poppabk
Cheeks Spread for Digital Only Future
I'm not sure I want to live in a world where AotC is someone's favorite star wars movie.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
If you could only ever watch one Star Wars film for the rest of your life, which would you pick?
- Thread starter Alter_Fridge
- Start date
June
Member
Tough call between II & III.
II has the least weak parts and is the tightest film, so it's the easiest to rewatch.
However III, whilst more uneven, has higher highs. It's got the Darth Plagueis scene, Palpatine's reveal, and the entire closing sequence from Mustafar onwards.
I think I'll go with Attack of the Clones since it's my favourite Star Wars film and therefore the safer choice.
II has the least weak parts and is the tightest film, so it's the easiest to rewatch.
However III, whilst more uneven, has higher highs. It's got the Darth Plagueis scene, Palpatine's reveal, and the entire closing sequence from Mustafar onwards.
I think I'll go with Attack of the Clones since it's my favourite Star Wars film and therefore the safer choice.
Last edited:
NecrosaroIII
Ultimate DQ Fan
As neither of them are part of the poll my answer is Return of the Jedi.
Underrated gems. And fucking grim.
Kagey K
Banned
The real nerd in me wants to pick Empire, it really is the best movie, but without the payoff of Return of the Jedi it wouldn’t stick the landing. Eternal cliffhangers aren’t my thing.
That leaves me with a couple weird choices.
Rogue One, or Battle for Endor.
I think battle for Endor was the better self contained story, so I guess I’m going to have to go with that (until a rewatch ruins it) as I haven’t seen it in 30 years.
That leaves me with a couple weird choices.
Rogue One, or Battle for Endor.
I think battle for Endor was the better self contained story, so I guess I’m going to have to go with that (until a rewatch ruins it) as I haven’t seen it in 30 years.
JimiNutz
Banned
Empire is the best but I voted Rogue One for several reasons.
It's a stand alone story.
It 'looks' the best as it's more recent and has lovely effects and cinematography.
It has the best action
It has far more sex appeal. No matter how you get off there's something for everyone. Things you can wank to in this movie:
- The starship dog fights with peak X-Wings in all their glory.
- Vader absolutely savaging a bunch of scared pussies with his glowing red saber of doom.
- Jyn Erso and her sexy little mouth
- Cassian Andors sexy booty
- The sassy and badass K-2SO all sexy black and shiny like any good sex robot should be
Rogue One is awesome how has it only got 4 votes?
It's a stand alone story.
It 'looks' the best as it's more recent and has lovely effects and cinematography.
It has the best action
It has far more sex appeal. No matter how you get off there's something for everyone. Things you can wank to in this movie:
- The starship dog fights with peak X-Wings in all their glory.
- Vader absolutely savaging a bunch of scared pussies with his glowing red saber of doom.
- Jyn Erso and her sexy little mouth
- Cassian Andors sexy booty
- The sassy and badass K-2SO all sexy black and shiny like any good sex robot should be
Rogue One is awesome how has it only got 4 votes?
The Scrivener
Member
IV.
Because of the final scene.
The greatest scene in any movie ever.
Because of the final scene.
The greatest scene in any movie ever.
GeorgPrime
Banned
Return of the Jedi. I love the scenes with the Ewoks.
Laptop1991
Member
The Empire Strikes Back
mcz117chief
Member
A New Hope
It is the only movie that you can watch on its own and it makes sense. It has a beginning and an end, the other movies are practically just an afterthought, an extension of the original movie. You can easily imagine that the Empire is on the Death Star and the story ends with its destruction.
It is the only movie that you can watch on its own and it makes sense. It has a beginning and an end, the other movies are practically just an afterthought, an extension of the original movie. You can easily imagine that the Empire is on the Death Star and the story ends with its destruction.
HoodWinked
Member
ScarletSpider
Banned
.
Last edited:
DelireMan7
Member
A new hope without hesitation. Especially if I can only watch only one.
Spaceman292
Banned
Excuse me what the fuck?
ruvikx
Banned
It's Star Wars, i.e. objectively speaking all of them could be considered either great or awful depending on who is watching & which movie it is. Star Wars is like that, i.e. it appeals to people in different ways. Personally speaking I believe Empire Strikes back is overrated (i.e. the movie most considered the best in the series). Its opening is strong, as is the confrontation between Vader & Luke, but the rest? I don't like it. I didn't like the romance between Solo & Leia, the excessive wisecracking & C-3PO becoming one of the most annoying comedic side characters in cinema history long before Jar Jar.
I enjoy Episode III most, if I had to choose. It has so many cathartic moments, i.e. for example Anakin slicing Mace Windu's forearm off, followed by Windu's screaming & the "unlimited powerrrrr!" from Palpatine is like literally my favorite Star Wars moment ever (best cinema experience as well). The build up to the big moment is just so good. And the part of the duel on Mustafar when Anakin & Obi Wan swing on the ropes of the collapsed structure, Obi Wan lands, Anakin runs, backflips onto the small platform & casually twirls his lightsaber. That whole sequence is so awesome (best music as well).
Spaceman292
Banned
I can't tell if this whole post is being sarcastic.
ruvikx
Banned
Star Wars is serious business, right? i.e. one man argues that a bunch of grown men hitting each other with glowing sticks in the 1980's was better than a bunch of men hitting each other with glowing sticks in the 2000's. Me? I don't care. I'm just saying it as I experienced it. 2005's Episode III was my favorite Star Wars movie & cinema moment.
Your favourite one is the worst one ever made. My God, man!!
sol_bad
Member
I'm one of the three!
Meowzers
Member
Phantom Menace. Simply because at the time I was happiest in life at 13. I went with my mum to see it. I wasn't really a fan but all my friends were so just wanted to watch it because they did as they loved Star Wars.
Yea I hear you Kev Kev Kev Kev Kev, bruv. Carrie Fisher was hella hot.
Yea I hear you Kev Kev Kev Kev Kev, bruv. Carrie Fisher was hella hot.
Spaceman292
Banned
Wow bro you're so mature and thoughtful.
MaestroMike
Gold Member
I don't really remember any of them, but I guess return of the jedi because of the cute & cuddly dancing bears I wish I could own one as a pet
Hoya Destroyer
Member
When I was a kid, I loved RotJ for having the coolest monsters, the Speeder Bikes and the Biker Scouts.
Now Im older, I love it for all that, plus Slave Leia and the big showdown at the end.
Now Im older, I love it for all that, plus Slave Leia and the big showdown at the end.
EverydayBeast
ChatGPT 0.1
Good question, I have no problem with only watching one Star Wars movie, if you rewatch any of time, some excellent quotes, some of the biggest movies ever.
Force Awakens.
Force Awakens.
#Phonepunk#
Banned
Empire is really the only one u need
Slings and Arrows
Banned
Where's the option for death?
Nerds
Nerds
PaddyOCanager
Member
Empire. It's nearly perfect for me.
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll