Support NeoGAF

[Pelta88]

They will both win a plethora of GOTY awards and deservedly so.

 

[DeepEnigma]

They will both win a plethora of GOTY awards and deservedly so.

More than likely, this.

 

[Andrew Evenstar]

As one of the many Elden Lords on this site, I must say...
you dont have the right; O you dont have the right
Duel with God of War, for GOTY?
weak foe ahead

 

[Punished Miku]

I mean what other games are even in the conversation this year? I highly doubt GOW will outdo Elden Ring for me personally. But I’m open minded. The first one definitely wasn’t close to Elden ring-level but maybe they’ve really upped their game.

Some people didn’t like Elden Ring or felt it was super overrated - but I think that’s a minority.

Games I've enjoyed this year:

• Neon White
• Triangle Strategy
• Kirby and the Forgotten Land
• Sifu
• Splatoon 3
• Card Shark
• Immortality
• Live A Live

I think people always underestimate how much indies win these. But yeah, Elden Ring and God of War will be on everyone's short list I'm sure.

 

[Men_in_Boxes]

It's like a soup. If 10 people in a row add vegetables, someone has to add a dash of salt. Better tasting soup this way.

 

[DeepEnigma]

It's like a soup. If 10 people in a row add vegetables, someone has to add a dash of salt. Better tasting soup this way.

Sir, your vegetable farming sims are in another thread from another show.

 

[gow3isben]

Or It might be treated like GOW2. An epic masterpiece that was held back by the PS2 and overshadowed by Mass Effect, Bioshock, Uncharted and Halo 3 despite some incredible setpieces, boss fights and probably the best campaign of the lot. I think Elden Rings also feels too samey but clearly the critics didnt think so. Probably impressed by the new open world design and ignored the samey combat.

GOW2 was lauded over all of them by many lol

 

[Pedro Motta]

It's going to be like it was in 2018 when it split awards with RDR2. VGAs could go either way. They gave it to Sekiro over Death Stranding after giving kojima best director which was bizarre. So they must love fromsoft, but they also gave it to GOW so who knows. It will be close either way.

I personally think that the gameplay is going to feel incredibly stale and samey. The few videos they have shown so far dont really feature any brand new mechanics. No Uncharted 1 to Uncharted 2 or AC1 to AC2 leap. It's going to be more of the same, and those games typically dont win too many GOTY awards. See how no one is even talking about HFW this year despite the first finishing runner up to BOTW. GOW is going to have some epic setpieces and boss fights as shown in the trailer, but the sameyness will hurt it in GOTY voting even if it scores really high.

Or It might be treated like GOW2. An epic masterpiece that was held back by the PS2 and overshadowed by Mass Effect, Bioshock, Uncharted and Halo 3 despite some incredible setpieces, boss fights and probably the best campaign of the lot. I think Elden Rings also feels too samey but clearly the critics didnt think so. Probably impressed by the new open world design and ignored the samey combat.

You’re both wrong about GOW and Elden Ring. Do you even like games?

 

[semiconscious]

take your graphically stunning action game, throw in lots of extraordinarilly detailed violence & a dash of troubled relationship, saute it in some gravitas, anger, & angst, let it all simmer in its own juices for a number of hours, & you've got yourself a highly mature, thoroughly delicious goty candidate...

 

[FalsettoVibe]

Sorry, but it has no chance.

 

[Tiago Rodrigues]

Elden Ring didn’t have the luxury of Forbes conditioning the public to believe it was one of the best games this year prior to release - it just was.

It just had a ridiculous metacritic score based on reviews that 100% ignored all the performance issues the game had at launch, you're right.

 

[GigaBowser]

I think GOW will win GOTY over Elden Ring but this is a Forbes Contributor Article about a trailer

I could have written a more credible piece

 

[Thirty7ven]

Elden Ring is old trash, kids game for the twitch generation.

 

[Thirty7ven]

gotta hype the next product to consoom

My man you are completely out of the loop, bunch of media folks were talking about ER being their goty before laying hands on it.

 

[Tiago Rodrigues]

People downplaying GOW gameplay when Elden Ring is exactly the same as every souls game but in an open world game, lmao.

Anyway, for now it feels like both will win a lot of awards. The thing about God of War, is that the trailer feels like it's barely scratching the surface of what that game really is. I feel like a lot of stuff is still to be revealed. The game will surprise quite a bit tbh.

 

[Thief1987]

It just had a ridiculous metacritic score based on reviews that 100% ignored all the performance issues the game had at launch, you're right.

This game has a pile of far more glaring issues than just performance. Performance is just a small annoyance in comparison.

 

[Edgelord79]

Clear as mud.

 

[Guilty_AI]

My man you are completely out of the loop, bunch of media folks were talking about ER being their goty before laying hands on it.

gotta hype the next product to consoom

 

[GigaBowser]

This game has a pile of far more glaring issues than just performance. Performance is just a small annoyance in comparison.

Like?

 

[Fake]

Another clickbait.

 

[V1LÆM]

this trash ain't getting near Elden Ring lol. it'll do well but not as good as ER.

 

[01011001]

it has forced slow walking IN THE TRAILER...
instantly disqualified even as an actual contender

 

[LordOcidax]

I love how the press can make that conclusion with just a trailer… Looks more fanboys than the real fanboys.

 

[Thief1987]

I love how the press can make that conclusion with just a trailer… Looks more fanboys than the real fanboys.

It's not a press, it's Paul Tassi.

 

[//DEVIL//]

I don't own a PS5 anymore. But it's not even close. Gow mobs the floor with elden ring.

Man that game sucks. Just like all soul games for me. Shitty story with shitty frames even on a mighty pc with shitty frame pacing and frustrating breaking controller level bosses.

I am probably alone in this but whatever. Gow wins by default and the game isnt out yet lol.

 

[bender]

God of War can battle it out with Elden Ring for second place. Windjammers 2 is easily GOTY.

 

[remember_spinal]

the meltdowns if elden ring loses would be a sight to see and I love elden ring but it seems like a lot of people are placing so many hopes in dreams on it winning GOTY

It successfully overshadowed horizon but it won’t be the same story for GOW, which is going pretty much uncontested in November.

 

[Ozzie666]

Shredders Revenge, Triangle Strategy, Elden Ring and God of War. Pretty good list of very different games. I wonder if God of War coming out so late in the year, will prevent any flaws being exposed with the game. All others have had time to be picked apart. I really don't know what they base game of the year on anymore, because it's very subjective and everyone has a preference or genre.

I could make a legitimate argument for any of the above-mentioned games and be perfectly _fine_ or indifferent to any winner.

 

[MikeM]

How about we let the game come out first.

 

[remember_spinal]

Shredders Revenge, Triangle Strategy, Elden Ring and God of War. Pretty good list of very different games. I wonder if God of War coming out so late in the year, will prevent any flaws being exposed with the game. All others have had time to be picked apart. I really don't know what they base game of the year on anymore, because it's very subjective and everyone has a preference or genre.

I could make a legitimate argument for any of the above-mentioned games and be perfectly _fine_ or indifferent to any winner.

Horizon will be nominated also. There are not 6 games better than forbidden west imo

 

[Zok310]

Mafuckers swearing on ER. Kray coming to give it that work.

 

[Jormatar]

After the 2018 game I feel like God of War franchise took a big leap in popularity. The latest game sold 20 million copies, beat RDR2 in GOTY, scored 94 on metacritic and many people felt like it was their game of the generation.

If God of War can nail the story and enemy variety, I could absolutely see it challenging Elden Ring.

 

[Ghost of Caelid]

Needs to be a contender for one of the best games ever to be in contention and that means noticeably better than the first. I love the first game and it’s not the in the same league as elden ring.

 

[ChorizoPicozo]

How about we let the game come out first.

Do you actually believe Ragnarok is going to be the next The Order 1886?

 

[Buggy Loop]

Was not impressed by GoW on PC when I played it earlier this year and ragnarok looks like more of the same.

Who thought the level design was even remotely interesting in that game? The areas are all perpendicular to the center hub, but no interconnection or little of it. For a game that gave « Metroid » vibes initially with the unlocking areas based on found skills, they did a shit job of using it. It ended up as being mainly useful to find chests/collectables that end up mostly useless. The linearity of the levels, the backtracking, the kid having a tantrums..

It’s not even as good as the pre-dad god of wars.

For me, to beat Elden ring it would have to step up considerably.

 

[Vick]

It appears yesterday Trailer ruffled lots of feathers. Understandable.

What an embarrassing Thread.. for an article simply stating the obvious.

Keep the salt coming.

this trash ain't getting near Elden Ring lol. it'll do well but not as good as ER.

 

[remember_spinal]

It appears yesterday Trailer ruffled lots of feathers. Understandable.

What an embarrassing Thread.. for an article simply stating the obvious.

Keep the salt coming.

I’m suddenly very thirsty

 

[Tiago Rodrigues]

This game has a pile of far more glaring issues than just performance. Performance is just a small annoyance in comparison.

lmao, i can't remember the last Sony WW studios game with "more glaring issues" than what Eden Ring has or had when released. There were people that couldn't even start the damn game on PC let alone reach the point of finding performance issues

When you have Digital Foundry telling you to play the PS4 version instead of the PS5 one for stable framerates you know you suck at optimizing your own damn game, lmao.

If this God of War game came out with half of those issues you'd be all over it and trashing it, i just know that.

 

[Represent.]

Elden Cockring will be forgotten about and exposed for what it is. Another open world snooze fest with great enemy designs. Froms complete negligence towards competent combat and graphics/tech will be exposed. GOW will make Elden Ring feel like a game from 2005.

 

[Fess]

Why do people keep saying this when no one has played this game yet?

People said that Elden Ring would be a GOTY game before anyone had played it as well, and Starfield was certainly in the discussion too before the delay.

In short, we know what the developer is capable of.

As said though, this year we all win, 2022 is turning out to be a fantastic year.

 

[Gamer79]

Ragnarok will be GOTY it will be known as not one of the best games ever like Elden Ring but THE best game ever and you can take that to the bank

I hope you are right. I loved the God of War ps4

 

[Kenneth Haight]

Our hottakes .

 

[Xaero Gravity]

Why is this even an article....

It's from a Forbes contributor, so it's a blog post at best, but people can't help but fuel and revel in their small PPs console wars

 

[Cyberpunkd]

Forbes….senior contributor.

 

[Fess]

I mean what other games are even in the conversation this year? I highly doubt GOW will outdo Elden Ring for me personally. But I’m open minded. The first one definitely wasn’t close to Elden ring-level but maybe they’ve really upped their game.

Some people didn’t like Elden Ring or felt it was super overrated - but I think that’s a minority.

Ragnarök looks like a very worthy competitor but I’m not sure I’ll play it before the voting anyway so for me that’s it’s biggest obstacle to get my GOTY.

Another game to mention is Horizon Forbidden West, or has everyone forgot about that? Poor Guerrilla. First they had to battle BOTW. Then Elden Ring and Ragnarök.

 

[Heisenberg007]

I think there's a typo in the title.

The writer meant to say GOTY Winner.

 

[remember_spinal]

Ragnarök looks like a very worthy competitor but I’m not sure I’ll play it before the voting anyway so for me that’s it’s biggest obstacle to get my GOTY.

Another game to mention is Horizon Forbidden West, or has everyone forgot about that? Poor Guerrilla. First they had to battle BOTW. Then Elden Ring and Ragnarök.

Eh it’ll still be nominated at TGA’s and still get a bunch of awards. It will probably be 3rd or 4th running for total GOTY awards

Next year will be the real bloodbath for GOTY

 

[rofif]

2022 is a great year, both are amazing games

Amazing year with like 2 new games!
I’ve not seen a more dry year in my life lol.
But if we get at least 2 good games out of it, then good.
I 100h and loved Elden ring but it’s overrated af!
One game does not make a year

 

[ParaSeoul]

Geoff,your Game of The Year has returned.

 

[Hobbygaming]

take your graphically stunning action game, throw in lots of extraordinarilly detailed violence & a dash of troubled relationship, saute it in some gravitas, anger, & angst, let it all simmer in its own juices for a number of hours, & you've got yourself a highly mature, thoroughly delicious goty candidate...

If it were that easy, there would be way more Goty nominations