• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

In only three weeks, I completely abandoned iOS devices for Android

Status
Not open for further replies.

Aiii

So not worth it
Disclaimer: Wall of anecdotal text incoming, tl;dr at the bottom.

So I’ve been using iPhone’s and iPad’s and even the occasional iPod Touch pretty much since the inception of iOS, we’re talking from the very start here, I had a first generation iPod Touch, a iPhone 3G, 3GS, iPhone 5, hell, I’ve owned ever single iPad, except the 4 and the Mini Retina and of course I have an Apple TV for Airplay. Needless to say, I was a pretty devout Apple user. In fact, I’ve only “betrayed” Apple exactly twice before, I replaced the 3GS with a Samsung Galaxy S II and used that for well over a year before returning to Apple after getting annoyed with the sluggishness, the lack of certain Apps I got used to using and most importantly the crappy support as far as software updates go (when Android 4 was released it took months upon months for that to come to the S2, and my country (Netherlands) was amongst the last to get it due to some localization issues). I also got the first Nexus 7, which was a lot better, but too suffered a lot from sluggishness. I didn’t care much about how “open” my device is, and I don’t want to spend hours upon hours rooting my device and installing custom mods to get the best experience, I’m lazy, I want a device that works well out of the box.

So Apple it was for me, for the better part of seven years. But at the 22nd of last month, I got a Nexus 7 2013 from work, officially for testing purposes (I’m a WebDev), but pretty much a gift for a job well done (I’m totally NOT browsing GAF at work…). And so I started using it, it remembered all my apps and settings from the old Nexus 7 and set the thing up for me. Just like iOS would, that was nice. But, this device completely blew the old one out of the water, it is insanely faster, browsing, zooming, navigating apps and multitasking all seemed so much more snappy than the older version. Not to mention I have had to do absolutely zero memory management (while I spend most of my time on the Nexus 7 and Galaxy S II killing apps running in the background). I went into the Play Store and replaced all of the apps I used in iOS with their equivalent as far as features go and then some. Of course the biggest plus coming from the system being open, because even though it never really bothered me that I needed iTunes to transfer files from my PC to my tablet or phone, it is insane how much easier things can be. I want to put a new comic on my device? Fine, I’ll transfer it via Bluetooth or Wifi. I accidently have a duplicate picture in my vacation album? Fine, I’ll just delete right here (because you can’t actually delete a picture from an Album you synchronized via iTunes, you see). It blew my mind that I could install a new browser from my device and links from other apps actually opened in that browser, of course I didn’t mind when the PlayStation Store in the PlayStation App opened up in the Safari Browser instead of the browser I actually used when I was on iOS, but it sure feels good to have a device actually do what you want instead. Seems so simple, but yet was so hard for Apple to do.

As I was using the Nexus 7 over the past weeks I hardly even looked at the iPad Air and when I did it started annoying me more and more. Sure, it still had a few things that were better, the 4:3 aspect ratio is better, the scroll-to-top when you tap on the statusbar is great, the battery life is unrivaled and you can’t really beat the look of the device. But the browser would still crash constantly due to the lack of memory (1GB), iOS 7 still looked horrible and as said, I missed the ease of use of being able to download a podcast MP3 file from the web directly to my device for listening. Even worse, I had to struggle using my iPhone 5. Every time I was out and about and using the iPhone I couldn’t help but wish I had my Nexus there, so last week I decided to sell the iPad Air (no reason to have it just lying there doing nothing after all) and used a chunk of the profit to replace my iPhone with a Nexus 5, had it for a week now and I love everything about it, just like the Nexus 7, it’s fast and snappy and even it’s minor drawbacks (as any device has them) don’t even remotely weigh up against the lack of progress made on the iPhone front. It even manages to amaze me, from anticipating features like Google Now that blow Apple's stuff out of the water, to something as simple of dialing the food delivery last night as they were taking too long to deliver and having the phonenumber in the dialer change to the name of the place complete with a picture of the place (including delivery truck) as I dialed the number. It seems silly, but stuff like that impresses.

Long story short, it seems Android has finally hit that sweet spot for me, where the OS is no longer sluggish and unnecessarily bloated. Of course much of this is due to the Nexus line of devices, where you are excluded from the custom skins and software companies put on Android and get the latest Android updates as soon as they’re released, instead of having to wait. The Play Store took a while to match up to the quality of the App Store, and while it’s not quite there (especially on the tablet side), it’s close enough where you can pretty much get the same experiences if you spend some time looking into the different Apps that are out there. It’s been quite the experience for me and I feel that anyone still on iOS thinking about making the switch should definitely give Android (another) serious go, because pretty much every drawback it used to have has been addressed, especially in the Nexus line of devices.

tl;dr: I was a devout iOS user for seven years and have been completely blown away by how far Android has come over the past few years and advise every iPhone user to give Android a serious go.
 

