Vanadis 01
I can already see how this can get some recognition in the Western fanbase, but being different is, by itself, not enough to instantly be praised. In a lot of ways, the tone reminded me of something like Tears to Tiara. It's been done in anime before, but that doesn't mean it's unoriginal, it just means it's the next step in how stories have been evolving in otaku culture over time.
Tigre defines himself and is defined in the show by a real sense of humanity, and establishes that this is a season for Archers. (And velociraptors?). I also like Elen. Haruka Tomatsu has always been a favorite of mine, and she did a good job with the role. The bath scene was nice, too, and while the show has as many fictional countries and terminology as Dragonar, it's presenting it in a way where the viewer is eased into things a little easier. And not just through the eyecatches that explain said terminology.
While I concende that Garo has the best opening animation so far, this, at least music-wise, is one of the best songs, right out of the gate. The ED's pretty good, too. The battles look interesting, but I'm also interested in Tigre's new castle life. Give your fantasy series some struggle, some humanity, and that can go the distance far more than any shallow "badass" ever can.