What's wrong with Persona 5 that it seems like so many people bounced off of it? Just not different enough from P4?
Didn't a ton of people bounce off of P3 and P4 ass? Me included, and I play a ton of jrpgs.
I feel like one of the problems was that P5 became a much more "mainstream" title than P3 and P4, because of the stylish visuals and P4's positive word of mouth/ER.
If you have a ton of people who normally don't play/enjoy jrpgs play one, no matter how stylish it is, many will bounce off of it hard.
As for fans of P3/4 who were disappointed, different strokes for different folks, I guess. Like I said, I personally got bored of P3 and 4 around 12-25 hours in, so I'm hardly what you'd call a persona fan (loved the ER though!), but P5 is one of my favorite games ever.