People who are saying Gears: Judgement is more like Gears 1 just don't understand what Made Gears 1, and the Gears after that the franchise that it is.
Gears competitive play has always been about teamwork, fighting over weapons and important areas of every map. The pace always, even in the first Gears, has been a little slower, a little more tactical.
With the exception of Overrun mode, that is all out the window. There's no strategy in TDM now, there is absolutely no teamwork, and cover has been made completely useless with map design that has no business being in a Gears game.
To be honest, I wouldn't care about the changes if Epic (according to GB Epic did the MP dunno if that's accurate or not) would of just included a few maps that were faithful to the old Gears games, with a Gears classic playlist.
The way the game is setup now, I dunno who they are trying to please.