Zod the Bear
Member
ethelred said:more useful stuff [/.spoiler]
Ah, thanks much. I'll have to try that on the next Orzammar trip.
ethelred said:more useful stuff [/.spoiler]
ethelred said:If you take the double-dealing letters to the Shaperate, there's no question they're forged. The only question is if Bhelen directly ordered it or whether Gavorn did it on his own. Given how hands on Bhelen tends to be and given that Gavorn is his trusted second-in-command, I think it's much more believable that he directly ordered it (I mean, the documents relating to his father's death directly implicated him and if you're okay with fratricide and regicide I doubt you're going to get qualms over forgery), but even if he didn't, the whole incident is still rather damning. Either he did it himself or his right hand did it on his own knowing it's the sort of thing Bhelen endorses. It doesn't make a big difference.
I agree that Harrowmont, regardless of what happens in the rest of the game, doesn't turn out to be a good or effective (or even particularly long-lasting) king. But that doesn't mean that elevating Bhelen to the throne is morally ambiguous. It isn't.
lorddarkflare said:Good man, you have articulated some of my issues very well. The Witcher this game is not.
Anyone wonder why a third way was not given for dwarf nobles? If you think about it, we could have forced our way to the throne after assassinating both douche bags
Doytch said:Probably because the entire Assembly kicked your ass out and stripped you of name and caste? If they all of a sudden did a 180, I'd find that more jarring.
lorddarkflare said:Good man, you have articulated some of my issues very well. The Witcher this game is not.
Anyone wonder why a third way was not given for dwarf nobles? If you think about it, we could have forced our way to the throne after assassinating both douche bags
lorddarkflare said:Oh i certainly understand, but i was implying that the takeover would be hostile. It is not difficult to believe that if you sided with your brother, you could have worked on the inside to get what you want.
Other than something like that, there is 0 reason why a Dwarf Noble would side with him.
Zod the Bear said:My dwarf noble supported Bhelen because he had a son from those wanna be noble whores in the Origin. Sure, I could get him adopted by Harrowmont, but I wanted an Aeducan son to be an Aeducan. So, gritted my teeth and went on with it. Got my son and myself restored to the family--kind of a big deal for a dwarf.
Zod the Bear said:Ah, thanks much. I'll have to try that on the next Orzammar trip.
lorddarkflare said:Good man, you have articulated some of my issues very well. The Witcher this game is not.
Doytch said:Probably because the entire Assembly kicked your ass out and stripped you of name and caste? If they all of a sudden did a 180, I'd find that more jarring.
Zod the Bear said:My dwarf noble supported Bhelen because he had a son from those wanna be noble whores in the Origin. Sure, I could get him adopted by Harrowmont, but I wanted an Aeducan son to be an Aeducan. So, gritted my teeth and went on with it. Got my son and myself restored to the family--kind of a big deal for a dwarf.
ethelred said:It's pretty interesting.Especially if you go back to talk to Gavorn again and tell him, "hey, I know these are forgeries." His response is basically "So what? Help us anyway."
I actually think it's a bit weaker in the moral ambiguity stuff in a lot of ways even compared to Mass Effect -- which I'm sure some might disagree with, but it's how I felt after going through both games, and I found that a bit amusing just because Mass Effect's dialogue system is structured to provide Good Shepard Choice and Bad Shepard Choice, but the actual plot stuff has a lot more grey in it.
For one, Saren's motivations and actions as a villain are a lot more morally defensible than Loghain's. Yes, Saren eventually did really heinous stuff once he became a total thrall of Sovereign, but his actions prior to that point were pretty interesting -- the lengths he went to convince himself that he was doing what had to be done, firstly to stop Sovereign, and secondly to protect as much of the civilized world as possible. The decision on whether or not to kill the rachni queen was a wonderful one. So was the decision at the end on whether to save the Council's ship. They're often frustrating and short-sighted, but the society definitely needs leaders... but at the same time, is that significant enough that you should waste your firepower defending the Ascendant over holding back the entire fleet until Sovereign can be attacked? Stuff like that, I thought, didn't feature as prominently in Dragon Age.
If you look at it in terms of their belief structure, they are doing a 180, regardless. When he is convicted of Trian's murder, the second son is made casteless and sent off to die. Going off dwarven beliefs, the casteless are those that have been rejected by the Ancestors, are considered to have been mistakes that never should have existed in the first place. But when he returns as a Grey Warden, he brings a Paragon's crown and is recognized as the person speaking for the Ancestors. It's a bit silly.
That's a really nice touch for that part of the scenario. I like that bit.
RPGCrazied said:so how do you get this edge dagger? I didn't get any email, ive registered my game through the social site.. an nothing.
lorddarkflare said:My noble was female, do you know of anything like that for them?
ethelred said:It's something that's been bothering me a bit about the game. Honestly, I feel more of the choices in the game are black and white than not.
The only one that I thought was really really good was the choice of whether to use or save the Anvil. But that turned out to be a pointless decision since the ending makes it clear that the dwarves are going to fix and use the Anvil anyway.[/spoiler]
ethelred said:For one, Saren's motivations and actions as a villain are a lot more morally defensible than Loghain's. Yes, Saren eventually did really heinous stuff once he became a total thrall of Sovereign, but his actions prior to that point were pretty interesting -- the lengths he went to convince himself that he was doing what had to be done, firstly to stop Sovereign, and secondly to protect as much of the civilized world as possible. The decision on whether or not to kill the rachni queen was a wonderful one. So was the decision at the end on whether to save the Council's ship. They're often frustrating and short-sighted, but the society definitely needs leaders... but at the same time, is that significant enough that you should waste your firepower defending the Ascendant over holding back the entire fleet until Sovereign can be attacked? Stuff like that, I thought, didn't feature as prominently in Dragon Age.
Moonstone said:Duncan is portrayed as good guy and honorable man - until he kills that Grey Warden who just wants back to his wife. And why? Becuase he is to weak to become a warden. He easily could have send him away. Loghains murder of the king, is not more evil than duncans murder. Both do it for the same intention. But Duncan could have let the guy go, while Loghain had to kill the guy who was like a son to him to save Ferelden.
Doytch said:Human Noble end:And yeah, don't even get me started on your brother, who just pops up in the epilogue and I completely forgot about and didn't even recognize at first.
Moonstone said:1. As Bhelen is against a systems which drives people to drop their child into a trashbin if they want to stay with their caste, it's not that easy. No matter how evil Bhelen is - there's no clear black and white. I agree with the anvil quest.
Moonstone said:2. Elves - As it turns out, the werewolves are not so evil and the leader of the elves is the root of it. Actually it's his hate which caused this. There is no black and white side. Zathrian is bad, but the Daelish not. The wolves killed and attacked first, but they had no other choice as they are victims who tried to end it peacefully. You have to see through this to find a good solution.
Moonstone said:3. Urn. Freedom of Religon? A dialog in this quests hints at it. Has not everybody the right to believe in what he wants? Leliana holds monoloques about this, as she thinks she can hear the maker, although the church saying that the maker is gone. So Leliana is not better than the cult. Both are heretics. Or take Stens point who is an atheist. In most other rpgs, the cult would have been portrayed as pure evil, but that's not the case. They just believe that andraste is the dragon. Yes they kill people, to defend their sanctuary, but that's what people who have a strong believe do, at least in a fantasy setting.
Moonstone said:4. Denerim. Well there weren't any major choices until the landthing. The slavers are evil, but they offer a letter that helps you with the landthing, if you let them go. You don't need it to win the landthing, but you can't know this for sure at this point. And Anora or Alistair or both is no easy choice.
Moonstone said:6. Redcliff. Seems like Jovan had no other choice. He's no hired murderer, if he'd refused he would have been killed. Isolde never would have hired him, if she wouldn't be so selfish and would have send her son to the circle.
