That's pretty much how I saw it too. I didn't see this sentiment in the press though, at all. Oh well.
Jimquisition (July 21) - The Xbox One: A Lying Failure Machine
- Thread starter L~A
- Start date
That's pretty much how I saw it too. I didn't see this sentiment in the press though, at all. Oh well.
Pretty much. GM and their knowingly putting out faulty ignition that killed people comes to mind. A few fines and the ceo called to congress lol.
I thought the overwhelming consensus of "the press" was that Nintendo "won" E3..
Actions while blaming consumers for basicly being Luddites, unwilling to embrace their 'digital future'
Sure.
Ninja Scooter
Member
Having a disappointing E3 press conference (which for most companies is usually the norm) because Sony didn't show the games you wanted to see, is NOT comparable to the things Jim is ranting about. Is that so hard to get?
Zvonimir Boban
Banned
I fully agree with Jim here. They tried to sell us bullshit, praised it's anti-consumer "features" and then reversed them without apology when PS4 preoder numbers exploded after E3.
Xbone will forever be tainted by this colossal fuckup, but I don't think the MS will count it as a failure. It is selling good enough for now, and they even have chance to win US territory in a few years with good management.
Xbone will forever be tainted by this colossal fuckup, but I don't think the MS will count it as a failure. It is selling good enough for now, and they even have chance to win US territory in a few years with good management.
Jimmyfenix
Member
It seems like a lot of people did not watch the video or partake in discussion related to the video.
I think the fans dragged the press to that point after the fact. I'm glad for that. I didn't see anyone really saying anything negative about Sony.
I'm not a fan of MS at all now, but I thought they did more this year to put on a good show.
Metallix87
Member
Indeed, but the overall failure of Sony was glossed over almost completely.
blankempathy
Member
What about option C? I simply want to buy an xbox one to play games. I don't care about that other crap and only about the games. Thats all my ps3/ps4/x360/wiiu etc are used for. Just to play games and not any of the extra features. You seem to think that everyone that bought a X1 before the sku less version did so because they wanted Kinect when the fact is some people simply wanted to play xbox one games. How hard is it to understand that? A lot of people don't give a damn about the kinect and only sucked up paying for it because Microsofts stance on the peripheral was that it was here to stay. Have you ever bought any other electronic and opted for the cheaper version because you didn't need that extra fluff? Well kinect was that extra fluff but Microsoft lied and said it was mandatory.
I didn't say they are comparable. I'm saying that reveling in the past like this is not super helpful if it blinds you to the present.
It's good to remember the past, but not if it blinds you to changes.
The press likes to create a "narrative." And oftentimes the narrative can last years after it is no longer reality.
The fuck?
BibiMaghoo
Member
You said his audience on the whole are not Xbox fans, that has nothing to do with the most vocal of his audience being PC gamers does it? By suggesting he is bashing the Xbox to cater to his audience, you are suggesting his audience are Sony fans no?
You have no basis to declare what his fans preferences are in any direction. That was simply a sentence to dismiss his critique.
What failure? Not showcasing games that won't even be out until 2016?
I usually agree with Jim's opinion, but it seems is trying to hard in this video. I find the notion of videogame companies "in a moral quest" rather silly, coorporations are a-moral by very definition, they are not here to be "honest", they are here to make money.
MS is just reacting to the market, they put out a product that wasn't selling, they are turning the ship in the right direction reacting to the market with somewhat good results. Sony did the last thing last gen: remember getting 2 jobs?, rumble controller is "last gen"? no achievements at launch because reasons...
Im somewhat satisfaced with my xbone, at least it has some actual exclusives games that I've enjoy.
MS is just reacting to the market, they put out a product that wasn't selling, they are turning the ship in the right direction reacting to the market with somewhat good results. Sony did the last thing last gen: remember getting 2 jobs?, rumble controller is "last gen"? no achievements at launch because reasons...
Im somewhat satisfaced with my xbone, at least it has some actual exclusives games that I've enjoy.
Nemesis_
Member
I refuse to believe that post was serious =/
Metallix87
Member
Coming to the show with what I'd describe as "little to show, with way too much time to show it".
Because there wasn't one.
Ninja Scooter
Member
maybe because it wasn't an 'overall failure'? Not everyone thinks of things in hyperbolic absolutes. All of the damn press conferences (outside of Nintendo's innovative treehouse stuff, and EA's wierd prototype shit) were the damn same. I think the media AND for the most part fans came away the same overall "is E3 even necessary?" feeling.
It was a boring, uneventful conference. Is that really something that is deserving of any sort of expose or "calling out"? Especially when MS, Ubi and EA all pretty much had the same type of showings? E3 is what it is. The real problem is people need to stop setting themselves up for disappointment and then getting mad at Sony for not announcing Crash Bandicoot 5 made by Naughty Dog.
Dr. Kitty Muffins
Member
That isn't blatant trolling when I am speaking to my personal preferences.
And I referenced all three consoles so why single out Sony?
Are you just looking to fight?
Zvonimir Boban
Banned
Your option C is part of option A.
If you don't want Kinect, but the launch lineup was appealing enough to make the console worthwhile then people bought it. There are plenty of people on GAF who bought an Xbone and don't have Kinect plugged in.
