• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Fall of Anime 2012 |OT2| O cursed spite, that ever I was born to UUURRRRYYY!!

Status
Not open for further replies.

sonicmj1

Member
Utena 33

I'm so conflicted right now.
on the other hand that was really hot

irnuGYD3qFbcI.gif
 

Saiyar

Unconfirmed Member
Watching

Hayate no Gotoku
Pet Girl
Girls und Panzer
Medaka S2
Seitokai no Ichizon L2

Will watch

Chuunibyo
Hidamari Sketch

Will Watch when Uncensored

To Love-Ru Darkness
 

Articalys

Member
Newtype November Character Rankings, Girls' Side:
1) Asuna
2) Saber
3) Eru Chitanda
4) Sheryl Nome
5) Rikka Takanashi
6) Lacus Clyne
7) Yui Hirasawa
8) Homura Akemi
9) Madoka Kaname
10) Morgiana

Haven't seen the guys' rankings yet.
 

RurouniZel

Asks questions so Ezalc doesn't have to
Newtype November Character Rankings, Girls' Side:

1) Asuna
2) Saber

3) Eru Chitanda
4) Sheryl Nome
5) Rikka Takanashi
6) Lacus Clyne
7) Yui Hirasawa
8) Homura Akemi
9) Madoka Kaname
10) Morgiana

Haven't seen the guys' rankings yet.

Japan loves boring girls confirmed. Saber is cute though. <3
 

sonicmj1

Member
C'mon, man.
Utena tensing and shuddering as she struggled to maintain her composure against Akio's ministrations? Hell yes.

Utena 34

behuhuhu

Dude, she's in middle school.

It's like the bizarre opposite of those thousand-year-old loli vampires.

EDIT:
The fact that it's presented in a way that makes it kinda hot is a lot of what made it so unsettling to me.
 
Utena 35

Fabulous, shirtless bonding. Fabulous, shirtless bonding everywhere. Touga got styled on so hard.
Dude, she's in middle school.

It's like the bizarre opposite of those thousand-year-old loli vampires.

EDIT:
The fact that it's presented in a way that makes it kinda hot is a lot of what made it so unsettling to me.
So you see in me what disgusts you about yourself!

But seriously, as far as anime goes, Utena's lead characters don't really come across as middle schoolers. Whereas thousand-year-old loli vampires are dubious, a mid-20s porn actress playing the role of a "barely legal" schoolgirl is fairly standard fare.

And something related to this that I wanted to comment on but forgot to:
Utena's behavior after losing her virginity is like the antithesis of normal teenage behavior. Other than a blush here and there, it was just another day in the life of Tenjou Utena.

Also, are you denying that Touga, Saionji, etc are pure hotness? I mean, I'm straight, but goddamn.

edit: I think I'm going to pack it in for tonight(?). This last episode was pretty mundane, and I don't want to risk falling asleep in the last leg of the race.
 

Maedhros

Member
Newtype November Character Rankings, Girls' Side:

1) Asuna
2) Saber
3) Eru Chitanda
4) Sheryl Nome
5) Rikka Takanashi
6) Lacus Clyne
7) Yui Hirasawa
8) Homura Akemi
9) Madoka Kaname
10) Morgiana

Haven't seen the guys' rankings yet.

Good god... I know Japan has a shitty taste, but this list just confirm it... ugh. Putting Asuna and Chitanda in top 5? LOL

As for my watchlist:

Still watching
Psycho Pass
Btooom!
Magi
Tonari no Kaibutsu kun
Zetsuen no Tempest
Robotics; Notes
Jormungand: Perfect Order
Sword Art Online
Shin Sekai Yori
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure
Code:Breaker
Ixion Saga

Consider dropping
Chuunibyou/Retarded Girls - This show is just stupid and I'm not getting entertained by it anymore. Shittest slice of life I've watched so far in my life.

Dropped
K - Yaoi tones/Shitty story/Shitty fights
Sakurasou no Pet na Kanojo - Seems to be better than Chuunibyou... but first episode was too fucking stupid... a girl that can't dress herself? Moe.
Busou Shinki - Shitty, pandering show for otakus who wants to fap to dolls.
 

sonicmj1

Member
Utena

So you see in me what disgusts you about yourself!

But seriously, as far as anime goes, Utena's lead characters don't really come across as middle schoolers. Whereas thousand-year-old loli vampires are dubious, a mid-20s porn actress playing the role of a "barely legal" schoolgirl is fairly standard fare.

And something related to this that I wanted to comment on but forgot to:
Utena's behavior after losing her virginity is like the antithesis of normal teenage behavior. Other than a blush here and there, it was just another day in the life of Tenjou Utena.

Also, are you denying that Touga, Saionji, etc are pure hotness? I mean, I'm straight, but goddamn.

edit: I think I'm going to pack it in for tonight(?). This last episode was pretty mundane, and I don't want to risk falling asleep in the last leg of the race.

I pretty much agree with you. They come across as much older than they are. But it is the story it is, so it's weird to me.

That said, Touga and Saionji are in high school, so that's a different story. And their sizzling bromance is fabulous.

It's probably best to be rested for the home stretch. The symbolism comes fast and furious in the final three episodes, so you want to be prepared.
 

darkside31337

Tomodachi wa Mahou
Newtype November Character Rankings, Girls' Side:

1) Asuna
2) Saber
3) Eru Chitanda
4) Sheryl Nome
5) Rikka Takanashi
6) Lacus Clyne
7) Yui Hirasawa
8) Homura Akemi
9) Madoka Kaname
10) Morgiana

Haven't seen the guys' rankings yet.

Man its absolutely insane Sheryl is still up there that high.

Makes sense though, she is the waifu of forever. <3 Sheryl
 

Defuser

Member
Newtype November Character Rankings, Girls' Side:

1) Asuna
2) Saber
3) Eru Chitanda
4) Sheryl Nome
5) Rikka Takanashi
6) Lacus Clyne
7) Yui Hirasawa
8) Homura Akemi
9) Madoka Kaname
10) Morgiana

Haven't seen the guys' rankings yet.

At least Morgiana is in. I hope Alibaba or Aladdin gets in.
 

dimb

Bjergsen is the greatest midlane in the world
Psycho Pass 05
Virulent garbage. I think I just don't like any of the characters. None of them are distinct, and their interactions with one another are like an emulation of cop shows than actually feeling genuine. The police work has no logical progression or means of playing out, scenes that belong in a show like this are simply strung together. Most of it in this episode was solved by super technology suddenly appearing and saving the day, and at no point did it feel like anyone working the case was using their brain.

The main characters lamenting over the death of Spooky Boogie was pathetic, and the show's lack of emotion causes what is supposed to be some deep inner turmoil or something to instead feel like half-hearted whining. The action stuff in this show is just awful. I don't really know what else to say about it. The moment plot armor saved two characters from an explosion they should have been in I knew the show had lost me. It is absolutely mind boggling that as far as technology reaches the police essentially just run around wildly with guns shooting at people. And I simply cannot suspend my disbelief anymore of the way justice works in this show. Some of these are simple arrests to make, but instead people with high crime ratings are executed on the spot. Needlessly messy, but its difficult to imagine the reliance on technology for that split second could potentially put innocent lives at risk.
 

SDBurton

World's #1 Cosmonaut Enthusiast
Utena 33

I'm so conflicted right now.
On the one hand I want to rage because fuck Akio(JUST LIKE UTENA DID HURR), but on the other hand that was really hot and I still don't care much about Utena anyway. Anthy certainly didn't seem to be taking it very well, though.

You took this episode a hell of a lot better than I did. :)

Newtype November Character Rankings, Girls' Side:

1) Asuna
2) Saber
3) Eru Chitanda
4) Sheryl Nome
5) Rikka Takanashi
6) Lacus Clyne
7) Yui Hirasawa
8) Homura Akemi
9) Madoka Kaname
10) Morgiana

Haven't seen the guys' rankings yet.

This is the kind of garbage that can lead someone into drinking bleach. Come on Japan. :lol
 

Metrotab

Banned
Horizon - 9

- No one can match the grand-industrial force of commercialised J-Pop.
- Fanservice episode, ahoy!
- I didn't expect the Peace of Westphalia to be referenced.
 

Grzi

Member
Robotics; Notes - 05


Hey, what do you know, a good episode. Not much has been revealed, but hints have been given and this could turn out well. It could turn to crap too, but hey, I'll take the risk. I'm hoping to see some more robot battles, maybe even the appearance of Gunvarrel, that would be cool.

On a side note, where's DTL?
 

Jex

Member
Don't worry, soon it will all be about the Kirito's sister. I guess it will be the all important sister vs Asuna battle spectacular.
 

jbug617

Banned
I wonder if there is enough material for Asaoka High School Baseball Club Diary: Over Fence. As a big fan of Cross Game, I want to see more of Mitsuru Adachi work.
 

darkside31337

Tomodachi wa Mahou
Mai Ritoru Poni: Yuujou wa Mahou S3 01-02

Best anime of the season. Fun episodes, I'd say it's the 2nd best of the season premieres although the villain was pretty weak. Glad to see the gang back in action. The
crystal
forms were so awesome. Gonna have to buy dat merchandise.
 

Grzi

Member
K - 06


Where's my action? ;___;
Unnecessary background that didn't tell us much we didn't already know.
The art looked a bit uglier and the animation worse than usual at certain scenes, which is probably the first time for the show. The filter is still here.

Looks like next week there might be some sakuga, so that should be cool.
 

Jarmel

Banned
Shin Sekai 7-

It almost feels like no fucks were given when directing this. Really the directing has gone off a cliff these past three episodes.
 

kayos90

Tragic victim of fan death
Sword Art Online 19

Holy shit that was a solid episode. Why the hell can't every episode be something like this one? It has almost everything that makes something entertaining. It has its little humorous quirks, solid action, and Kirito being... well.... Kirito. Fuck. Great episode.
 
I recently learned about K (Project K? idk) Been watching it and I think it's amazing, barely on episode 3, tho.

What is AnimeGAF's verdict on the show so far?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom