• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Endgame: McMullin now leads in Utah. McMullin 31, Trump 27, Clinton 24, Johnson 5

Status
Not open for further replies.
Trump being the first Republican to lose Utah since 1964 would surely bruise his ego (he hates losing)
I doubt it. I mean it sucks but it's honestly impressive he got that many votes in what was clearly a rigged contest in the first place. It really shows how big league his message is that he had such tremendous success.
 
Not to completely derail on a post from several weeks ago but:
959px-Evan_McMullin_ballot_access_%282016%29.svg.png

Dark blue: on ballot
Light blue: Write-in only
Grey: No access to votes

I'm seeing yellow and orange and white not any shade of blue or grey.

Am I going insane or...?
 

Xe4

Banned
Not to completely derail on a post from several weeks ago but:


I'm seeing yellow and orange and white not any shade of blue or grey.

Am I going insane or...?
It's grey. You're probably on dark theme, so it looks white, but it's really just a light shade of grey.
 

Timedog

good credit (by proxy)
Not to completely derail on a post from several weeks ago but:


I'm seeing yellow and orange and white not any shade of blue or grey.

Am I going insane or...?
This is all part of an elaborate game we've been playing with you for years. As is this comment. Your next move will, with great certainty, be to ignore this crackpot comment. Things will now proceed as planned.
 
Not to completely derail on a post from several weeks ago but:


I'm seeing yellow and orange and white not any shade of blue or grey.

Am I going insane or...?
I'm seeing two shades of orange and very light grey. Definitely no blue.

The graphic just probably got updated and re-uploaded to the same URL.
 

FelixOrion

Poet Centuriate
Not to completely derail on a post from several weeks ago but:


I'm seeing yellow and orange and white not any shade of blue or grey.

Am I going insane or...?

I'm seeing two shades of orange and very light grey. Definitely no blue.

They changed the colors on the linked image after I posted. When I posted that, they were using blue, since then the map makers at Wikipedia changed the colors for Mullins's ballot access to orange/yellow but the link remains the same.
 

FelixOrion

Poet Centuriate
Probably my last check-in on Egg McMuffin™ before the election:

Trafalgar Group (Nov. 3-5) (538: C)
1,350 LV
Clinton 30%
Trump 40%
Johnson 4%
McMullin 25%

538 Now-cast: 13.5% chance to win Utah
538 Polls-only: 12.4% chance
538 Polls-plus: 11.7% chance
 

FelixOrion

Poet Centuriate
Pretty good change he'll be the repub nominee in 2020?

I doubt it. He's a pretty neutral, cookie-cutter GOP candidate, but the main reason he's doing well at all in Utah is because he's a non-controversial Mormon conservative. I don't think that translates that well to the national stage. But he could certainly tout a Utah win as reason to vote for him in the 2019/2020 primary season.
 

Toxi

Banned
McMullin taking Utah doesn't help Clinton since what matters is getting 270 or more electoral votes.

It does, however, further demoralize Trump's base.
 
Bumping this with the same headline is really only going to misinform people.

It's looking like Trump has Utah, unless turnout works against him. Which is a shame. Almost wish Clinton would encouraged her Utah supporters to vote for McMullin as a means to close the gap, but she's too close to taking it for herself for that to be viable.
 

Redd

Member
If McMullin pulls this off and wins Utah I would be fine with it. Looking like Utah has a standard for what they're okay with for the Republican nominee.
 
I kind of don't want McMullin to win. Trump winning Utah won't win him the election, and it won't make him a viable contender. McMullin winning though? He could be the GOP's Obama. I'd sooner see him nipped in the bud.
 

cress2000

Member
Bumping this with the same headline is really only going to misinform people.

It's looking like Trump has Utah, unless turnout works against him. Which is a shame. Almost wish Mcmullen would encouraged her Utah supporters to vote for him as a means to close the gap, but she's too close to taking it for herself for that to be viable.

Your pronoun usage is extremely confusing. Please edit to clarify.
 

Biske

Member
If McMullin pulls this off and wins Utah I would be fine with it. Looking like Utah has a standard for what they're okay with for the Republican nominee.

Some Utahns.

Not all.

Trump will probably win Utah, proving that at the end of the day, Utahns can, will and do support a deplorable asshole.
 

johnsmith

remember me
I kind of don't want McMullin to win. Trump winning Utah won't win him the election, and it won't make him a viable contender. McMullin winning though? He could be the GOP's Obama. I'd sooner see him nipped in the bud.
McMullin has no chance nationally. At best he could be Utah's governor or senator one day.
 

FelixOrion

Poet Centuriate
Bumping this with the same headline is really only going to misinform people.

It's looking like Trump has Utah, unless turnout works against him. Which is a shame. Almost wish Clinton would encouraged her Utah supporters to vote for McMullin as a means to close the gap, but she's too close to taking it for herself for that to be viable.

Sorry, but I wasn't gonna make a new thread for each batch of polls. This was kinda the de facto McMullin Polls Thread in my eyes.
 

B-Dubs

No Scrubs
McMullin taking Utah doesn't help Clinton since what matters is getting 270 or more electoral votes.

It does, however, further demoralize Trump's base.

No, but it will give anyone thinking about using Trump's strategy in the future pause. If they can't even count on a solidly red state to stay in their column they might not do it in the future.
 

TAJ

Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that.
Bumping this with the same headline is really only going to misinform people.

It's looking like Trump has Utah, unless turnout works against him. Which is a shame. Almost wish Clinton would encouraged her Utah supporters to vote for McMullin as a means to close the gap, but she's too close to taking it for herself for that to be viable.

She has no chance. If that's her reason for not throwing her votes to McMuffin then lol.
 

Stinkles

Clothed, sober, cooperative
I kind of don't want McMullin to win. Trump winning Utah won't win him the election, and it won't make him a viable contender. McMullin winning though? He could be the GOP's Obama. I'd sooner see him nipped in the bud.

I think a bald middle of the road Mormon is pretty much the opposite of anyone's Obama.
 
Bumping this with the same headline is really only going to misinform people.

It's looking like Trump has Utah, unless turnout works against him. Which is a shame. Almost wish Clinton would encouraged her Utah supporters to vote for McMullin as a means to close the gap, but she's too close to taking it for herself for that to be viable.

Trump losing Utah to McMullin doesn't really hurt him especially bad. It will hurt his ego, but that's about all.

Imagine McMullin wins Utah.
If Trump has < 264 electoral votes, Trump losing Utah didn't cost him the election.
If Trump has >= 270 electoral votes, Trump wins anyway
If Trump ends up in the middle, where he has somewhere between 264 and 269 electoral votes, then McMullin's win will throw the election into the House. Seeing as how it's the House that the Republicans have on lockdown and their choices will be Trump and Clinton only, Trump will be elected President anyway.

Hillary's only interest in Utah was when she was seeing if she might be able to win the electoral votes by getting the rest of the state to split evenly between Trump and McMullin. If that's not possible, she doesn't really care if it's McMullin or Trump that wins.
 

SourBear

Banned
I've seen some of the evangelicals on my Facebook feed talking about voting for McMullin where they can, in the hopes he'll take enough states to prevent both Clinton and Trump from getting 270.

That is fucking stupid. Because then it goes to the House and the House will vote Trump in. So they are just voting for Trump via proxy.
 
I think a bald middle of the road Mormon is pretty much the opposite of anyone's Obama.

While Romney is not the best choice for my argument given that he's never one an election, it's not like Mormonism is an inherent failing. McMullin is relatively new, untainted by scandal, has not been shown to do extremist shit (unless I missed something), and opposed Trump. Jeb, Rubio, and Cruz, none of them nail all four; Kasich hits three of these, but I think he suffers some of the same problems as McMullin does.
 
I know 538 have been getting a lot of criticism over their model recently, but they still have Trump at an over 80% probability of winning Utah, and this isn't the first time I've read a story that says McMullin is polling very well. What gives?
 

Miletius

Member
I know 538 have been getting a lot of criticism over their model recently, but they still have Trump at an over 80% probability of winning Utah, and this isn't the first time I've read a story that says McMullin is polling very well. What gives?

He's polling very well, but consistently below Trump. He has a good chance of a solid showing in Utah, but not enough to overtake him. He might beat Hillary in Utah though, which would be somewhat of an accomplishment.
 
It's really a shame McMullin isn't on the ballot in Arizona, Nevada or Alaska. He could have helped Hillary that way. I'll have to settle for laughing at a Republican candidate losing, or at least getting under 50%, in Utah.
 

jackal27

Banned
It's pretty incredible that, of all people, this nobody who came in to the game so late may be the third party candidate that actually wins a state. Pretty awesome.

I just still can't believe that an Independent candidate didn't sweep in earlier to take advantage of this mess. Ron Paul would have done so well in 2016 haha (not that I dig Ron Paul or actually believe he would have done well).
 
Figures that the first election after I move out of Utah would be the first competitive (and probably last) competitive election in decades.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom