Support NeoGAF

[BlueWord]

Just watched 17 and 18, one right after the other. If I recall correctly, there was a bit more suspense in the manga regarding

Spoiler

whether or not Roy actually killed Maria. They sort of knocked it out in two episodes, here.

Also, is it just me, or did 18 have better visual quality than some of the other recent episodes? It may have just been a palette swap for lighter tones, but it was a nice contrast with previous episodes.

Next up,

Spoiler

Hohenheim... well, for Ed, anyway.

 

[TheOddOne]

Regarding your comments:

Spoiler

#1: The name is Maria, not Diana. :lol
#2: As people have mentioned before, the first anime did it's own thing. Scar is the person who kills Winry's parents in the source material. Mustang killing them was completely fabricated in the first anime.

BHAHAHAHAHH... it was way to late for me :lol :lol :lol

 

[GaimeGuy]

spoilers

Well, in the manga, they didn't do (episode 18 spoilers)

Spoiler

Ed going to Xerxes at the same time as the confrontation with the homunculi/barry's real body.... in fact, it shouldn't even occur for another 1 or two episodes. Although the events occur at roughly the same time, Arakawa covered everything with Roy in Central first, THEN covered Ed's little side trip.

There are a good 5-6 chapters between the scene in the alley and Ed meeting Maria in Xerxes and learning the truth about her. Since FMA is serialized montly, that means there was a good half-year where people were left in the dark about whether or not Mustang killed her, never mind the fact that Brotherhood is also quite a bit more straightforward than the manga due to its pacing of ~2 chapters per episode and with a lot of character interactions, dialogues, and some subplots being cut out altogether

 

[Auron_Kale]

Watched ep. 18, definitely great.

I'm kinda disappointed that they crammed both the truth about Maria and Ed's trip to the Eastern ruins into one episode, but then again, all of Mustang's team got airtime so I'm happy.

Loved the foreshadowing of future events and I was stoked to see the telephone scenes animated.

Next episode is going to be downright epic. Can't wait!

 

[GhostRidah]

How long is this series going to be? I seen the original but I think I want to start watching this one soon.

 

[GaimeGuy]

How long is this series going to be? I seen the original but I think I want to start watching this one soon.

Unfortunately, based on the way they're pacing things, I'm expecting something around the length of the first anime (50-55 eps). This is not really enough time to do a faithful adaptation though.... should have been ~75 episodes really :/

 

[BlueWord]

Unfortunately, based on the way they're pacing things, I'm expecting something around the length of the first anime (50-55 eps). This is not really enough time to do a faithful adaptation though.... should have been ~75 episodes really :/

Yeah, I was talking about this with a friend the other day. I can't help but feel that the story of FMA would be better told in a longer series.

On the other hand, they also have to pace things quicker, which means there aren't going to be too many boring episodes.

 

[Jangaroo]

Just watched 17 and 18, one right after the other. If I recall correctly, there was a bit more suspense in the manga regarding

Spoiler

whether or not Roy actually killed Maria. They sort of knocked it out in two episodes, here.

Also, is it just me, or did 18 have better visual quality than some of the other recent episodes? It may have just been a palette swap for lighter tones, but it was a nice contrast with previous episodes.

Next up,

Spoiler

Hohenheim... well, for Ed, anyway.

The last episode or two have had some disparities in their animation quality. Episode 18 looked a lot nice though. This happens in animation all the time though, certain episodes just don't have as much polish as the more important ones.

 

[castlegar]

Anyone pick up the OVA? I was thinking of getting it, but I've already seen the subs so Im on the fence. I know it's cheap, but eh, they were ok. The best one has hardly any dialogue, lol. Curious of how the chibi party will translate, though.

I guess it would be nice to have, just to complete the series

 

[Auron_Kale]

Anyone pick up the OVA? I was thinking of getting it, but I've already seen the subs so Im on the fence. I know it's cheap, but eh, they were ok. The best one has hardly any dialogue, lol. Curious of how the chibi party will translate, though.

I guess it would be nice to have, just to complete the series

My friend's dad picked it up for me at SDCC, but I haven't had a chance to watch it yet. Funimation has a trailer for it on their youtube channel, so you can at least hear the voices.

I do know that when I saw the trailer for it at Anime Expo, the few excerpted pieces of dialogue were great.