SmokyDave

Member
tl;dr: I was a devout iOS user for seven years and have been completely blown away by how far Android has come over the past few years and advise every iPhone user to give Android a serious go.
Can't man. I like mobile gaming so it's a non-starter. Plus, I have a shit-ton of App Store and iTunes content.

Glad you're enjoying your new kit though.
 

neshcom

Banned
Strange, just the opposite for me. I've had Android phones since the original Evo and I finally got over the tendency for hardware to get slower and slower over time. I've had an iPad mini for a while and recently got the retina one and it really convinced me to go with iPhone. Everything just feels more polished and the App Store feels full of life. When they got Google Music in iOS, there was nothing major holding me back. I do miss having a back button sometimes,
 

Aiii

So not worth it
Can't man. I like mobile gaming so it's a non-starter. Plus, I have a shit-ton of App Store and iTunes content.

Glad you're enjoying your new kit though.

I must admit I don't do much gaming on mobile, but I found the move away from the App Store and iTunes alot easier than I thought. Even though I invested 7 years worth of cash into it, I find the Play Store's offering to be great at replacing more or less of everything and the cost of it has been surprisingly low.

I do miss QuizUp though, but Android version should arrive soon. :D
 

linkboy

Member
I had a 4S and the first gen mini, but when iOS 7 came out, I said screw it and went back to Android.

Picked up a Nexus 4 when Google dropped it to $250 and my wife just bought me a Galaxy Tab 3 (7") for my upcoming deployment.
 

styl3s

Member
Tablet wise i prefer the ipad but phone wise i am android all the way. Android just doesn't offer a 10.1 tablet that interest me.

I have absolutely 0 interest in mobile gaming.
 

Blearth

Banned
Sorry. Can't give up the hardware.

My Atrix 4G and Galaxy Nexus both started to crap out on me after a few months even though I rocked a case for both.

My iPhone 5 is naked. I've dropped it a hundred times and it still works just fine.
 

entremet

Member
I'm fine with my Apple ecosystem. It exceeds my expectations, has great support and resale value and I have a lot of legacy content on it.

Android stuff is great, though.
 

Baconbitz

Banned
Can't man. I like mobile gaming so it's a non-starter. Plus, I have a shit-ton of App Store and iTunes content.

Glad you're enjoying your new kit though.
Yay, I can't figure out how people can give up the stuff they paid for and, completely switch to a new mobile OS.
 

PaulloDEC

Member
Sorry. Can't give up the hardware.

My Atrix 4G and Galaxy Nexus both started to crap out on me after a few months even though I rocked a case for both.

My iPhone 5 is naked. I've dropped it a hundred times and it still works just fine.

A few months? How many times did you drop them? I've had my Galaxy Nexus a little over two years with no issues, though I'll admit I've only dropped it maybe three times over that period.
 

WanderingWind

Mecklemore Is My Favorite Wrapper
I bought a Samsung Galaxy 10.1 a few weeks ago, the first Android device I had bought in years. Worst purchase I've made since I bought a car that didn't start. Wish I had bought a replacement iPad instead. In theory, I like Android's philosophy of do want you want, but the practice of actually using Google Play Store and trying to sift through loads of off-brand shitware apps doesn't really live up to the promise.

Take, for instance, a comic reading app. iOS had one great one and a bunch of lesser one. ComicZeal works exactly how you want it to. You load your comics up, it sorts them and the animation of flipping pages is unnoticable. Android comic apps range from utterly broken to barely usable. The best is ComicRack, which works about half as well as ComicZeal and had a terrible sorting algorithm that makes a hash of even simply labled series.

I don't know OP. I want Android to be great, but everything about it just feels so half-assed and disorganized.
 

NinjaBoiX

Member
Me too man! Well, not five years, more like two months, but I'm done with iOS. Plus the battery on iPhones is poorer than a very poor thing.

It's fine, nothing wrong with it. In fact, it's brilliant in a lot of ways, just too restrictive for me. I made the jump to have a small but powerful phone after my monstrous Galaxy Note, but now the Z1 compact is out, I'm swapping back over.
cheap plastic hardware is a deal breaker for me
Z1 Compact is a thing of beauty.
 

Aiii

So not worth it
Yay, I can't figure out how people can give up the stuff they paid for and, completely switch to a new mobile OS.

Oh, that's definitely the hardest part/biggest hurdle to take when you switch. But it has been a lot easier than I initially expected it to be, Android has some great offerings in the free app department too. I haven't been spending too much and have pretty much replaced everything I still used as far as Apps go.

I use Spotify for music, so that was an easy switch and mostly do comics and books as far as the rest goes. I had to give up some books I bought via iBooks, but that's about it. The comics were available cross device via Comixology and the rest of the books were easily imported into Google's Play Books (and uploaded via the Nexus 7 and available cross-device right away, which was nice).

All in all, the switch was a lot less jarring than I initially expected it to be.

I bought a Samsung Galaxy 10.1 a few weeks ago, the first Android device I had bought in years. Worst purchase I've made since I bought a car that didn't start. Wish I had bought a replacement iPad instead. In theory, I like Android's philosophy of do want you want, but the practice of actually using Google Play Store and trying to sift through loads of off-brand shitware apps doesn't really live up to the promise.
As said, I had a similar experience back when I tried the S II, maybe it's because of naked Android that I find the experience much more satisfying now. But I honestly couldn't say since I haven't tried a Samsung device since the Tab 2 we have at work.

Take, for instance, a comic reading app. iOS had one great one and a bunch of lesser one. ComicZeal works exactly how you want it to. You load your comics up, it sorts them and the animation of flipping pages is unnoticable. Android comic apps range from utterly broken to barely usable. The best is ComicRack, which works about half as well as ComicZeal and had a terrible sorting algorithm that makes a hash of even simply labled series.

ComicRack has been doing well for me so far, but I never keep many comics on my device at one, so sorting has never been much of an issue for me either way. I like to sort on filenames anyways, I keep everything neatly organised on a external drive and just transfer over as I need them. ComicZeal was great, but the importing process is horrid. I used iTunes to get the comics in there or put single issues on my Dropbox and then imported them that way. You had to open the app, wait for the comics to be imported and only then read them. On Android I just put them in the right folder and I'm good to go, that alone feels so good.
 

Chorazin

Member
I went thought that same experience about three years ago, when the 4S turned out to be just another boring retread I was just done with Apple. Made the jump to Android and loved it for all the crazy stuff you could do.

This past month, my GF scored a return MS Surface, and after playing around with hers I got one too to replace my aging Galaxy Note 10.1. Then she got a Nokia Lumina 520 super cheap, and then I bought one too to use as a beater for hikes and workouts so I didn't have to carry my massive Note 2. Started actually using it more than my Note 2, and I realized I fell in love with Windows Phone. Ordered a gently used Nokia Lumina 1020 which should be here any day now!

TL,DR: I get bored with mobile OSs every three years or so, and change is good.
 

Blearth

Banned
A few months? How many times did you drop them? I've had my Galaxy Nexus a little over two years with no issues, though I'll admit I've only dropped it maybe three times over that period.

I drop my phone a lot. Headphone jack only worked on one ear after a few months, same issue with the Atrix.

If Apple can make a phone that can withstand my clumsy hands. why can't anyone else?

EDIT: Might not be a problem now, but software was a big deal too. 2.3.6 broke my Atrix's wifi and 4.2.2 turned my Nexus into a crashy mess.
 
The 'waiting for changes to be applied' bullshit that has impaired my ability to sync music since iOS 7's release is almost single-handedly steering me towards Android after 5 years of iPhone ownership. Games would keep me locked into the ecosystem if I actually played any, but I don't. I use a couple apps for work, but I'm pretty sure they've been ported at this point. Add my desire for a bigger screen, and I'm starting to get a wandering eye.
 

Goodlife

Member
Bought my wife a 5c for Xmas.
I had a play around with it as my contract was up soon after.

I bought myself a Nexus 5.

No Swype is a killer for me.
 

PaulloDEC

Member
EDIT: Might not be a problem now, but software was a big deal too. 2.3.6 broke my Atrix's wifi and 4.2.2 turned my Nexus into a crashy mess.

Maybe I've dodged a bullet, but thanks to my crappy carrier I'm something like a year behind in software updates. Word to the wise: always buy your hardware direct from Google if you want to stay up-to-date.
 

Blearth

Banned
Maybe I've dodged a bullet, but thanks to my crappy carrier I'm something like a year behind in software updates. Word to the wise: always buy your hardware direct from Google if you want to stay up-to-date.

