Nin, are you telling the truth about your role?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Gafia 2: The Bride of Gafia |Mafia OT| One Wedding, Many Funerals
- Thread starter RetroMG
- Start date
Nin, are you telling the truth about your role?
If I were that weird Ninja I should have messed up the results with Camjo as well unless I didn't move for some reason.
I think it's more likely some sort of blocker is affecting Nin. Was the flavor clear on that you saw nothing, Nin?
I mean it would make only you undetectable, the alert would have come from Camjo. If bothey you and him were concealed, Camjo could have claimed to have moved which would have blown your supposed cover.
Ah, I see. I thought you meant a passive blocker when using an ability.
Nah. Just a plain old ninja whose moves can't be seen.
Still, you wouldn't have claimed to have received a drink then. Hm.
i am , you can lynch me if you want to be sure.
Ty strikes me as someone that thinks through his posts - I don't think he had a reason to hide the fact that he got a drink.
I've been suspicious of nin for a long time (yes, Burb, I know), but has he actually revealed anything before? That wasn't common knowledge? Either nobody has moved or the one who moved was killed. The one time he did something different was Camjo-Z, but that was after he had been moved into the gossip chat and then claimed.
Well something has to have happened, right? There is a contradiction right now in the information present.
Oh, right. Forgot about that. Hm.
Hiding results would imply that the MD is protecting someone. But why would town MD protect anyone? Scum MD could try to protect scum teammates.
But on the other hand, lying at this spot, especially since Ty4on had claimed about receiving the drink before nin came foward, seems odd. It doesn't add up there either.
Right, it doesn't add up. But he wasn't exactly forthcoming yesterday either.
Italics mine:
Exactly. Why should that hide Ouro's action on me?
My idea was that it would also hide any power targeting you. It's a long shot, but it would be possible explanation that wouldn't involve Ouro or nin lying. Still like I said, I think it's not possible since you claimed to have received the drink, as scum you would have said that you didn't receive anything due to some mysterious force.
And what's the point of a power like that? I can maybe see a purpose to create a false narrative, but it is bound to either break apart when people flip or just make me stick out like now.
I don't even know anymore.
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
Okay, I think I am lost, what is the contradiction here?
This isn't making much sense to me. To me, either Ty4on or Nin is lying, or something, or fuck, I don't know, but their stories conflict. I know who I gave my drinks to, and Ty4on chimed in before nin, which leads me to believe Ty over Nin.
What the reasoning behind either's motives are...I haven't got a goddamn clue.
What the reasoning behind either's motives are...I haven't got a goddamn clue.
Nin claimed there was no movement, but Ty4on got a drink (as did Nin).
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
Thank you.
I guess it could work on giving the ninja more space to work on, like if they were sitting next to MD with an ordinary, there wouldn't be an alert.
But like I said, it's a long shot. More likely is that someone is lying, or there is outside interference.
And Nin was next to Ty4on and CzarTim.
Why are you so adamant against the possibility of a ninja?
What do you think happened?
As for my stance right now:
VOTE: Timeaisis
Still the same. Although now I'm less sure that the scum RB needs to target only on their own table, since Roy was one of the possibile Scum RB's. Killing him to make the possible RB's would be foolish. Scum JOAT could still be a possibility.
VOTE: Timeaisis
Still the same. Although now I'm less sure that the scum RB needs to target only on their own table, since Roy was one of the possibile Scum RB's. Killing him to make the possible RB's would be foolish. Scum JOAT could still be a possibility.
Burb brought it up. He sure wants it to be true.
Ugggh, this is a pain in the ass.
Ok, I want to simplify this a bit and mention something that's been bothering me. Both our trackers are still alive and it seems to me that scum is using them to their advantage, I think that if we look back at all the claims and the actions of all the days we can actually go back and see where we went wrong and pinpoint who is lying.
Also, I am going to say this now, we have way too many ordinary claims, I think we should lynch one of them.
But also this is the same reason why I think its weird scum decided to off an ordinary claim. I think they are trying to find a certain role that is messing with them. Right now the trackers control almost half the table.
Ok, I want to simplify this a bit and mention something that's been bothering me. Both our trackers are still alive and it seems to me that scum is using them to their advantage, I think that if we look back at all the claims and the actions of all the days we can actually go back and see where we went wrong and pinpoint who is lying.
Also, I am going to say this now, we have way too many ordinary claims, I think we should lynch one of them.
But also this is the same reason why I think its weird scum decided to off an ordinary claim. I think they are trying to find a certain role that is messing with them. Right now the trackers control almost half the table.
we can solve this problem by getting rid of the trackers
i agree and i support this idea
this has been an issue aswell, i witheld the information yesterday to see how town would react without any info from my side.
He just said Seath soft claimed which I assume was from the post I linked to.
Can you link to it? I can't find it.
Here. It doesn't sound like soft claiming ordinary to me, since he is assuming "unintended consequrnces" which sounds like additional information.
hmm, sounds like a bunch of bullshit to me.
Mostly because he used similar wording as me =P.
All right, here we go
Dead Players:
Town
Gryvan ordinary
Kingkitty ordinary
BananaSpacePrincess ordinary
roytheone ordinary
ScraftyDevil cop
LaunchpadMcQ jailor
Xamtheking shuffler
scum
Weemadarthur godfather
Kalor disabler
neutral
Camjo-Z arsonist
Alive players
a Seath unintended consequences
b Ourobolus drink giver
c Salvapot Royal_Flush
d nin1000 Motion detector
e burbeting even commuter
f terrabyte20xx Motion detector
g fireblend ???
h czartim ordinary
i ty4on ordinary
j timeasis ordinary
k absolutbro ordinary
That is a grand total of 8 ordinary players out of 22. I call shenanigans.
Dead Players:
Town
Gryvan ordinary
Kingkitty ordinary
BananaSpacePrincess ordinary
roytheone ordinary
ScraftyDevil cop
LaunchpadMcQ jailor
Xamtheking shuffler
scum
Weemadarthur godfather
Kalor disabler
neutral
Camjo-Z arsonist
Alive players
a Seath unintended consequences
b Ourobolus drink giver
c Salvapot Royal_Flush
d nin1000 Motion detector
e burbeting even commuter
f terrabyte20xx Motion detector
g fireblend ???
h czartim ordinary
i ty4on ordinary
j timeasis ordinary
k absolutbro ordinary
That is a grand total of 8 ordinary players out of 22. I call shenanigans.
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
I'm almost tempted to suggest we mass claim at this point.
But then you take into account there is two motion detectors, and at least 1 scum, maybe 2 scum left and a roleblocker in the loose and you kind of have to consider there has to be someone lying there.
The motion detectors are there to balance the game, so it would make sense that there has to be a good amount of PR's that actually move, and we have 3 confirmed passive abilities.