Game journalists think Little Mac is OP in Smash, publish actual articles about it

knowing how to deal with lil mac would mean actually dedicating time to fighting games.

do game "journalists" have the dedication/time for that? this be some basic shit
 
I don't think Little Mac is only good on FD. Battlefield gives him some platforms to avoid some projectiles heavy characters, and gives him a non linear approach (just jump then shield though since his aerials suck). As long as he hangs out primarily at the bottom and avoids the edges, he's still rather viable.

Never forget Team ASS going on an absurd streak until Marn came through and put us on to the early peak of Marvel 3's end game with Zero. :lol
Sadly. I was so hype for Arthur too and then that match and the upcoming months showed me otherwise lol. Oh well.
 
Yeeeeeeeeeeeeeup.

Its always the first reaction to anything decently strong.

Gotta' give a game at least a few months and some consistent tourney results for the actual bullshit to show itself. :-p

Exactly. People get their ass kicked in a fighter earlier on, scream OP and ask for nerfs. Hopefully Sakurai ignores the earlier pleas, and allows the game to actually mature a bit before we start sending patches out.
 
The noob Little Macs will weed themselves out over time. Mac has pretty obvious counterplay, but people are trying to go toe-to-toe with him and losing.
 
Well when you play on a stage with little arial game like the Omegas I could see it. Add some platforms and his drawbacks are hugely apparent.
 
At least Kotaku ranked each fighter in an article: http://kotaku.com/super-smash-bros-3ds-characters-ranked-1643390632

It's a joke article.

It's a joke site

I can remember one or two Little Macs kicking the shit out of me online, but I have bested at least as many. It seems like a lot of people are picking him because they hear he's good, but don't know how to use him. I'm not a great player by any means, but I've played at least 100 online matches, and Little Mac hasn't been any more common than other popular fighters.
 
Maybe people, you know, just like his character and want to play him? He's the coolest newcomer for a lot of people (including me) so it makes sense that he's very popular online. Seeing as a lot of posters here are saying he's not OP then I don't think that many people would be choosing him for that reason...
 
"Man, lots of people sure use Ken, better make an article about it"
knowing how to deal with lil mac would mean actually dedicating time to fighting games.

do game "journalists" have the dedication/time for that? this be some basic shit
He's completely balanced.

This is some Sentinel day one MVC3 shit.

BOOM

I mean holy shit. It took me a small handful of matches to acclimate myself to playing against Little Mac. He's a casual friendly character with a lot of power but he can be approached and gimped pretty easily. Not to mention most people online play predictably as FUCK with Little Mac. Counterpicking Dedede or Shulk has literally not failed me once since I started playing this game online, even against some better Little Macs.
 
Games journalism everyone.
Anecdotal evidence. I played about 10 matches yesterday. Only 2 of them had a lil' Mac each and i beat both games with Lucina.
I wouldn't call Mac OP.
 
otEnad2.jpg

lol

Mac is awesome I won't deny it but everyone is using him so we'll have tons of practice against him. :p
 
Never forget Team ASS going on an absurd streak until Marn came through and put us on to the early peak of Marvel 3's end game with Zero. :lol

OMG I forgot about this :lol

Smash 4 doesn't need any rebalancing until at LEAST a year in. Smash Wii U isn't even out yet!

I think we are going to see a lot of casual players toy with For Glory mode, which is going to be their first exposure to "competitive" Smash. Projectiles will be spammed and they will be camped out. Off to Twitter they go, complaining that X character is broken or OP because they couldn't get a hit in.
 
FUCK little mac

I honestly feel like the people who are saying "He's not THAAT bad" are just being contrarian.

He's THAT bad.
 
FUCK little mac

I honestly feel like the people who are saying "He's not THAAT bad" are just being contrarian.

He's THAT bad.

Who do you play as? With Shulk I just play defensively for a while, use my Smashes or jump>nair when I think Mac will approach and above 40 I go for gimps with Jump and Smash. It's easy to knock him off the stage and follow up with a hit, Jump in particular is amazing for this. With Dedede it's piss easy to stomp Mac because his crouch roll is quick and just breezes through most of dudes approach options, and a lotta Mac players second guess themselves and start to play bad once you start throwing Gordos in the mix. You just gotta adjust your playstyle, he's really not like fighting other characters but that doesn't have to be a problem
 
Even little things like disabling the Flying Man in Magicant would go a long way.

Sakurai said:
You will still be able to control the apparition of items, but you won't be able to turn off stage hazards. If we did that, you'd find yourself with PSASB!
This is the one remaining thing that Sakurai needs to get his head out his arse on. So many stages in this game are utterly ruined by their hazards and its not just competitive players saying that this time.
 
I actually think he's fairly balanced for Omega stages. He needs a lot of room to work efficiently, and his air play isn't that good. If you can space yourself, Little Mac isn't that harder to manage with than other fighters. Basically:

8l6TLeB.png


Of course, what he misses with his awful recovery, he gains with his agile groundplay and his powerful smash attacks. I can certainly see him being a little overpowered in his home stage, for instance.

Good analysis.

I think they did a really good job with designing Little Mac's moveset to reflect his background as a boxer as well as the theme of Punch-Out as a whole -- Distance and timing. It's absolutely imperative to control spacing and manipulate your opponent's movement to the areas you have the advantage (i.e -- keep the fight on the ground and away from the edges). Also many of his moves allow you to control the timing of the actual strike with delays and charges, which again reflect what 90% of the Punch-Out game actually is.
 
Even if he was overpowered (which I'm still undecided about), I don't think the solution is hitting everything with a nerf bat. Other characters should be receiving significant buffs - the game has enough weak hits and non-viable killing moves as it is.
 
SFIV Ken issue you mean everyone online using him and not the OP part right?

Both. I don't own this game, full disclosure. But this thread has taught me that he's NOT OP but does happen to be chosen somewhat frequently. SFIV had the issue of Kens everywhere but were generally just wake up shoryukens, easy to deal with. Little Macs look like they're similarly easy to deal with.
 
FUCK little mac

I honestly feel like the people who are saying "He's not THAAT bad" are just being contrarian.

He's THAT bad.

You can go on youtube and see some pros beat Little Mac. He's a tough fighter for sure, but he has weaknesses, especially because it seems like a lot of people playing as Little Mac online aren't actually playing to his strengths but rather just relying on his knockout power.

Someone like Duck Hunt Dog, for example, or Rosalina even would have a field day with Little Mac. Keep your distance, zone and pressure, hit him in the air, and bait/force Little Mac to the edge and make your opponent gamble on big hits.
 
You can go on youtube and see some pros beat Little Mac. He's a tough fighter for sure, but he has weaknesses, especially because it seems like a lot of people playing as Little Mac online aren't actually playing to his strengths but rather just relying on his knockout power.

Someone like Duck Hunt Dog, for example, or Rosalina even would have a field day with Little Mac. Keep your distance, zone and pressure, hit him in the air, and bait/force Little Mac to the edge and make your opponent gamble on big hits.

I disagree that Rosalina would have a field day with Mac, with Mac's large knockback on tons of moves, Luma is easily gimped.
 
I disagree that Rosalina would have a field day with Mac, with Mac's large knockback on tons of moves, Luma is easily gimped.

Maybe but I've seen some really good Rosalina's use the Luma and long range attacks to really confound fighters who need to get up close to deal damage. I don't use Rosalina but I think her ability to pepper Little Mac would force an opponent to either roll to the edge or roll in for easy grabs and throws. I saw an amazing Rosalina grab, throw, and up B(?) combo that led to some impressive air juggling of an opponent.
 
If you're fighting Little Mac like you're in an episode of Fist of the North Star and trading blows back and forth, of course you're going to lose. He's fucking Little Mac.

You have that jump button for a reason!
 
With the extensive amount of time this game has been out, how can anyone disagree?

Anyway, Little Mac is awesome. Make more Punch-Out!! games, kthx.
 
He's good, but far from OP. Journalists are just confirmed casuals.

That being said, some ATs have been discovered that might bump him up...a lot.
 
Everyone wrote off Mac as garbage the first week of the JPN release.

I've played online with every character and recorded my data in the Smash OT. I saw Mac four times. He tied with DK for the most appearances. This was before the US release though.
 
Top Bottom