in Oklahoma would do the same thing if someone wore an Obama shirt, this state is blood red and people have been crazy (ier) since the debate.
 

pigeon

Banned
Well they certainly were in the history of the United States.

I would probably still go with the people who actually kept slaves and fought a war to preserve their right to do so.

(There's also a whole genocide of Native Americans thing, but, you know. We've got a whole catalog to go through.)
 
Im no fan of the guy, but assuming this is true word for word than that is fucked up because it doesn't sound like a joke to me. Actually making her leave the classroom, trying to scribble on her shirt? What the hell?


However, on the flip-side, there is always the possibility things didn't play out this dramatically and it has been blown out of proportion. It just seems almost too abstract to be true, but who knows with some people.
 
This 16 year old girl who wore a Romney-Ryan t-shirt to school also claimed she didn't know if her parents were Republicans or not.

Her parents fly 2 "Tea Party" flags in their front yard, and have a daughter who wears Romney-Ryan t-shirts to school.

These parents also claimed their 16 year old is too young to understand jokes.

And that she felt "ashamed" and believed she'd "done something wrong."

It's a pile of intellectual dishonesty, mixed with outright lies, mixed with a teacher probably telling a joke they shouldn't have told. Maybe even taking it too far.

But outright believing every word the girl says in this situation?

Oh, and another detail.. the parents for their first TV interview wore t-shirts advertising their own business.

Hahaha what a circus.
 
Allegedly. This story is told entirely from the student's perspective. That doesn't mean it isn't true, but it doesn't mean it is true, either.

Jesus. When it's anti-Romney it's "allegedly". If that teacher had been dishing on a student wearing an Obama shirt this thread would be calling for that person's job and firstborn.
 
(There's also a whole genocide of Native Americans thing, but, you know. We've got a whole catalog to go through.)

Just taking a guess as this, but I thought it was more expansion rather than racism. (though im sure there was racism behind the ideas too I guess)
 

Matt

Member
Teacher shouldn't have done this, obviously, or any permutation of this. Children have a general right to express their beliefs in school.
 
yeah, and you believe that?

Why not? Assholes really do exist in this world and *gasp* some of them are instructors, police officers and even politicians. I know it's hard to believe, man, but trust me here.

Is it possible the student's story is all bull shit? Sure, but I'm simply arguing that if what she said was true that she's not a "whiney girl" and is indeed a victim of bullying, to which her instructor should absolutely be fired for.
 

diehard

Fleer
Reading through this thread - the hypocrisy demonstrated by some people here is absolutely astounding.

Remember in "A Time to Kill" Matthew Matthew McConaughey goes through that speech with everyone's eyes closed and then says "now imagine she is white" at the end? I just imagine this story being told on gaf with a "Now imagine it was an Obama shirt" at the end.

... you get the idea.
 

Dresden

Member
This 16 year old girl who wore a Romney-Ryan t-shirt to school also claimed she didn't know if her parents were Republicans or not.

Her parents fly 2 "Tea Party" flags in their front yard, and have a daughter who wears Romney-Ryan t-shirts to school.

These parents also claimed their 16 year old is too young to understand jokes.

And that she felt "ashamed" and believed she'd "done something wrong."

It's a pile of intellectual dishonesty, mixed with outright lies, mixed with a teacher probably telling a joke they shouldn't have told. Maybe even taking it too far.

But outright believing every word the girl says in this situation?

Oh, and another detail.. the parents for their first TV interview wore t-shirts advertising their own business.

loooooool
 

Guevara

Member
Jesus. When it's anti-Romney it's "allegedly". If that teacher had been dishing on a student wearing an Obama shirt this thread would be calling for that person's job and firstborn.

Would a tea party public school teacher be an oxymoron? I'm having a hard time picturing such a person.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom