How is this Troy Ave verse alright yet Cilvia Demo has maximum three good songs?
Troy Ave has more charisma in that verse than all of the shitty songs on Cilvia Demo combined.
We've already talked way too much about Cilvia Demo, and I pretty much say the same exact thing every time it gets brought up, but it really is unremarkable. That's the perfect word for it,
unremarkable. At it's height, it's okay. Yeah he has a decent ear for production (I wouldn't say good) but he chose so many similar sounding beats that it becomes solely a background music album for me. As an MC, he doesn't seem to bring enough novelty to the table to elevate those beats to something great as a song, it could be anyone else mumbling over those beats for me, except for those 2-3 songs
maximum that have some more memorable flows that give me the full package (RIP Kevin Miller & Cilvia Demo are my two). In addition to his mic presence, his character as an artist is lacking identity. If a no-name MC hit me up on the street in 2006 and told me to check out his tape, I would expect it to sound
exactly like Cilvia Demo.
Altogether, the question "why should I care about Isaiah Rashad?" is really hard to answer right now. And him being signed by Top is 10x a better answer than his actual output right now, and I'm not giving him a pass because Top signed him.
RE: It being the first thing anyone has heard for him, maybe it's a good thing. And if it really is his first project, maybe we're judging him unfairly. I get the feeling both him and SZA (who is like, the most unremarkable new talent to hit the industry of recent) were signed on a promise of something better in the future, maybe even foreshadowed by the name of Isaiah's first release, and will undergo actual artist development which post-Dipset seemingly doesn't exist in the industry anymore. And I respect that, but I'm not sure it would have done him enough good if he wasn't being backed by the juggernaut that is TDE/Interscope.