Marty Chinn said:
So I'm trying out Newstand with Edge Magazine. Are other publications a better experience than this? I caved in and tried out a $5 magazine to see what it would be like and it really feels like it's just a PDF that I'm scrolling page by page. Even the index isn't great let alone the table of contents which is non interactive. On top of that, it just doesn't work well with being displayed on an iPhone. Maybe it would be more useful on an iPad, but if this is what Newstand is like, I just won't be using it at all on my phone.
Edge in iOS5 Newsstand looks like it's a straight up PDF.
At least Edge in Zinio has some nice features, such as converting pages to all-text for easier reading (with scalable font size). That's in fact how I read Edge on my iPad and my iPhone: I'll read the article as text-only, then switch to the graphical mode and look at the pictures & screenshots, etc. before turning the page.
Zinio also has a nice scrollable pop-up menu for easy navigation.
My only gripe with Zinio is they compress the images too much. I'd prefer they delivered larger downloads with higher res graphics. As it is, it's not *horrible*...But it leaves a bit to be desired.
Overall, I'd definitely suggest getting an Edge subscription with Zinio over Newsstand. I personally subscribe to both the print and digital editions of Edge. Being based in the U.S., I get the digital issue the day it comes out and can get a good jump on reading the issue as the print edition takes maybe a week, week and a half to be delivered (although during the holiday season I've had horrible delays as the magazine has been held up in Customs). In fact, that's why I originally purchased the digital edition, because I went 3 months without a print edition during a particularly nasty Christmas Customs nightmare.
That said, it's still a print magazine slightly re-configured for digital. Whereas something like EGMi is straight-up designed for digital and it shows.
The redesigned print edition of EDGE magazine that debuted at E3 in June reads MUCH better on iPad than the older design. I have no idea if that was intentional, but it is an improvement. If/when EDGE starts publishing for-digital by design I think we'll be in for a real treat.