If there were people who wanted an Xbone but didn't want to pay the extra money for Kinect, you know what they could do? Not buy it.
Nobody got screwed here, nobody was forced to buy the Xbone against their will, but you keep on banging that drum.
It's not like the MS presser was better and showed more than Sony's presser.
So if you think Sony's conference was a failure, I can't even imagine what you are thinking about Microsofts "CG 2016" conference.
I can agree with the "too much time to show it", but I'd say focusing on content that is soon to arrive is better than showing us super early stuff like a 2016 Crackdown.
I have a feeling No Man's Sky and Bloodborne (Destiny to a lesser extent), caused the press to gloss over the weaker parts of Sony's conference and just give it a neutral rating. Still, I don't think I would care nearly as much if they didn't show it in movie theaters. You'd think they'd have something earth-shattering to announce since they had that stage, but nothing really came of it.
blankempathy
Member
How many xbox one owners do you think would of bought a kinectless sku it was a launch option?
Metallix87
Member
I think a fair mix of both is acceptable. I mean, realistically, when do you think Uncharted 4 is coming? I'm guessing October 2015 at the earliest.
Zeyphersan
Banned
Hahahahahaha
Somebody brought this Chris Rock segment up earlier and it's very relevant to the discussion.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B0B_ekSrsEk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B0B_ekSrsEk
Black Mantis
Member
Nancy Tellem and a couple others are staying on until these projects are complete, plus it's more than likely Spielberg would use his own production team on it. ShowTime coming on board is most likely a way of getting a bigger audience to broadcast to.
PeskyToaster
Member
This video pulled no punches. Quite refreshing in this industry. Thanks Jim!
Yeah, next year, not 2+ years from now.
On a similar note, Jim stated he unplugged Kinect from his XB1 virtually straight away and it functioned just fine so one has to assume he'd fall into that bracket.
Did he purchase the console himself or was it donated? I find that relevant because as far as I can see videos like this seem to promote the stance of avoiding Xbox products and praise for____ reason(s) yet when Microsoft were at their supposed worst a purchase was made which says that the consumer was happy with the product offered. Seems to be somewhat contradictory.
Perhaps I'm over or under thinking things though. Feeling worse for wear today.
Phil Spencer's every interview and even his first video was pretty much an apology tour and a course correction for exactly what the hardcore gamer's want.
Gamers: Talk is cheap Phil. I'll believe it when I see it.
Kinect removed
$400
Xbox Live App Paywall Removed
ID@Xbox expanded and giving out a lot of free devkits and free Unity support
Bring back classics like Phantom Dust, pushing Killer Instinct Season 2
Halo Master Chief Collection for $60
Fully demoing Cloud Compute in real time and using it extensively for a major Crackdown reboot
Funding a brand new exclusive IP with Platinum Games
Xbox Entertainment Division producing TV content shut down (without any effect to any games like Quantum Break or Halo MCC).
Monthly OS Updates that are checking off all the major fan requests and even adding things like 3D BluRays support
"Gamers": Well they're still deceitful shits and they spin everything and I want them grovelling at my feet begging for forgiveness.
Uncharted 4
LittleBigPlanet 3
Bloodborne
The Order 1886
No Man's Sky
Entwined
Let it Die
Driveclub
Grim Fandango remake
Infamous First Light
Looks like a pretty solid lineup to me. And considering PS4 STILL managed to be the top selling console in June (even against Mario Kart and an XBO price drop) I don't think it was much of a failure.
Zvonimir Boban
Banned
That isn't relevant in any way to your "Microsoft screwed everybody" mantra.
Metallix87
Member
A year and a half vs. two years isn't that much of a different, especially since 2016 could mean Q1.
HocusPocus
Member
Wow it won't end for some until Microsoft leaves the console space for some I guess .
Nemesis_
Member
People are deluded enough to think that a monopoly will be a good thing for any of the major console manufacturers.
Metallix87
Member
Three things:
1.) Uncharted 4 was a teaser. Heck, it was barely a teaser.
2.) Grim Fandango was not shown. At all. It was named, and they had a photo of Tim. That's it.
3.) Drive Club was not part of their press conference.
Everything you listed is only happening because they're getting their asses kicked. It's great that it's happening, but it's not out of an act of benevolence, it's out of an act of desperation and complete course correction.
blankempathy
Member
Its very relevant because you you seem to think that people bought the xbox one wanting the kinect. Also I never said everyone.
Ninja Scooter
Member
Why does a press conference matter? Especially in comparison to the things talked about in this video? Especially when their conference was par for the course for what the other major press conferences were like. What "media pass" was given that wasn't given to everyone else?
At least they had in engine footage for UC4 which is more than what one can say for a majority of XB1 exclusive announcements which were mostly CGI teasers.
Metallix87
Member
Because we're discussing Sony's poor E3 showing? The press conference is the "face" of E3 for Sony and Microsoft with regards to most gamers.
Who cares if it was in-engine? Nothing was really shown.
I don't understand this viewpoint. "Gamers" hated everything about the X1 when it was first announced/released. Now that Microsoft has reversed pretty much all of those things people are still pissed? Is not getting a verbal "I'm sorry" seriously what people are still upset about?
Similar threads
- Poll