Alright, finally able to sit behind a PC and start my note document. Here are my thoughts on some subjects:
Swamped
I actually want to thank swamped for her weird post. The post was a bit weird, immediately jumping to protect Star, mentioning to back off of Sawneeks and scrafty, but it didn't read as a scum post to me, I doubt scum would already make such an notable post during day 1, calling out specific persons for no real reason. Also, on purpose or not, the post did got people talking and discussing things, before it was mostly just fluff and people trowing out votes randomly, and getting people to talk is very pro town, that's the way we will find scum. So unless something else happens, I am not feeling a swamped lynch today.
Squidyj and sorian
These two have been by far the most aggressive this game. Squidyj immediately jumped on the Swamped train after her weird post, which I found a little weird, almost like he wanted to start a bandwagon for her. Sorian on the other hand did something similar with Squidyj, and went heavily against him, maybe hoping to sway the town opinion against squidyj? I think there is 1 scum between those two, but figuring out who it is, is going to be hard. The way I am now looking at it, I think Sorians arguments are better and I get more of a town feel from him compared to Squidyj. Also, there is this:
you don't have to listen to my read on Star, I presented her as my top town and said "she's clear" because I got a good feeling off of her first post. and I continue to feel good about her subsequent posts, but that's me, I'm not making an argument that nobody should vote her or come forward with accusations against her.
.
When I read this, I seriously thought I missed some posts of Star. I looked back at her posts, but nope, they didn't told me jack shit about her. I am REALLY surprised Squidyj got any kind of feeling from those posts, because I sure as hell couldn't. I really want Squidyj to explain why he got good feelings about those posts of Star.
Ourobolols
He hasn't said a lot of concrete stuff yet, it is mostly fluff and jokes. But he was wrapping up his election game, so I am willing to give him some more time to chime in. For now, I would feel a bit uncomfortable to try to lynch him.
Rats off to Ya
I got a bad feeling about Rats. Can't really explain it, but this post just made me a bit suspicious:
I agree, squidy's been acting weird. I think there are some logical explanations for that, but I don't feel "squidy is scum" is one of them. Not right now, anyway.
I don't have much else to say right now. Well, I do, but nothing I'd like to say in public at this juncture. Playing solo is rough.
I'll continue to hang back until I see something worth commenting on. I'll vote for someone by day's end, but now is not the time.
"I think squidyj is weird but I don't think he is scum because of reasons."
"I don't have anything to say right now even though things have happened in the thread"
"I will wait with voting until we are closer to the end of the day!"
I get the feeling Rats is just staying at the sidelines, looking at what happens in the thread and making sure he keeps as much options open as possible for him, so in the end he can jump on whatever train is most beneficial for him and not raise to much suspicion. Later he did gave some more opinions on stuff, but it was always closed by "but it is day 1 so things are murky, I am not sure". I mean, he is not wrong, but it didn't help with my suspicious feeling about him. I have nothing concrete (duh, it is day 1), but I am keeping an eye on him.