 

[GaimeGuy]

Yeah, I was talking about this with a friend the other day. I can't help but feel that the story of FMA would be better told in a longer series.

On the other hand, they also have to pace things quicker, which means there aren't going to be too many boring episodes.

there really aren't that many boring or drawn out sections of Full Metal Alchemist, to be honest.... the worst is probably the Paninya chase scene (it takes up like 3/4 of a chapter, seriously >_>). It's pretty much perfectly paced, with events being fleshed out without being drawn out.

a 1 chapter per episode pace would be too slow, I agree, but a 6 season series with 74-76 episodes, or ~1.5 chapters per episode, would have been perfect, especially considering that 25-50% of each chapter is resolving things that the previous chapter ended with.... would allow them to pace episodes pretty freely (that is, in determining cliffhangers and how to end episodes eventwise/emotion wise).

 

[GaimeGuy]

So, episode 19 should be airing in about 10 hours or so.... this is something that arakawa and manga viewers have been hoping to see animated for years. I hope they do it justice

Edit: Haven't seen the ep yet, but it sounds like it delivered

 

[Won]

*scratches head*

The Xing fight is left out? Really now? -.-

At least the rest looks epic.

 

[duckroll]

People still watch this shit? Lolz.

 

[Defuser]

People still watch this shit? Lolz.

Your love hate relationship with bones is wierd lol.

 

[Magnus_Bulla]

So just how different is this than the original one?

 

[duckroll]

So just how different is this than the original one?

The first series had a director who actually understands shounen anime.

 

[Tacitus_]

The first series had a director who actually understands shounen anime.

I think that's balanced by having a shitty plot.

 

[Orin GA]

Watch episode 19 and say that again duckroll >:|

 

[Magnus_Bulla]

Ok, so basically if I've already seen and loved the first one is this one worth checking out? Or is it just the same basic thing with new animation?

 

[Lain]

So just how different is this than the original one?

This is good, the other one isn't. That's all.

 

[duckroll]

Watch episode 19 and say that again duckroll >:|

You mean the episode where they decide to completely remove an awesome fight from the manga involving awesome characters? Yeah that episode. What a piece of shit!

 

[BeEatNU]

People still watch this shit? Lolz.

:|

 

[duckroll]

Sorry, I'm just an angry bitter manga reader. I'm sure this will wear off once I get over it. Ep19 has really good animation. I'm just mad they removed the other fight.

 

[Tacitus_]

What fight did they remove? I haven't seen ep 19 yet.

 

[GaimeGuy]

What fight did they remove? I haven't seen ep 19 yet.

Spoiler

Ran Fan + Ling vs. Envy

 

[Tacitus_]

Spoiler

Ran Fan + Ling vs. Envy

Hmm, I will need to consult my manga collection when I return home before I can exclaim sufficient outrage about this. I might even go as far as posting an image macro.

Hmm, was it at the [OBVIOUS MANGA SPOILERS]

Spoiler

stakeout near whathisnames apartment with Barry? The fight where Envy kept transforming into different people and Ran Fan said that she senses him, whatever he becomes?

 

[GaimeGuy]

Hmm, I will need to consult my manga collection when I return home before I can exclaim sufficient outrage about this. I might even go as far as posting an image macro.

Hmm, was it at the [OBVIOUS MANGA SPOILERS]

Spoiler

stakeout near whathisnames apartment with Barry? The fight where Envy kept transforming into different people and Ran Fan said that she senses him, whatever he becomes?

Yes.

 

[Zanmato]

You mean the episode where they decide to completely remove an awesome fight from the manga involving awesome characters? Yeah that episode. What a piece of shit!

WHAT WHAT WHAT!?!?!?! Does it at least look like it will be in the next episode?

 

[GaimeGuy]

WHAT WHAT WHAT!?!?!?! Does it at least look like it will be in the next episode?

apparently not.

 

[Tacitus_]

apparently not.

Meh, while a nice fight (and propably awesome while animated), it isn't exactly necessary for plot advancement. The way someone acted, I thought they had dropped something important plotwise.

 

[B.K.]

That's a really stupid cut to make.

Meh, while a nice fight (and propably awesome while animated), it isn't exactly necessary for plot advancement. The way someone acted, I thought they had dropped something important plotwise.

It is important plotwise.

Spoiler

That fight was the fist time in the manga that you hear from Pride.

