Thanks for reading the piece guys. I appreciate it.
I don't see how you can make this conclusion given Google's track record. Google is in and out of projects with seemingly few reasons. There was no coherent design language or market positioning between all the products recently released. From stories of Nest being close to failing and who knows how many over lapping messaging apps, internally they seem to be a mess. I'm no tech insider but I don't see how they have a chance of designing and releasing a competitive coherent hardware line never mind a mobile processor.
It is purely because Google has never had a proper hardware division until now, and surely not a true lineup of consumer-facing products all coming from the same place. Again, they said very clearly that they're in it "for the long run", and considering just how much they're spending on advertising and marketing we better believe it (it's also important to note
what kind of marketing strategy they're adopting, which is very interesting).
Nest has been a mess because of Fadell's brouhaha and the fact that they have worked independently — there was absolutely no connection between them and Osterloh's team. The "competitive coherent hardware line" has just started — oh, and the mobile processor
will come.
I think it's the best stock android device on the market by a country mile. But it's still a stock android device. The addition of a few key features, and a more competitive price point, they could have cornered the android market, particularly with the issues Samsung is having.
I'm upgrading this year and I would have been all over this phone if it had water resistance, dual front speakers, expandable memory, image stabilization, IR blaster etc. Unfortunately as it stands, the 7+, V20 or S7 edge are still more attractive options and better values in my opinion. It's a very small part of the market that will gush over a stock android phone, no matter how smooth the experience. But Google is on the right track, and I'm interested to see the next itteration.
It could be a very small part, but the fact remains that none of the devices you mentioned above come that close to being a perfect overall package. The S7 edge, which I used up until ten days ago, was very nearly there, but my time with the Pixel has taught me that it's an overall superior device, despite lacking the few hardware bonuses the edge has.
Namely:
• Water resistance — nice, but far from indispensable; it proved to be actually useful no more than four or five times over a seven months period
• FFS — another nice addition, but if I want to properly listen to music I use my headphones or bluetooth speaker; for anything below that the Pixel's speaker is loud and crisp enough
• I haven't had or used expandable memory in just about forever; there's a freaking 128GB option and unlimited high-res storage for photos and videos even in 4K
• OIS — even without it, the Pixel has the best photo camera on the market, and if shooting video is your thing, you can pretty much rest assured that EIS is absolutely killing it; so yeah, very little to regret there
etc. etc.. The overall Google experience easily trumps all of this stuff in the actual day to day use, and despite being definitely pricey, it still is the very best you can get right now.