Moonstone said:And Loghain is a former hero who saved the land. I think when he started the shit, he had honorable plans. Duncan is portrayed as good guy and honorable man - until he kills that Grey Warden who just wants back to his wife. And why? Becuase he is to weak to become a warden. He easily could have send him away. Loghains murder of the king, is not more evil than duncans murder. Both do it for the same intention. But Duncan could have let the guy go, while Loghain had to kill the guy who was like a son to him to save Ferelden.
ethelred said:Well, I've already said all that I can say on this. A tyrant that implements one positive social change for the benefit of better controlling the entire populace is not doing something morally laudable. I'm not sure how much clearer I can make my position on this beyond what I've already said. I don't feel it's sufficiently well developed as a grey moral choice.
:lolRight, you have, as I said, the option to force Zathrian to lift the curse, even though it kills him. This is good, as Zathrian is a blood mage and, even though he is ostensibly doing what is best for his people, he is guided by racial hatred from a long, long time ago. But that isn't the Side with the Werewolves option. To do that, you have to go in, listen to the Lady's very reasonable defense of the werewolves and her people's development of awareness and moral inhibitions and a desire to repress their animal urges... and then say, hey fuck that, guys, let's go slaughter the entire Dalish clan down to the last man, woman, and child. This is very clearly a black moral choice!
The cult is pretty clear cut in its badness. Their murder people, they lead people into ambushes (see: anyone going to meet with "Weylon" is directed to an inn where they're killed... and Kolgrim is quite clearly stark raving mad. He talks nuttier than Christopher Walken. As far as freedom of religion goes, I don't see how that factors in at all. They have the right to believe their nutty crap, but they don't get to murder knights all across Ferelden and they prrrrrobably shouldn't be the ones guarding a sacred object that actually does have the power to heal the sick. As far as Leliana goes, I think that dialogue stuff with her makes it clear that she doesn't really believe the Maker speaks directly to her, but she came up with that idea because after she left Orlais she was no longer special and she wanted people to focus their attention on her again even though it may be negative attention. Did you take her to meet with the Guardian?
You get evidence of the slave trade even if you do the morally just thing and send the slavers to the Maker. Which is good, because they're fomenting sickness in the Alienage and, you know, killing and enslaving people. If you confront Loghain about it in the Landsmeet, he admits to his actions. As I said, none of the actions Loghain is taking at this stage are morally defensible choices in the service of protecting the kingdom. There are ways to structure a decision around "I may do something morally grey but I need to in order to protect people." The stuff Loghain and Howe are doing doesn't qualify. As far as picking between Anora and Alistair, I agree it can be a tough choice, but it isn't a moral choice. It's a political choice.
If you do the mage origin, I'd say this about Jowan: maybe he shouldn't have been practicing blood magic in the first place and then lying about it to his friends and lovers.
When Loghain retreats at Ostagar, he doesn't just kill the king. He condemns an entire army of Fereldans to death. You don't think that's a black moral mark on his record? His intentions there are not the same as Duncan's, and they're not even morally sound -- Loghain is concerned with protecting Fereldan from Orlais above all cost, and he was angry at Cailan's plan to invite Orlais's Wardens and forces to help with the Blight. But as Cailan said at the strategy meeting, the best way to ensure that Orlais wouldn't be needed was to beat the Blight with the forces they had assembled then and there... but instead of going along with that plan, Loghain ensured the death of the king, the death of the Wardens, and the deaths of thousands of others which did nothing except weaken Fereldan and make it more likely, not less, that Orlais would be needed. It's definitely not on the same level as Duncan's actions which were guided by the rule that once you agree to become a Warden, there's no turning back.
I think that Loghain's aide, Ser Cauthrien, is depicted as a much more interesting moral actor, especially if you probe her motivations and beliefs before the Landsmeet instead of just killing her outright.
Doytch said:In general, I think the tie-ins to the origin stories are weak. Huge disclaimer: I only know the Dwarf Noble and Human Noble tie-ins, but I suspect I know the City Elf one also (dungeon).
Human Noble end:The game elicited a good amount of "fuck this guy" from me when Howe backstabbed me in the Origin story, but then I barely get to do anything about it. I see the asshole in the Landsmeet (I think), and have the conversation with him and I wanted the ability to gut the fucker right there. Instead I get some shitty dialogue option and nothing happens.
Then when I finally get to kill him in the Denerim dungeons, it's in a lame fight in a small room with a shitty cutscene to finish it off. That's it? This dude backstabbed my dad, killed my family and sacked down our family's castle and I get a lame cutscene where he dies? Weak.
And yeah, don't even get me started on your brother, who just pops up in the epilogue and I completely forgot about and didn't even recognize at first.
So essentially, I think they put a lot of work into the actual Origins parts, but didn't do enough to tie it back together once the main game started.
kyo_daikun said:I think the code will be emailed around the 30th as long as you have registered your game before then, I have it but can't use it as im not a rogue and its tier 6
Well, I've already said all that I can say on this. A tyrant that implements one positive social change for the benefit of better controlling the entire populace is not doing something morally laudable. I'm not sure how much clearer I can make my position on this beyond what I've already said. I don't feel it's sufficiently well developed as a grey moral choice.
Good points all around. In the endethelred said:For one, Saren's motivations and actions as a villain are a lot more morally defensible than Loghain's.
Sielys said:So how's the control scheme though? Is it necessary to hot key a bunch of things?
John Harker said:Can you sleep with multiple party members?
I want Morrigan, but she's proving more difficult than the red head is...
Surreal said:This game looks really cool to play but all I have is a PC. I checked out the minimum/required specs but I have no idea what they mean, I've been out of PC gaming since the HL2 days.
Anyways, if a kind soul would tell me how well it would run I'd be thankful.
Windows 7 32 bit
Core 2 Duo P8600 @ 2.4 GHz
3 GB RAM
ATI Mobility Radeon HD 3450
My screen is 1600x900
I'm pretty sure if it did run if would run terribly, but maybe on all minimum settings it'd be tolerable?
laserbeam said:head here http://cyri.systemrequirementslab.com/srtest/
select dragon age origins from the list and run the test will give you a quick rundown
Zeouterlimits said:Fought ain the Mage's Tower. Wow. Alistair, the only pc alive, managed to just get a final blow in.Revenant
Also, on asking a friend what a female friend on how to handle the 'loving' Desire Demon upstairs and going with her choice (kill the demon) Alistair too was the one who just survived.
Now for wandering the Fade. Just got crushed by a troll...
sweetvar26 said:So, I missed out to buy the backpack from the Quartermaster at Ostagar. Now I can't go back there, is there any other way I can get that one? I really need the high space. I do know that there are others you can them from but there are only 5 in total and I do not want to miss any.
Any suggestions about it?
fallout said:Uuuugh. I hate the fade.
.So, I finally get a spirit mage for healing, only to lose her and the rest of my party. I am burning through so many pots on my rogue in these fights it's ridiculous. I think I may have completely screwed myself over in coming here.
Keep in mind, touching those Lyrium Veins insta-heals you.fallout said:Uuuugh. I hate the fade.
.So, I finally get a spirit mage for healing, only to lose her and the rest of my party. I am burning through so many pots on my rogue in these fights it's ridiculous. I think I may have completely screwed myself over in coming here.
She likes "Chanty" items.Zzoram said:I found Morrigan is WAY easier than Leliana or Zevran. I am still courting Leliana with little success. Andraste's Flower or whatever is something she really likes but I can't find anything else that boosts her much.
You can actually buy 2 bags at ostagar. One during the daytime, just when you get there, and one in the evening after you get back from the wilds. Giving you an extra 20 spaces right off the bat.sweetvar26 said:So, I missed out to buy the backpack from the Quartermaster at Ostagar. Now I can't go back there, is there any other way I can get that one? I really need the high space. I do know that there are others you can them from but there are only 5 in total and I do not want to miss any.
Any suggestions about it?