• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Giant Bomb GoTY 2016- Agent 47, take out that Doom Marine

Vinny did good.

On the one hand, I kinda hate that the only reason it got included is because "well, if we look at the reaction to all that stuff, it's clearly incredible." I do like this list to be Giant Bomb's list, not the end-all-be-all list.

On the other hand,
the witcher is fucking incredible and the fact that it doesn't get more love on this site is ridiculous. Especially Blood and Wine.
 
On the one hand, I kinda hate that the only reason it got included is because "well, if we look at the reaction to all that stuff, it's clearly incredible." I do like this list to be Giant Bomb's list, not the end-all-be-all list.

On the other hand,
the witcher is fucking incredible and the fact that it doesn't get more love on this site is ridiculous. Especially Blood and Wine.

Lol yeah their reasoning was.... suspect. But I like the result so I turn a blind eye!
 

Alucrid

Banned
i don't see how SFV is a hotter mess than MM9. i mean, at least you get a good game, a game that has improved since launch and will continue to improve. like, who would stand up for MM9 after the poor game, terrible kickstarter and continued screw ups (like making another kickstarter)?
 

rudds

Name 10 better posters this year
Brad only edits uhms and such out of the podcast, and music in.
They feel as strongly about unedited as we do, I think.

There's more to processing the podcasts (both Bombcast and GOTY) to get them ready for public consumption than that, but yeah, you've got the gist of it. The audio files are raw when they come out of the recorder -- they need to be leveled, have transitions cleaned up, off-air junk like mic checks cut out, ads produced and edited in, etc. etc. Now that we record "live" there's a misconception that I get a finished mp3 right after the show and throw it straight onto the site, but there's way more work to do before it's ready to go live than is probably obvious to the audience. That's what I was talking about with "editing" in that tweet.

In other words, I'm definitely not cutting any content out, it's all housekeeping to make them sound clean and not like a total mess. 100% of what was discussed is in the finished product.
 
Not sure I agree with the hottest mess. That shit could've hurt Occuluss/Palmer more than it actually did.

We haven't seen Palmer since...And that's pretty much the only thing that came out of that.

No Man's Sky on the other hand is probably the most controversial game launch of all time.
 

bigkrev

Member
Legit dissapointed in the discussion on the podcast in hottest mess. When Jeff says
"White Supremecy is the hottest mess", and then Vinny and Brad literally say "I DON'T KNOW" it kind of grossed me out
 

Lunar FC

Member
Legit dissapointed in the discussion on the podcast in hottest mess. When Jeff says
"White Supremecy is the hottest mess", and then Vinny and Brad literally say "I DON'T KNOW" it kind of grossed me out

Dan
ghosted more than Palmer did.
 

War Peaceman

You're a big guy.
There's more to processing the podcasts (both Bombcast and GOTY) to get them ready for public consumption than that, but yeah, you've got the gist of it. The audio files are raw when they come out of the recorder -- they need to be leveled, have transitions cleaned up, off-air junk like mic checks cut out, ads produced and edited in, etc. etc. Now that we record "live" there's a misconception that I get a finished mp3 right after the show and throw it straight onto the site, but there's way more work to do before it's ready to go live than is probably obvious to the audience. That's what I was talking about with "editing" in that tweet.

In other words, I'm definitely not cutting any content out, it's all housekeeping to make them sound clean and not like a total mess. 100% of what was discussed is in the finished product.

Thanks for the information, Brad, and thanks for the great goty content. Have a good new year :)
 

Gurrry

Member
Hottest Mess was sadly well deserved. Alex brought up great points and just listening to the passion he had behind it got me fired up as well. I understand not wanting to mix real life issues with the awards, but this one was so intertwined that its nearly impossible to do that.

But dont worry
No Mans Sky
, you will have your day. Biggest disappointment is ripe for the taking.
 

Lunar FC

Member
Firewatch getting cut from best styyyyyle. Im out.

Idk wtf style is then.

Let It Die is going to win just because it has the most nonsense.
 

FStop7

Banned
Best Style results 🙄🙄🙄

Never let people who wear the same clothes every day talk style.
 
Alex is going IN on this Hottest Mess talk, everyone else seems so apprehensive about talking about it, everyone but Alex is just looking down at their laptops awkwardly.
 
We joke about Alex Navarro folding like a house of cards, but his Hottest Mess advocacy:
qMOKX.gif
 

xuchu

Member
Great start to the GOTY podcasts. Jeff on fire with that Palmer Luckey incident being hottest mess.
Having said that, while I agree with Witcher 3 being old GOTY, the way it got there was weird. Vinny didn't even particularly argue that strongly for it other than 'it's a really good game' and it won more so cos the others didn't really feel like arguing against it or for another game. But that's sorta keeping in with Giantbomb tradition though and I love it.
 

Lunar FC

Member
Great start to the GOTY podcasts. Jeff on fire with that Palmer Luckey incident being hottest mess.
Having said that, while I agree with Witcher 3 being old GOTY, the way it got there was weird. Vinny didn't even particularly argue that strongly for it other than 'it's a really good game' and it won more so cos the others didn't really feel like arguing against it or for another game. But that's sorta keeping in with Giantbomb tradition though and I love it.

The catergory just really didnt need to exist this year.
 
Top Bottom