 

[GaimeGuy]

That's a really stupid cut to make.



It is important plotwise.

Spoiler

That fight was the fist time in the manga that you hear from Pride.

It's also the first time we learn that (spoilers)

Spoiler

the people from Xing can sense out the Homunculi specifically from their Ki... this plays a big role in setting up the next events

 

[Tacitus_]

Oh yeah. My memory seems to be extra cruddy this evening.

Spoiler

I forgot that they learned about the sensing before Lings fight with Wrath, which, in hindsight, is fucking stupid from me

 

[B.K.]

Don't feel bad. I had to reread that chapter of the manga. I didn't even remember that fight. It's been too long since I read that part of the manga.

 

[duckroll]

I think it's a lot more than a "nice fight" myself. There are several other things besides what was already mentioned that made the fight pretty important imo.

Spoiler

- It's the first time you actually see Envy getting desperate and annoyed at the fact that he's been outgunned and outwitted, and his reaction to it. This is important character development for his character, because he doesn't really have much scene time in the series compared to other characters.

- It's important development for the Xing crew, because it's the first time you see Lan Fang and Ling working together well, and also the first time you see Ling actually fight with a sword. This builds up the audience's expectations of his character's fighting skills for his later clash with Wrath, because up until now he's been shown as a rather weak character.

- It shows that Ling and Lan Fang together can easily match Envy AND Gluttony, which is the ONLY reason the plan to draw out the other Homunculi would make sense to begin with. Otherwise, without a good idea of what they're up against, it would be really foolish for Ed and Al to even agree to drawing out Scar AND the Homunculi, especially if they don't know if together they can handle all their opponents.

 

[Auron_Kale]

Saw the raw during the stream then saw it again. Still loved the episode, despite the removal of the Xing crew. The one fight I wanted to see - Roy v. Lust - was absolutely amazing. Pretty much nailed the scenes panel for panel.

Now waiting for the subs.

 

[GaimeGuy]

Yep. Mustang is awesome and awesome is mustang.

 

[Plywood]

post

So from the sound of it, this isn't as close to the manga as it should be.

 

[GaimeGuy]

So from the sound of it, this isn't as close to the manga as it should be.

It's basically Full Metal Alchemist Abridged, to be honest. 52 episodes just isn't enough to cover the whole series of events faithfully.

 

[Lafiel]

So from the sound of it, this isn't as close to the manga as it should be.

Bones is to blame for being lazy mfers, they cant make a series last for more then 52 episodes!

 

[GaimeGuy]

Bones is to blame for being lazy mfers, they cant make a series last for more then 52 episodes!

That's really not their call to make. That's more the territory of Aniplex, MBS and Square Enix (the guys footing the bill for the anime) than it is Bones.

 

[duckroll]

I'll like to point out, there's nothing indicating it's actually 52 eps.

 

[Plywood]

I'll like to point out, there's nothing indicating it's actually 52 eps.

On a scale of 1-10 is how faithful is it to the manga?

 

[GaimeGuy]

I'll like to point out, there's nothing indicating it's actually 52 eps.

Animax said they've made a deal to air 51 eps, and the show is going at a pace where they'll be halfway through the manga chapters by episode 25-26.

Everything points to 4 seasons

 

[GaimeGuy]

On a scale of 1-10 is how faithful is it to the manga?

In overall style and feel? 9-9.5/10

In terms of being a 1:1 adaptation? 7.5-8/10

 

[duckroll]

Animax said they've made a deal to air 51 eps, and the show is going at a pace where they'll be halfway through the manga chapters by episode 25-26.

Everything points to 4 seasons

And yet MTV in Germany, who signed the deal later on, says it's 62 episodes.

 

[GaimeGuy]

And yet MTV in Germany, who signed the deal later on, says it's 62 episodes.

First I've heard of it o.o

 

[duckroll]

First I've heard of it o.o

Sorry, my bad. It was a German anime magazine which said it was 63 episodes long. MTV Italy said it would 65 episodes long when they announced it later on. So we have 51, 63 and 65 as "possible" episode numbers.

 

[Jangaroo]

Sorry, my bad. It was a German anime magazine which said it was 63 episodes long. MTV Italy said it would 65 episodes long when they announced it later on. So we have 51, 63 and 65 as "possible" episode numbers.

It'd be nice to see 65 episodes.