Personally, this sounds like you're setting yourself up for failure.
And yeah Dax I dont understand why you would roll without an AA? Its best to have one there and forget about it until you really need it than just not have it at all.
Hey Dax, regarding feeling like you didn't really need AA's, wouldn't you see that changing once the game comes out and everyone is familiar with the game and AA's? I'm envisioning that once everyone gets their hands on the game and gets used to it and is using AA's, you would to pick it up as well in that regard, or at the very least maybe counter-pick enemy AA's? Great write-ups by the way.
Let's break the AAs down one by one:
1. Jetpack: Easy target when flying in the air.
2. Regenerator: Useless to deploy during a fight, and probably just as safe as sprinting somewhere else afterwards.
3. PV: Radar
4. Auto Sentry: Useless to deploy during a fight. How often are you going to get kills with this thing?
5. Hologram: You don't counter hologram; you get fooled by it.
6. Hardlight shield: defensive.
7. Active Camo: You know who's using it and when they're coming. I guess HLS would help prevent these guys from getting the drop on you, but if you're careful and know the maps, I think you'll be fine.
8. Thruster pack: Admittedly, I didn't fight against this much, but seeing as how a player's hitbox doesn't change, can't fire while they thrust, and it shouldn't be a problem because all it comes down to is...
The base traits for the player in Halo 4 are enough to put one on an even footing with an AA user. The point that people aren't used to AAs and don't know how to use 'em properly is a good one, and could very well be the case for the level playing field I felt. However, if you look at the AAs individually, none except maybe thruster pack give you an offensive advantage in combat. Even in Reach where AAs dominated more because the base player traits were more grounded, I just ran around with Sprint and I have that by default in Halo 4.
And, I mean, it's a gamble to find yourself in the right situation with the right armor ability. I mean, in a situation in which, say Regenerator is your best bet, I'm just as likely to die if I have hologram as if I had nothing at all.