• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Game of Thrones *NO BOOK SPOILERS* |OT| Season 3 - Sundays on HBO [Read the OP]

Status
Not open for further replies.

Chuckie

Member
how big is this show with women?

I know I tried to get my Girlfriend to watch the show with me, but after a couple of episodes she kind of quickly got tired of the blood and how women were depicted in this series. Naked and almost all of them prostitutes.

My wife loves it although she had a real hard time with people dying in S01 (not the fact that it was violent, but because she became emotionally attached to them)
 
I didn't know anyone who would know my username wouldn't know that.


My girlfriends debate over who's better looking, Robb or Jon (how can anyone believe Jon is better?) and my aunt and father's gf loved Khal Drogo and Jaime.

Can't wait to show them this episode.

everyone knows that Jamie lannister is the hot one.
then again how should I know, I like girls!

The hot one is Rob starks new wife, and maybe some random naked hooker we have seen in some previous episodes.
 

Chuckie

Member
everyone knows that Jamie lannister is the hot one.
then again how should I know, I like girls!

The hot one is Rob starks new wife, and maybe some random naked hooker we have seen in some previous episodes.

I really liked Dany's handmaiden

tumblr_mdpgcelcVr1qi722ho7_r1_500.png
 
Your taste for Stoya totally threw me off.

Not judging, tho.
That's called good taste.

everyone knows that Jamie lannister is the hot one.
then again how should I know, I like girls!

The hot one is Rob starks new wife, and maybe some random naked hooker we have seen in some previous episodes.

Order (in girls) is Ygritte > Talisa > Doreah (the handmaiden) > Daenerys (who looks so much better as a brunette).

It is known.
 

Chuckie

Member
That's called good taste.



Order (in girls) is Ygritte > Talisa > Doreah (the handmaiden) > Daenerys (who looks so much better as a brunette).

It is known.

Mmmm.... usually I agree with your taste, but it seems this time we differ

Doreah > New slave girl > Talisa > Daenerys > Ygritte
 
I consider her quite low on the pecking order as far as GoT actresses go. Or rather, the actress looks much better in real life than she does done up as Daenerys (P.S. I had to look up the fucking spelling just then because it's so retarded).

I just googled some pictures of her; the ones I found had her wearing so much makeup that she looked weird. As weird as it sounds, she looks more real in the show than in real life.
 
Mmmm.... usually I agree with your taste, but it seems this time we differ

Doreah > New slave girl > Talisa > Daenerys > Ygritte
You know nothing.

I was just including the characters others have as well as my personal top.

I haven't watched enough to place Missandrei yet. I'm watching it as they release here, so tonight I'll be watching Episode 2.
 

J-Rod

Member
The 4 whores and follow up scene was so damn cheesey. Tyrion and Bronn regulated to being gossipy hens for comedic relief.

Dany's plan seems a little bit too obvious. The only thing I thought was weird is why would she mention she has 3 dragons when bartering? I'm surprised slaver dude settled for just one knowing that.

Stannis seems like a punk these days. Hard to root for him as king when he's crying about people laughing at him and being a simp to the fire lady while even she is shrugging him off.

Was Jamie telling the truth about Tarth coming from money? I know it was to save her, but am curious if any I it was true.
 

Vashetti

Banned
I was walking home earlier and got to thinking about the latest episode again and thought it was strange that (as far as I'm aware) no mention was made whatsoever of the attempt on Dany's life by the Warlock in Season 3, episode 1.

Seems like something they would talk about, no?
 

TCRS

Banned
HOW COME NOBODY IS TALKING ABOUT THE BIZARRE CREDITS MUSIC

cross posting from the book thread (deleted all spoilers):

TCRS said:
OH MY FUCKING GOD!!! WHO WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR THAT FUCKING SONG IN THE END?? I WANT TO KILL HIM!!!!!!! SUCH A DRAMATIC END AND THEN THIS SHIT!!

what in the seven hells were they thinking? I can't believe this. Someone has to be fired over this shit. oh my dayyyyyyyyyyss... totally destroyed that feeling and the atmosphere at the end. shock gone in 0.1 seconds.
 

Kilrogg

paid requisite penance
I consider her quite low on the pecking order as far as GoT actresses go. Or rather, the actress looks much better in real life than she does done up as Daenerys (P.S. I had to look up the fucking spelling just then because it's so retarded).


I'm probably in the minority, but it's the other way around for me: Emilia Clarke's make-up, hair and clothes as Daenerys make her much hotter than she is. Emilia has a big forehead, and that's less visible on Daenerys. Plus I like her more as a blonde/white-haired girl than as a brunette. Not to say that Emilia Clarke is ugly thoughn who would think that? I just find her more attractive as Daenerys.
 
I feel dumb. I can't figure out what is going on this season.

The people who have Jaimie and had Theon are of the same house? They were also the ones surrounding Winterfell at the end of S2? Leader of Jaimie's captors is the son of Robb's advisor who was always interrupted by his wife and gave dirty looks?

And was the grandfather's death just randomly brought up to explain where they were heading or did I miss a raven message?

Maybe because I'm not watching them back to back is throwing me off.
 
how big is this show with women?

I know I tried to get my Girlfriend to watch the show with me, but after a couple of episodes she kind of quickly got tired of the blood and how women were depicted in this series. Naked and almost all of them prostitutes.

Popping into this thread just to say that I am also obsessed with the show.
 

Kai Dracon

Writing a dinosaur space opera symphony
I loved the end credits music / rock cover. To me it was the perfect way to punctuate the insanity of the final moment.

I realize some people don't like anything anachronistic in their fiction and fantasy, and that's fair. But I'm down with something funky and unexpected as was done here.

Edit:

It reminds me of the use of "We Will Rock You" in the jousting tournament in A Knight's Tale. The out of time music was used to get across an attitude to the viewer that some stereotypical (to modern audiences) fantasy flute tunes wouldn't. To the people in that time period, such an event was a rock concert - bawdy, rude, exciting, and heart pumping. The surreal use of a rock song for the scene got across the attitude.

Same deal here. What happens to a major character at the end of this episode, is a shocking reminder that the rules can't be taken for granted in this series, as with the end of season 1. A rock cover of an in-universe bard's song worked really well IMO to enhance the viewer being thrown off balance.
 

xenist

Member
how big is this show with women?

I know I tried to get my Girlfriend to watch the show with me, but after a couple of episodes she kind of quickly got tired of the blood and how women were depicted in this series. Naked and almost all of them prostitutes.

No girlfriend right now but both my sister and my sister-in-law love it.
 
I loved the end credits music / rock cover. To me it was the perfect way to punctuate the insanity of the final moment.

I realize some people don't like anything anachronistic in their fiction and fantasy, and that's fair. But I'm down with something funky and unexpected as was done here.

Edit:

It reminds me of the use of "We Will Rock You" in the jousting tournament in A Knight's Tale. The out of time music was used to get across an attitude to the viewer that some stereotypical (to modern audiences) fantasy flute tunes wouldn't. To the people in that time period, such an event was a rock concert - bawdy, rude, exciting, and heart pumping. The surreal use of a rock song for the scene got across the attitude.

Same deal here. What happens to a major character at the end of this episode, is a shocking reminder that the rules can't be taken for granted in this series, as with the end of season 1. A rock cover of an in-universe bard's song worked really well IMO to enhance the viewer being thrown off balance.

agreed. the song choice was great.
 

Raiden

Banned
that fight felt stiff as fuck. i don't like how they have so much money for set design apparently but they can't afford a decent fight choreographer (and if he is decent then i don't know why he's so crap for this series)

whenever this show has a duel it just feels like a few lumbering oafs and there's no grace or spectacle to it. thankfully the action scenes are few and far between.

I honestly loved the way they handled that, it felt very real, switching stances and carefully planting swings. Those are massive two handers you cant swing that stuff around like a ninja.

Edit; I want someone to minor spoiler me because its bumming me out =>
So they chopped of Jamie's hand, all i want to know is can i expect some Jamie fighting in the future or he is completely incapacitated?
 

lmpaler

Member
Well...

"McKidd and I had lunch the other day, and I said to him, "Have you been asked to do Game Of Thrones?" And he said, "I'd never do it. Because they stole our fucking show." He worked out that if Rome had run for the entire seven seasons that it should have run, we would only have finished it last year. And he feels that HBO did Game of Thrones instead of us, so they stole our show. I kind of agree with him. I won't be doing Game Of Thrones, even if they ask me."

http://thewertzone.blogspot.de/2013/01/james-purefoy-and-kevin-mckidd-rule-out.html

AC/DC said it best
 

Trojita

Rapid Response Threadmaker
I honestly loved the way they handled that, it felt very real, switching stances and carefully planting swings. Those are massive two handers you cant swing that stuff around like a ninja.

Edit; I want someone to minor spoiler me because its bumming me out =>
So they chopped of Jamie's hand, all i want to know is can i expect some Jamie fighting in the future or he is completely incapacitated?

Do you really want to know? I can send you a PM.
 

Brashnir

Member
I feel dumb. I can't figure out what is going on this season.

The people who have Jaimie and had Theon are of the same house? They were also the ones surrounding Winterfell at the end of S2? Leader of Jaimie's captors is the son of Robb's advisor who was always interrupted by his wife and gave dirty looks?

The people who captured Jamie/Brienne are flying Bolton banners. They were a scouting party sent off from the main army in the riverlands. The leader of these guys - Locke - his relation (or lack thereof) to Roose or any of the other Boltons is unknown. He might be a relative or just an officer in the army.

The Boltons also surrounded Winterfell at the end of Season 2. This was a different force - basically the garrison left at the Bolton's home known as the Dreadfort, which isn't very far from Winterfell. Roose Bolton's (Robb's advisor) bastard son Ramsay was heading the garrison, and Roose sent word to him to recapture Winterfell from the Greyjoys.

I don't think the identity of Theon's captors has formally revealed on the show, but the contraption Theon was on is part of the sigil of House Bolton, and given the circumstances of his capture, it's a safe assumption that it's Ramsay's contingent.

And was the grandfather's death just randomly brought up to explain where they were heading or did I miss a raven message?

Maybe because I'm not watching them back to back is throwing me off.

They actually doubled back from Harrenhal - which is a ways east of Riverrun in the riverlands - to Riverrun due to the death of Lord Tully. Lord Karstark (the guy with the white hair and beard) was complaining during the march that it was pulling them away from the war campaign.
 

Trojita

Rapid Response Threadmaker
The people who captured Jamie/Brienne are flying Bolton banners. They were a scouting party sent off from the main army in the riverlands. The leader of these guys - Locke - his relation (or lack thereof) to Roose or any of the other Boltons is unknown. He might be a relative or just an officer in the army.

The Boltons also surrounded Winterfell at the end of Season 2. This was a different force - basically the garrison left at the Bolton's home known as the Dreadfort, which isn't very far from Winterfell. Roose Bolton's (Robb's advisor) bastard son Ramsay was heading the garrison, and Roose sent word to him to recapture Winterfell from the Greyjoys.

I don't think the identity of Theon's captors has formally revealed on the show, but the contraption Theon was on is part of the sigil of House Bolton, and given the circumstances of his capture, it's a safe assumption that it's Ramsay's contingent.



They actually doubled back from Harrenhal - which is a ways east of Riverrun in the riverlands - to Riverrun due to the death of Lord Tully. Lord Karstark (the guy with the white hair and beard) was complaining during the march that it was pulling them away from the war campaign.

The sigil of House Bolton is a flayed man. I'm guessing you might have read the book and are explaining stuff for the people here?
 
