Well maybe not the first but the big reason I even started listening to Who Charted was because I was curious about Jason Mantzoukas appearing on a coupler older episodes. After that I just went through older episodes from comedians I liked and fell in love with Howard falling over his stream of consciousness comments and Kulap losing it every time. It was fun to isten to one of the first episodes with Casey Wilson where Howard blurts out that getting roofied and raped isn't so bad or finding the genesis of Howard's solution to The Clench™ where he starts beating himself with metal bars or his epiphany about how the guy who fucked a stuffed pony in Walmart has it all figured out.
edit: Though considering I'm too lazy to actually find links to those episodes since it's so daunting kinda undermines my point.
Here's the last six months of Who Charted?
Ep #245 - Bush-Shaped Bush (Nick Thorburn, Armen Weitzman)
Ep #244 - Meryl's New Moves (Echo Kellum)
Ep #243 - An Inconvenient Convenient Store (Natasha Leggero)
Ep #242 - Grinding In The Friend Zone (Jonah Ray, Armen Weitzman)
Ep #241 - Appropriate Funeral Music (Daniel Van Kirk)
Ep #240 - Dippin Cakes (Andy Daly)
Ep #239 - Summah Waves Of Feminism (James Adomian, Emily V. Gordon)
Ep #238 - Jurassic Sherbet (Drew Droege)
Ep #237 - The Trans-Millennial (Brooks Wheelan)
Ep #236 - Disrupted Harmonies (Brett Morris)
Ep #235 - Vision Impaired, Still Prepared (Jamie Lee)
Ep #234 - Weedies (Erin Gibson, Bryan Safi)
Ep #233 - Dry Docked Nugget (Rich Sommer)
Ep #232 - The Birthday Show! (Nate Craig)
Ep #231 - Slow Dance Party (June Diane Raphael, Armen Weitzman)
Ep #230 - 29 Forever? (Zach Sherwin)
Ep #229 - Leading Love Man (Ken Marino)
Ep #228 - Riff Raff The Rapping Dog (Eugene Cordero)
Ep #227 - Movie Theater Plug Life (Kitty)
Ep #226 - RuPaul F. Tompkins (Paul F. Tompkins)
Ep #225 - Sex Causes Pregnancy (Casey Wilson)
Ep #224 - Tardy To The Party (Jason Mantzoukas)
Ep #223 - Chappie: The Oliver Twist Story (Kate Berlant)
Ep #222 - Suit City (John Gemberling)
Ep #221 - A Tribute To Harris Wittels (Harris Wittels)
Ep #219 - Live From Cobb's Comedy Club (Jason Ritter, Brett Morris)
Here's the last six months of HH:
Ep #97 - Julie Klausner, Our Close Friend (Julie Klausner)
Ep #96 - Tom Scharpling Again, Our Close Friend (Tom Scharpling)
Ep #95 - Mike Still, Our Close Friend (Mike Still)
Ep #94 - Hayley Huntley, Hayes' Daughter (Hayley Huntley)
Ep #93 - Patrick Walsh, Our Close Friend (Patrick Walsh)
Ep #92 - Fans, Our Close Fans (Valerie Bryant, Anastasia Vigo, Tim Treese & Adam Rost)
Ep #91 - Tom Scharpling, Our Close Friend (Tom Scharpling)
Ep #90 - Brian Huskey, Our Live Friend (Brian Huskey, Brett Morris)
Ep #89 - Erin Whitehead, Our Close Friend (Erin Whitehead)
Ep #88 - Neil Campbell, Our Close Employee (Neil Campbell)
Ep #87 - Whitmer Thomas and Clay Tatum, Our Close Friends (Whitmer Thomas, Clay Tatum)
Ep #86 - Ross Mathews, Our Close Friend (Ross Mathews, Andy Kneis)
Ep #85 - David Letterman, Our Close Friend (Will Hines)
Ep #84 - Moments of Greatness, Our Constant Companions (Rashid Ramkissoon)
Ep #83 - Nick Kroll, Our Close Friend (Nick Kroll)
Ep #82 - Neil Casey, Our Close Friend (Neil Casey)
Ep #81 - Alex Anfanger and Jon Bass, Our Close Friends (Alex Anfanger, Jon Bass)
Ep #80 - Jon Gabrus Again, Our Close Friend (Jon Gabrus)
Ep #79 - Mary Holland, Our Close Friend (Mary Holland)
Ep #78 - Listeners Again, Our Close Friends
Ep #77 - The ScuzzMan, Dom's Close Friend (Dominic Dierkes, Joe Spellman)
Ep #76 - Hal Rudnick, Our Close Friend (Hal Rudnick)
Ep #75 - Shelby Fero Again, Our Close Friend (Shelby Fero)
Ep #74 - Kumail Nanjiani, Our Close Friend (Kumail Nanjiani)
Ep #73 - The Gilmore Guys, Our Close Friends (Kevin Porter, Demi Adejuyigbe)
I guess I'm just having a hard time believing this change is significant for people wanting to find new podcasts to listen to, especially
casual ones. That's still a lot of content for new people to decide if they want to invest the time and money into hearing the entire back catalog.
I think this change hurts current earwolf listeners and fans more than the new people. However, from Earwolf's perspective, us current listeners are already the ones most likely to spend money on this.
I wish they had stuck with all their current content being available forever and premium just being re-mastered ad-free versions. It also seems to me that the "Howl Miniseries" should be the main selling point of the service. Whether those miniseries be new mini-podcasts from earwolf/wolfpop hosts/guests/favorites or special / bonus podcasts of their current lineup. Or bring back VPN behind a premium paywall.