Is he really?
Bolded were wrong, except maybe the last sentence... don't really know what it means, but Sony claimed they never intended nor discussed DRM, so if that's true, and many GAF users believe Sony's claim, then it's wrong.
The underline is debatable. All I've seen of CBOAT is a bunch of safe guesses from already established rumors by some other source, rumors. He took all the safe guesses and they were mostly wrong. I haven't been here for long, so I don't know if CBOAT has a record from 2009 or something where he was always right, but now, it seems to me he was majority of the time, wrong.
I don't know, maybe he really is an insider, and his sources were just wrong this time.
The Live paywall one was right, but that's how the system works on Xbox LIve right now. It's not hard to infer Xbox 360 policies would be the same as Xbox One policies.