Eh... put me in the "Emilia Clarke looks much better as a brunette" camp.

vQ2oA0a.jpg



Or maybe it's because I generally prefer brunettes / not this extreme whitish blond hair.
 

Brashnir

Member
The sigil of House Bolton is a flayed man. I'm guessing you might have read the book and are explaining stuff for the people here?

It's a flayed man on a St. Andrew's Cross, as evidenced in the show by both the banners and the sigil worn on Roose Bolton's chest.

yazvSsS.jpg
 

Raiden

Banned
Do you really want to know? I can send you a PM.

I'm good thanks, Captain_Spanky helped me out.


Honestly, think i'll just try waiting for all episodes to air because 1 episode each week just gets me out of the moment and waiting with this show is extra annoying.
 
The people who captured Jamie/Brienne are flying Bolton banners. They were a scouting party sent off from the main army in the riverlands. The leader of these guys - Locke - his relation (or lack thereof) to Roose or any of the other Boltons is unknown. He might be a relative or just an officer in the army.

The Boltons also surrounded Winterfell at the end of Season 2. This was a different force - basically the garrison left at the Bolton's home known as the Dreadfort, which isn't very far from Winterfell. Roose Bolton's (Robb's advisor) bastard son Ramsay was heading the garrison, and Roose sent word to him to recapture Winterfell from the Greyjoys.

I don't think the identity of Theon's captors has formally revealed on the show, but the contraption Theon was on is part of the sigil of House Bolton, and given the circumstances of his capture, it's a safe assumption that it's Ramsay's contingent.



They actually doubled back from Harrenhal - which is a ways east of Riverrun in the riverlands - to Riverrun due to the death of Lord Tully. Lord Karstark (the guy with the white hair and beard) was complaining during the march that it was pulling them away from the war campaign.

Thanks. I think I got lost as to why they were at Harrenhal (the mountain?), and I don't remember any scene stating why they left until they mentioned that it's out of the way and how "the death of my grandfather isn't blablabla". When I saw that I thought "When did his grandfather die why are we finding out on the road?". I may have been distracted and missed a key scene there.

As for the Boltons, I think my confusion is coming from the discussion and relationship and possible spoiler territory in this thread as if I should know and not from my own viewing where I should be asking questions because it is supposed to be a mystery for now.


I'm good thanks, Captain_Spanky helped me out.


Honestly, think i'll just try waiting for all episodes to air because 1 episode each week just gets me out of the moment and waiting with this show is extra annoying.
Exactly. My wife and I have just gotten into Twin Peaks and we were torn which to watch last night, that or GoT. We may just catch up on TP and other shows until Thrones is over.
 
HOW COME NOBODY IS TALKING ABOUT THE BIZARRE CREDITS MUSIC

You mean how awesome it was? I already posted about it. I'm glad they had the balls to take it in such a great direction. The Hold Steady is a perfect choice for the kind of dirty, bar-folk song the Bear and the Maiden Fair is. The dissonance of its placement was choice.

The same exact song was sung earlier in the episode, by the same exact people that did such a horrifying act. It was a great circle back and provided the perfect contrast.
 

Magnus

Member
You mean how awesome it was? I already posted about it. I'm glad they had the balls to take it in such a great direction. The Hold Steady is a perfect choice for the kind of dirty, bar-folk song the Bear and the Maiden Fair is. The dissonance of its placement was choice.

The same exact song was sung earlier in the episode, by the same exact people that did such a horrifying act. It was a great circle back and provided the perfect contrast.

Loved it for all the same reasons. Turned Jaime's little tragedy into something of a comedy at the same time!
 

woodchuck

Member
Thanks. I think I got lost as to why they were at Harrenhal (the mountain?), and I don't remember any scene stating why they left until they mentioned that it's out of the way and how "the death of my grandfather isn't blablabla". When I saw that I thought "When did his grandfather die why are we finding out on the road?". I may have been distracted and missed a key scene there.

My mind could be playing tricks on me, but I think they learned the grandfather died in episode 2 in a scene at Harrenhall between Robb and Catlyn
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom