• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

GW2 GAFGuild | Community Thread

N

nataku

Member
Ferny said:
Alright so narrowed it down to these names for the guild. My favorite is in bold.

Gentlemen Ask First
Guilds Always Fail
Gaming Age Front
New Elite Order

All will have the tag of (GAF). I'll go ahead and announce the one we're going with on the next podcast. Throw out your opinions before then though so I can see what most of you guys like.
Click to expand...


I really like Guilds Always Fail. It a perfect fit for GAF guilds, lol.
 
R

Retro

Member
Both "Gentlemen ask first" and "Guilds always fail" strike me as too silly. First, they have a very short shelf-life; after a few months the novelty will wear off. Second, other players can see the name and something too silly may give us a less-than-positive reputation. For example, if you saw a guild running around named "Cornholers", you'd probably picture a pack of teenage jackanapes who troll general chat with Chuck Norris jokes.

I would prefer we have something slightly more serious, if at all possible. We'll also have Non-GAFers in the guild, so it has to be something they aren't ashamed to play under.

I also kinda liked the NEO rather than GAF since our tag will be "GAF".

New E____ Order is my favorite, though I don't like "Elite" particularly.

New Eternal Order
New Ebon Order (Ebon meaning "Black")
New Eldritch Order ("unearthly, supernatural, eerie")
New Eristic Order (Eristic "refers to a type of argument where the participants fight and quarrel without any reasonable goal." Sounds like GAF to me.)
New Elonian Order (References Elona, another continent in the GW world and probably a future expansion)

I dunno. Guilds Always Fail strikes me as too much of an in-joke and Gentlemen Ask First is just too silly for my tastes.
 
F

Ferny

Member
Retro said:
I dunno. Guilds Always Fail strikes me as too much of an in-joke and Gentlemen Ask First is just too silly for my tastes.
Click to expand...

It is a GAF guild though. Just because we will have non-gaffers in doesn't mean we have to cater to them. They will want to join because of the people in the guild not because of a name. It being "in-joke" is exactly why it fits so perfectly with the guild. I honestly see it as us having a funny little joke name or going with the NeoGAF name and calling it at that. It doesn't have to be the ones I listed either but it being some that GAF will know easily and be kind of a funny joke seems fine to me. At the end of the day the name is just the name, it won't dictate the community.
 
H

Hoo-doo

Banned
I think "Guilds Always Fail" is okay from a joke point of view, but horrible as an actual name.

This is supposed to be a guild name, not a statement that makes absolutely no sense in the outside world. Yeah I get it, "inside joke" yadda yadda, I just personally don't care for it.

I support the name Gaming Age Front, or just plain ol' NeoGAF.
 
F

Ferny

Member
Hoo-doo said:
I think "Guilds Always Fail" is okay from a joke point of view, but horrible as an actual name.

This is supposed to be a guild name, not a statement that makes absolutely no sense in the outside world. Yeah I get it, "inside joke" yadda yadda, I just personally don't care for it.

I support the name Gaming Age Front, or just plain ol' NeoGAF.
Click to expand...

That is actually one of more serious names that I liked as well. Gaming Age Front fits well.
 
R

Retro

Member
Ferny said:
At the end of the day the name is just the name, it won't dictate the community.
Click to expand...

But it doesn't dictate how the community is viewed, and that's the point I'm making. I can't tell you how many times I've queued up for a dungeon or raid or something in other MMOs and seen somebody with a silly guild name and thought "Great, this is going to suck".

The scary thing is that it's actually a surprisingly good indicator.


Hoo-doo said:
I support the name Gaming Age Front, or just plain ol' NeoGAF.
Click to expand...

At this point, I'd be fine if we came up with something cool-sounding with maybe a little cheek without it actually having a NEO or GAF abbreviation. After all, the tag will still be "GAF" whatever we do.

I do like "Gaming Age Front" though, "Gaming Age Force" also works.
 
F

Ferny

Member
Retro said:
The scary thing is that it's actually a surprisingly good indicator.
Click to expand...

I actually don't agree with that at all. Goon Squad has one of the worst reps in all MMOs and I can't tell you how many times i've grouped up with them and had the best experience. A funny name is just going to be a funny name. If we cause problems and all, then we will receive the bad rep of course. I'm not defending any of the names I picked or saying it's that or nothing else, but I do want it to represent GAF in some way.
 
H

Hoo-doo

Banned
Retro said:
But it doesn't dictate how the community is viewed, and that's the point I'm making. I can't tell you how many times I've queued up for a dungeon or raid or something in other MMOs and seen somebody with a silly guild name and thought "Great, this is going to suck".

The scary thing is that it's actually a surprisingly good indicator.
At this point, I'd be fine if we came up with something cool-sounding with maybe a little cheek without it actually having a NEO or GAF abbreviation. After all, the tag will still be "GAF" whatever we do.
I do like "Gaming Age Front" though, "Gaming Age Force" also works.
Click to expand...
I wouldn't mind if we ditch the G.A.F. acronym altogether, and just make a cool sounding name that references the boards in a way.
The tag will still be [GAF], so people will recognize either way. Make it a "proper" NeoGAF inside joke maybe, but one that also sounds cool as a guildname.

Take for example the GiantBomb SWTOR guild. It's called "Kessler Run", which is a reference to the infamous GB intern Matt Kessler.
It also apparently infuriates the Star Wars nerds, which is an added bonus.

Edit: I just realised I wrote exactly what you just posted, but yeah, i'm down with that idea! :)
 
R

Retro

Member
Hoo-doo said:
Make it a "proper" NeoGAF inside joke maybe, but one that also sounds cool as a guildname.
Click to expand...

Not a lot of GAF in-jokes that work well as guild names... "Dyack's Demise?".
JUWnj.gif
 
R

Ryan_

Member
Does anyone know when the first beta weekend will arrive?

EDIT: And what do I have to do to join this worthy cause? ;-)
 
F

Ferny

Member
Ryan_ said:
Does anyone know when the first beta weekend will arrive?

EDIT: And what do I have to do to join this worthy cause? ;-)
Click to expand...

Its going to be either the weekend of the 20th or the last weekend of the month.

I'll take you asking about it as being interested so I put you down.
 
N

nataku

Member
All registered and ready to go. Too bad I still have no idea what profession I'll play. I really hope they keep the level boost to 30 in for the BWE so I can test everything out. It's going to be hard getting a good feel for each profession when I've got to go through a bunch of levels where I hardly have anything available.

On the topic of guild names, just some random stuff I was thinking of. If we use the "A" for "And" it seems a bit easier to fit a G and F into it without having to come up with three words that make sense together. Gladiators, Guilds, Glory, Gold(en), Gods, Gore, Fire, Fury, Fate, Fear, Fame, Flame, Force. Various guild sounding words fit in there in certain combinations. I'm sure there's more I'm not even thinking of.
 
T

Teknoman

Member
Count me in. Probably going to end up a Greatsword Guardian or Rifle Engineer.

I support "Dyack's Demise" since it actually sounds kinda cool. But of course anything that sounds nice works for me.


#addme
 
R

Retro

Member
The reason we're trying to iron out a name and such now is so when the Beta weekends do start we can get up and running as quickly as possible.
 
F

Ferny

Member
We actually got the name all set but I'll be updating the OP with it later tonight as well as I'm going to try and get the updated member list updated as well.
 
F

Forkball

Member
I'm waiting for it to hit Steam before I purchase it, but I'm in. I already plan to play with some GAFfers anyways. Guild members should wear orange, grey, and white. Any other colors will be considered traitorous.
 
R

Retro

Member
Forkball said:
I'm waiting for it to hit Steam before I purchase it, but I'm in. I already plan to play with some GAFfers anyways. Guild members should wear orange, grey, and white. Any other colors will be considered traitorous.
Click to expand...

Not to burst your bubble, but ArenaNet has pretty much ruled out GW2 on Steam. Because Valve requires a cut of microtransaction sales and GW2's entire business plan is based on them, I don't think it's gonna happen.

Nevermind, see below. I is a stewpid.
 
W

Warrior_Keoni

Member
Retro said:
Well shit. I guess I'm clearly in the wrong then, I didn't see that (and it's from last month). Sorry about the confusion then, Forkball, I'll edit my post.
Click to expand...

I did not mean any offense! I'm sure Anet wants to secure as many prepurchases now before Steam is set up since most people want it on steam.

Impulse buyers like myself going with CE already know a good chunk of profit goes to Anet, and the eventual trip to Steam will come forth.
 
F

Ferny

Member
Yeah I can easily see a situation where they work a deal with Valve and this game. If GW is up there, I don't see any reason why GW2 won't be at some point.
 
F

Ferny

Member
Ok so everyone that has expressed interest in the guild above has been added to the member list. I'm also starting to add the user id's as well so if you want to post your own then feel free. It's the one they give you that's like username.xxxx. We also have 62 people in the guild and we don't even have a date yet which is awesome.
 
W

Warrior_Keoni

Member
Ferny said:
Ok so everyone that has expressed interest in the guild above has been added to the member list. I'm also starting to add the user id's as well so if you want to post your own then feel free. It's the one they give you that's like username.xxxx. We also have 62 people in the guild and we don't even have a date yet which is awesome.
Click to expand...

Nice, I assume US GAF and EuroGAF are going to be separate guilds or one?
 
F

Ferny

Member
I haven't seen any talk of someone forming up a Euro specific guild. If people from those regions are able to and want to join the US one, they are more than welcome though.
 
NeededSleep

NeededSleep

Member
Wonder how many guilds you can be on considering you can hop to different servers with your characters.

If so maybe we can all be under one roof. ?
 
R

Retro

Member
Warrior_Keoni said:
Nice, I assume US GAF and EuroGAF are going to be separate guilds or one?
Click to expand...

There's no regional restrictions in-game; European players can play with NA players can play with Asian players. I'm not sure if there will be 'recommended servers' or not, but as far as we've seen, you can play with anyone from anywhere at any time.

EuroGAF is more than welcome, the more the merrier.
 
T

Teknoman

Member
Ferny said:
Ok so everyone that has expressed interest in the guild above has been added to the member list. I'm also starting to add the user id's as well so if you want to post your own then feel free. It's the one they give you that's like username.xxxx. We also have 62 people in the guild and we don't even have a date yet which is awesome.
Click to expand...

Teknoman.3608
 
A

alazz

Member
I saw mention of being able to be in multiple guilds in GW2?
A nice casual guild sounds perfect. I was in a couple great guilds/alliances but I got too casual and they didn't like that.


#addme
alazz.3127
 
R

Retro

Member
alazz said:
I saw mention of being able to be in multiple guilds in GW2?
A nice casual guild sounds perfect. I was in a couple great guilds/alliances but I got too casual and they didn't like that.
Click to expand...

Yep, the GAF Guild is more of a place to hang out and do stuff with a familiar community. There's no end-game raiding slots or anything that people will fight over, so we avoid a lot of the drama that way. The plan so far is to just have fun, yuck it up in guild chat and try to do events as a group... like terrorize some WvW and get the GAF Banner flying over some valuable real estate.
 
M

_machine

Member
Retro said:
Yep, the GAF Guild is more of a place to hang out and do stuff with a familiar community. There's no end-game raiding slots or anything that people will fight over, so we avoid a lot of the drama that way. The plan so far is to just have fun, yuck it up in guild chat and try to do events as a group... like terrorize some WvW and get the GAF Banner flying over some valuable real estate.
Click to expand...
Totally forgot about having multiple guilds, so add me too:

#machinaea.8613
add #EU
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

I'm a bit worried.....
6 7 8 9 10
478
17K
Jinxed replied
Reddit IPO
2
74
6K
Grildon Tundy replied
  • Locked
Former Star Wars Jedi: Survivor Director, Stig Asmussen, Forms New Studio, Giant Skull, To Create Action-Adventure Game In Unreal Engine 5
News Game Dev
1
777
Thick Thighs Save Lives replied
Falcom has ~65 employees; Asia and the West combined account for 60% of sales; Wants no more than a year between Japanese and Western Trails releases
Game Dev
11
809
AmuroChan replied
Satya Nadella: Annual letter to stockholders. Content on new platforms will continue
3 4 5 6 7
349
16K
solidus12 replied
Top Bottom