Where do you think I bought the Nexus from? :(
 

Jedeye Sniv

Banned
I'm getting to the stage with my iPhone 4 that it's useless for anything other than being a phone so I could mayyyyyybe see replacing it with a cheaper android machine. Never replacing my iPad though, iOS and iPad are just too good for gaming, I would always feel like I was missing out with Android for the occasional games that don't come out there.

But then have two ecosystems would be annoying too, so I'll prob just get a new iPhone one day.

They've got me.
 

Aiii

So not worth it
Bought my wife a 5c for Xmas.
I had a play around with it as my contract was up soon after.

I bought myself a Nexus 5.

No Swype is a killer for me.

OH GOD! I totally forgot to write about swype/gesture typing!

Absolutely the best feature on both devices, yesterday I actually started writing a short story on the Nexus 7 and it barely took me longer to write than actually using a keyboard (again, as a WebDev I am very fast at typing). It was one of the key features in what was turning me off from my iPhone compared to the experience I was having on the Nexus 7.
 
Over the past couple of years I went from iPad to Nexus 7 and from iPhone to HTC One...

... and back again.

I understand your reasoning in the OP but just as I had tired of iOS I eventually tired of the Android ecosystem as well. When I finally weighed the two I realized that iOS was the better ecosystem for me.
 

WanderingWind

Mecklemore Is My Favorite Wrapper
ComicRack has been doing well for me so far, but I never keep many comics on my device at one, so sorting has never been much of an issue for me either way. I like to sort on filenames anyways, I keep everything neatly organised on a external drive and just transfer over as I need them. ComicZeal was great, but the importing process is horrid. I used iTunes to get the comics in there or put single issues on my Dropbox and then imported them that way. You had to open the app, wait for the comics to be imported and only then read them. On Android I just put them in the right folder and I'm good to go, that alone feels so good.

Even trying to resort 3 different series on ComicRack is frustrating. The app refuses to sort correctly. That alone makes it worse than ComicZeal. I agree the waiting for the comics to be be imported could be annoying on CZ, but I used to just hit the button and walk away. The actually usability is much worse too. There is noticeable lag in the page turning, even with animation turned off. The sidebar and navigation takes too many presses to change different settings,etc.
 

snacknuts

we all knew her
iOS will keep me from ever going back to the iPhone even though I really like Apple hardware. If I could get an Apple-made device with a 5" screen that ran Android, I'd buy it in a heartbeat.
 

NinjaBoiX

Member
iOS will keep me from ever going back to the iPhone even though I really like Apple hardware. If I could get an Apple-made device with a 5" screen that ran Android, I'd buy it in a heartbeat.
Apparently this may be happening. There is nothing to stop them, it's open platform. Apart from diluting the brand of course.
 
gold_medal-0x600.jpg
 
I'm glad I'm not invested in mobile gaming I would hate to be locked down to mobile ecosystem. Sent from my 3yr old Motorola Triumph, still running android 2.2 ....
 
I'm very happy with an Android phone and an iOS tablet. Android offers everything I need in a phone, iOS has tablet games I couldn't do without that I've invested quite a bit of money into.
 

renitou

Member
I've made deliberate moves away from iOS before, but always end up back with an iPhone and an iPad. They do what I want best. Android is always second-best.
 

Halcyon

Member
To the people saying they are heavily invested in Apple's mobile games: What games are you talking about? I can't tell if i'm missing out because I only have access to Google Play, or you people are assholes and don't realize that mobile games are mostly garbage.

This is a serious question.
 
You poor bastard.

It's not as bad as it sound. It's a custom ROM and it feels snappier than our Galaxy Tab 3, which might not be saying much. I really want a Nexus 5, but I also really want to use Verizon. Unfortunately Verizon doesn't support the Nexus 5. Samsung seems like the way to go, but I find their phones boring and I want to run Vanilla Android without rooting. Oh well I will figure it out in the next few months.

Lol, you have many options.. forget it, I'm not going to fall into this trap

7HY3UFU.png


I mean if you call THIS a choice.
It's a beautiful phone
 

Owari

Member
I think both platforms have a lot to offer, ideally I'd switch between them once a year, but I usually just stick with iOS.
 

reKon

Banned
To the people saying they are heavily invested in Apple's mobile games: What games are you talking about? I can't tell if i'm missing out because I only have access to Google Play, or you people are assholes and don't realize that mobile games are mostly garbage.

This is a serious question.

There are actually very good mobile games surprisingly and iOS had the advantage on this. They are still overall shitty compared to vita and 3ds libraries. iOS gaming fans will try to argue with me though. Games like Kingdom Rush are the only types of games I considered top tier.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom