I find it confusing that someone would defend this show so adamantly. Just really not particularly well done. It had no structure or logical arc...boring stuff just kind of happened. Some of the action was kind of okay and the music was A++ but otherwise it's kind of terrible. None of the characters could really carry a scene, and they all wound up being unlikable or unremarkable.
The last episode was like a leftover idea for an OVA, but nothing about it was very fun or even fulfilling when it came to fanservice. The production was also just super poor. Lots of reused music and scenes felt only half animated.
Oh, I'm not going to make any particular arguments in favour of the final episode. That was clearly just an omake, and not the greatest omake either. I still enjoyed it for what it was, basically just the show having a laugh, but it was without a doubt the weakest episode of the series and not something to judge the whole on. The quasi-supernatural stuff, too, I didn't feel was one of the series' strongest points, often just seeming to confuse things somewhat, but it did allow for some artistically nice scenes that fit in pretty well on a thematic and emotional level, so I don't think that element of the series was a mistake.
What it comes down to, though, is the core of the show, which is what I really feel was just plain wonderful from start to finish. It took the simple but effective route of focusing in on Yura's character arc as the lead, which I thought worked really well.
Essentially the whole thing was about her discovering herself through this group of people and her newfound love for this sport - how these new experiences inspire her to come out of her initial timid shell, her struggle to integrate as both her initial timidness and then the confidence she discovers clash with the group's existing values, and how by exploring all avenues she's able to come to terms with her own nature, mature as a person, and finally reach an understanding of both the group's values and her own real desires.
Her character arc, and thus the show, took an awful lot of twists and turns, and was pretty melodramatic at times, but I felt it always managed to keep the right balance - the drama never felt too contrived, because it always made perfect sense with the point Yura's character was at. It was always easy to relate to her, whether things were going well or awfully. While Yura herself definitely made some bad decisions, it never felt like the show was demonising her, because you could always see the reasons behind her decisions, and she was rarely the only one in the wrong - other characters' personal issues and failure to understand her point of view were often equally to blame for the rising tension.
In short, the drama felt really human, and I appreciated that and found it really engaging. Plus Yura herself was just really enjoyable to watch as a character. Her sheer enthusiasm for the sport was infectious, and when she was out on the field in action, you could feel her
drive, and the results she achieved were incredibly satisfying as a result.
The other club members I felt were pretty strong as characters as well. Obviously some characters received significantly more focus than others, but I felt that when they did get focus, they made the most of it. Sonora obviously got the most, as the figure Yura looked up to and the one who understood her best. Rento probably got the next most, as the person who invited Yura to join the club in the first place, the first one Yura really felt a connection with, and the person who was the most hurt when Yura left. She got some really nice scenes, both of the lighthearted kind and the more serious and emotional kind, and was amazing in all of them. The last three members - Karira, Honoka and especially Yachiyo - probably got the least focus, but you still got a strong sense of their individual personalities and what they brought to the group, and they each had their moments.
No one is adorable in C3bu though.
These are fighting words...
This is true. They even completely blew their fake Mugi.
...and this amounts to an all-out declaration of war.
No way in hell do you imply that there was anything wrong with Rento's character and get away with it. Rento was a goddamn angel, in the best possible way. And yes, she was adorable. As was Yura. The adorableness of those two is not up for question, it is a solid fact. As for the rest of the girls, I don't think I'd use the word "adorable" to describe them, but they were definitely appealing.
Monogatari SS 13 (Otorimonogatari 2)
Oh yes, this is what I was
actually going to post about, before I got sidetracked defending Stella from the outrageous words of heretics. It actually took me a fair while to watch this episode, since I was following the Mighty No. 9 livestream at the same time, so it was kind of a case of constantly pausing and unpausing as I divided my attention between the two.
But in no way do I mean that this episode wasn't worthy of my full attention or anything like that. No, actually I'd say it's a testament to the quality of this stuff that I couldn't just
stop watching it for the livestream, I had to keep going, dammit! And indeed the episode was really enjoyable and kept my attention remarkably well despite that constant distraction.
So yeah. Nadeko's arc is just really intriguing - both the conflict with the snake itself, with the anticipation and buildup to the awful conclusion we know that's going to lead to, and the constant examination and criticism of Nadeko's character, which both makes an awful lot of sense but also feels really cruel at the same time.
There's certainly no denying that, for better or for worse, she
is really cute xp