Risk Breaker
Member
Yoritomo said:
Nah, I have my 360 set to limited RGB range and it happens anyway.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Forza 3 vs Gran Turismo 5 Comparison Thread of John, Chapter 11, Verse 35
- Thread starter bishoptl
- Start date
Nah, I have my 360 set to limited RGB range and it happens anyway.
NullPointer
Member
I'll give the expanded option a shot. I do have HDMI and my Sony Bravia seems to default to ultra high contrast. I'd properly calibrate it if I had any clue what I was doing. Being colorblind probably doesn't help much either. ;PYoritomo said:
That said, the crush isn't as bad as Forza 3 to my eyes. I absolutely love how Forza 4 looks most of the time, short of some of the jaggies.
HollovVpo1nt said:
Correct, but when the real life and in-game footage comes from the same driver in the same car, the similar laptimes only serve to show how the real and virtual car behaves similarly to one's driving style. It's also a testament to how the car's performance and the track's modeling match their real life counterparts.
LittleJohnny
Banned
nib95 said:
Gran Turismo certainly has the reputation, and well deserved. When it comes to simulation, it's had Forza beat. However a lot has changed in Forza 4, not just visually but physics and mechanics have improved dramatically. I don't know any source that doesn't agree that Forza 4 is now the superior sim.
I prefer by a huge margin the forza 4 car selection over the gt5, but for me gt5 is some galaxys superior to forza in every aspect of a racing game would be.
I hope the D.L.C brings to the GT5 more european racing cars, and more real tracks, the lack of it is a big dissapointment, and the inclusion of 11 nascar racing cars over other racing cars in spec 2 is a extreme faiulure imo.
I hope the D.L.C brings to the GT5 more european racing cars, and more real tracks, the lack of it is a big dissapointment, and the inclusion of 11 nascar racing cars over other racing cars in spec 2 is a extreme faiulure imo.
Metalmurphy
Member
LittleJohnny said:
How many are those? How many of them actually know anything about sim racers?
Care to give some examples?
DownWithTheShip
Member
I have Forza and GT and enjoy them both. Don't want to spend money on a decent wheel, so I use the standard controllers.
I personally enjoy Forza more because the 360 controller does a pretty good job. The DS3is absolutely terrible for racing games. The triggers suck for acceleration and braking. I would imagine a wheel or maybe even a better 3rd party controller is required to fully appreciate GT.
I personally enjoy Forza more because the 360 controller does a pretty good job. The DS3is absolutely terrible for racing games. The triggers suck for acceleration and braking. I would imagine a wheel or maybe even a better 3rd party controller is required to fully appreciate GT.
LittleJohnny said:
Here is one.
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2011-10-21-reassessing-gran-turismo-5-article
DownWithTheShip said:
My friends play and enjoy GT5 on DS3 exclusively.
I'm the only one who play it on a wheel among my circle of friends. I'm telling you, with a wheel, it becomes like the Demon's Souls of racing game. The driving is much more engaging because of the wheel. And it will fight back when you bump into stuff. ^_^
Metalmurphy
Member
GTP_Daverytimes
Member
Wazzim said:
Here you go!
Love the camera shake when the car goes by, beautifully done.
eso76
Member
shinnn said:
would you mind posting similar pics from phototravel mode ?
i couldn't be bothered, but that will show people what i meant with "cars are considerably lower poly ingame".
(Not denying they're still more detailed than fm4 typical ingame models, mind you, but nowhere near phototravel or fm lod0 models)
When everything is said and done, though, i think knowing this thread will still be here when we're in our 80's is reassuring.
(i do think rims looked better in fm3)
gutterboy44
Member
GTP_Daverytimes said:
What car is that in the GIF?
Metalmurphy
Member
gutterboy44 said:
Not a Top Gear fan I take it?
KIA Cee'd
gutterboy44
Member
Metalmurphy said:
If it is the Liana, Lecetti oe C'eed I can't tell with a gif that small and fast. But yeah watched every episode, even with that worthless fat fuck.
Red Blaster
Member
LittleJohnny said:
There's one source: reality. You know, the one that doesn't feature cars that drive themselves.
GTP_Daverytimes
Member
shinnn said:
Promotional photo? it's official you really don't know anything you are saying. That's straight from photomode.
Steve McQueen
Member
patsu said:
Demon's Souls or Dark Souls?
"Gran Turismo 5, now as ever, demands wide-eyed attention at every turn, and in this regard it's very much the Dark Souls of driving. It's got its own Blighttown too, in the form of a drive around the Nordschleife in the dead of night, an experience that's as terrifying and as challenging as anything in From Software's game".
LabouredSubterfuge
Member
I swear every time I see shinnn post in this thread it's like sniffing glue in that I can't stop laughing until it occurs to me the number of brain cells it's killing. Then I'm hit by an overwhelming sadness in contemplating he might actually be airing genuinely held beliefs.
Metalmurphy
Member
shinnn said:
I can. But will I bother?
Plus pretty sure the pics you posted are from standard cars, as they all have a flat texture for the tire while premium cars have bumpmapping.
Metalmurphy said:I can. But will I bother?
Plus pretty sure the pics you posted are from standard cars, as they all have a flat texture for the tire while premium cars have bumpmapping.
Pretty sure they are premiums since I was driving with cockpit view with the BMW, and the Lexus is the IS-F. I think it is premium too?
Metalmurphy
Member
shinnn said:
Take them in Photo Travel next time, cause you know, GT5 doesn't switch models for race photo mode.
Steve McQueen said:
Yep, in last week's Eurogamer podcast Robinson said something similar when comparing the difference between the two Nurburgring experiences...
"In Forza it's loads of fun and you can just basically throw a car into a corner and about mid apex put your foot on the throttle and just slide it out, whereas if you're playing Gran Turismo you're just terrified".
gutterboy44
Member
Wazzim said:
Here you go!
Rowan Atkinson , fastest so far in the C'eed
Camera shake is a little liberal.
tusken77 said:
how about at night with rain then?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p_oW4qZkj3M&feature=related
tusken77 said:
Above all else this is what bothers me about Forza. Even with all their tire model data, physics refresh rates, etc, it still does not feel as good with a wheel. It just feels gamey. I am rarely fooled that I am playing a game. In GT5, my mind has these episodes where I think for a fraction of a second, what I am doing is real. I may lean my body into a corner in anticipation of g-forces that are not there. I think the funniest thing I ever did was squint and shield my eyes from the sun... lol... I laugh at myself for a while after I did that.
I don't get these moments in Forza.
Metalmurphy
Member
ShapeGSX said:
I think it's fantastic that T10 used the same cameras as the show and it absolutely boggles the mind why PD didn't...
Vicetrailia
Banned
gutterboy44 said:
Rowan Atkinson , fastest so far in the C'eed
Camera shake is a little liberal.
Only makes me realize how long of a ways we have to go. The tires in the Forza gif don't even move. Nitpicking at its finest!
I think they just did not had enough time to do things the right way with all the Top Gear stuff, I don't know if you remember the atmosphere around release but it was all about releasing that game ASAP.Metalmurphy said:
Haha yeah I shat my pants the first time I drove with all the HUD off in the night (alone, in a RX-7 Amemiya/Super GT), that was one of my best moments with GT5 for sure.darkwing said:
Steve McQueen
Member
paskowitz said:
I love Forza 4, but I feel exactly the same way. Despite the tearing and the framedrops, there are some moments ( for example 'special route' ) when the lighting seems so real, that I feel like driving home in my car at night. The use of a wheel reinforces this feeling. And off course, the fact that I own a GTR.
I wish!
Wax Free Vanilla
Member
Metalmurphy said:
photomode or travel, they still look like shit. the tyres and wheels are the weakest links in gt5's car models, some are truly appalling:
lol
gutterboy44
Member
The complete lack of integration of the TG license in GT5 does boggle the mind. It is all right there. Like making a movie story board from a comic book. All you have to do is convert the assets. Ugh.
Windom Earle
Member
Will Forza ever get Formula 1 cars? They are the icing on the cake in every GT game. On top of that the X2011/11 kills everything.
Dash Kappei
Not actually that important
LOLtusken77 said:
What do you care if there's optional Kinect stuff?
What do you care if casuals play with that horrible virtual wheel?
And what the hell, sound? Are you for real? No, just NO. GT5's sound effects are fucking HORRIBLE. Cars sound nothing like the real thing, so even if not accurate at least they sound nice and carry a punch in Forza 4. 95% of GT5's cars sound like my 50cc scooter.
test_account
XP-39C²
Which car is that?shinnn said:
Metalmurphy
Member
shinnn said:
"Plus pretty sure the pics you posted are from standard cars" = "You're lying"?
And I meant, take the pictures u just took in Photo Travel. If you can't use Photo Travel with standards then by default there is no model switching now is there? Use your head.
Wax Free Vanilla said:
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=32022304&postcount=15714
Some aren't.
Wax Free Vanilla
Member
Metalmurphy said:
yeah, that lambo wheel looks decent but the tyre looks absolute shit.
dat bumpmapping:
these are ps4 quality cars? lol, edges galore. polyphony better have some super high poly car models stored somewhere...