I haven't gotten all of the soundtracks yet, but what I've got on my scratch list based on suggestions are
Gravity Rush 2
Horizon Zero Dawn
Zelda
Nier: Automata
Persona 5
Hollow Knight has a beautifully sad soundtrack.
Speaking of which, I wanna congratulate whoever it was that plugged Hollow Knight on the podcast, I was thinking about doing it myself. It's a game that has the potential to be liked by pretty much all the Allies, being an awesome mix of metroidvania and souls-like mechanics and structure.
Honestly it's the 2D best metroidvania I've ever played, surpassing even Super Metroid, andi it's second only to Metroid Prime if you count 3D stuff as well.
It's that good.
Ian,
Brad,
Huber and
Ben could find many throwbacks to the Souls series, even though the fighting is much more simple. Bonus points for Ian because it shares similarities to SotN's structure and it builds his story through lore, interactions with other characters and explorations of the zones, making you comprehend the world naturally, as you travel through, without info dumps or cutscenes.
Blood could appreciate the marvelous, yet subtle soundtrack and the metroid-like progression of exploring the depths of the earth.
Kyle would love the game's contextualization of EVERYTHING. Seriously,
everything is explained or explainable in this game, you find certain things in certain places due to a reason, areas that aren't connected but that are physically near one another share many little traits, the enemies are designed around the places they're in, heck, even the map is explained and works inside the lore of the game.
Context is king in Hollow Knight.
Add to this the stellar hand-drawn art-style.
It's my current GotY, together with Zelda.