Support NeoGAF

[Fat4all]

When I saw 4 people dead I got concerned for a second but that went really well. How many scum does everyone reckon we have left? One?

two tops

 

[Ourobolus]

I WENT THROUGH ALL THE TROUBLE OF READING THE THREAD

*kicks trashcan on way out*

paging CzarTim

 

[rac]

when you come at the arsonist you best not miss

wee and dusk on opposite sides of the vote

 

[roytheone]

I WENT THROUGH ALL THE TROUBLE OF READING THE THREAD

*kicks trashcan on way out*

Hey, at least you are back on top of the replacement list! Not that there are any other games to replace in, but still!

 

[Fat4all]

the Vanilliser is scary to me

 

[CornBurrito]

I FUCKING TOLD ALL YOU FUCKS WEEMAD WAS SCUM. I POSTED EVIDENCE AND YOU FUCKS DID NOT BELIEVE ME.

 

[Sorian]

Don't think we don't see the laziness in this gif!

 

[Fat4all]

was scary to me

 

[CornBurrito]

I want an official apology from Blarg.

 

[Blargonaut]

TY acorns for justifying my paragraphs

oh look another player I read perfectly, Dusk Soldier

I'll take my Bad regarding weemad, I guess.

My sincere apologies to Launchpad for doubting him

RIP isaac

 

[Blargonaut]

I want an official apology from Blarg.

VOTE: CornBurrito

 

[NeckToChicken]

I FUCKING TOLD ALL YOU FUCKS WEEMAD WAS SCUM. I POSTED EVIDENCE AND YOU FUCKS DID NOT BELIEVE ME.

I may have, uh, super not believed you. What with Sorian flying the coop and all.

Eh heh... heh.

 

[Blargonaut]

"Player List:

6) NeckToChicken [m] (new)
8) kitsunelaine [f] (new)
12) rac [m]
13) franconp [m]
14) Fat4all [m]
15) melonrabbit [f]
16) Blargonaut [m]
17) Kalor [m]
18) CornBurrito [m]"

 

[CornBurrito]

6) NeckToChicken [m] (new)
8) kitsunelaine [f] (new)
12) rac [m]
13) franconp [m]
14) Fat4all [m]
15) melonrabbit [f]
16) Blargonaut [m]
17) Kalor [m]
18) CornBurrito [m]

These are the living players. I'm convinced there is only 1 scum left. 2 MAXIMUM.

We need to whittle down this list. I'm busy tonight but I'll pour over the votes.

Keep in mind Dusk and Wee were scum when analyzing the D1, D2, D3 votes. Remember scum often splits their votes. This is how I determined wee was scum, and I also somewhat suspected Dusk.

 

[CornBurrito]

Question: Is it worth just mass role claiming at this juncture? The neutral arsonist threat is gone. 3 scum members are dead meaning at most 1-2 are left.

I think mass role claiming would not be detrimental to town at this point.

 

[Fat4all]

So, the theory I alluded to yesterday is pretty clear. This game is full of Watcher-variants and roles that directly effect the results of those Watcher-variants.

It's probably best that I roleclaim now, as I have some strange findings.

 

[CornBurrito]

Kitsunelaine was almost lynched and had a late vote by weemad. I strongly lean town on kitsune.

 

[Kalor]

Question: Is it worth just mass role claiming at this juncture? The neutral arsonist threat is gone. 3 scum members are dead meaning at most 1-2 are left.

I think mass role claiming would not be detrimental to town at this point.

I'm okay with that if everyone else is.

 

[CornBurrito]

Rac and Melonrabbit are my top two suspects at this point.

 

[rac]

how?

 

[Fat4all]

I'm a Motion Detector.

I can target anyone at night and see if anyone used and ability by or on them. I cannot tell the difference between those two things (aka, dunno if who I targeted used an ability, or if something was used on them).

Likewise, I can't tell what ability was used, or who it was used by, or any of that good stuff. I'm just either given a yes or no if there was 'movement' or not.

N1 - heymonkey - there was movement
N2 - N/A - (I was on the road and forgot to use my ability N2)
N3 - rac - no movement
N4 - melonrabbit - No Info (I was specifically told there was no reading, which is odd)

 

[CornBurrito]

how?

Based purely on vote placement on the previous days. I'll admit it is weakish analysis. I'll need to see how Dusk and Wee ever interacted with you. But Dusk had a random vote on you yesterday which allowed him to split from his scum teammate Wee, and could have acted as a "bus" on you.

However, you might be town in which case Dusk voted on you because he didnt want to vote the same as Wee and Melonrabbit.

 

[CornBurrito]

N4 - melonrabbit - No Info (I was specifically told there was no reading, which is odd)

Vote: melonrabbit

Lets find out. Any ideas melon?

 

[rac]

Based purely on vote placement on the previous days. I'll admit it is weakish analysis. I'll need to see how Dusk and Wee ever interacted with you. But Dusk had a random vote on you yesterday which allowed him to split from his scum teammate Wee, and could have acted as a "bus" on you.

However, you might be town in which case Dusk voted on you because he didnt want to vote the same as Wee and Melonrabbit.

vote: acohrs

What do you think about this rac?

Are you panicking in scum chat?

what do you feel about this interaction?

 

[Blargonaut]

"Player List:

6) NeckToChicken [m] (new)
8) kitsunelaine [f] (new)
12) rac [m]
13) franconp [m]
14) Fat4all [m]
15) melonrabbit [f]
16) Blargonaut [m]
17) Kalor [m]
18) CornBurrito [m]"

According to their Roles I've unearthed, we can cross myself, franconp and NeckToChicken off this list as 91%-likely Town--

"Player List:

6) NeckToChicken [m] (new)
13) franconp [m]
16) Blargonaut

8) kitsunelaine [f] (new)
12) rac [m]
14) Fat4all [m]
15) melonrabbit [f]
17) Kalor [m]
18) CornBurrito [m]"

--so it's in this pool of 6 we gotta dive into. Six shots more than enough to kill anything that etc.

 

[CornBurrito]

what do you feel about this interaction?

Seems like an attempt to bus a teammate.

I can't simply discount you as being scum from that. Vote history is more telling.

 

[Blargonaut]

 

[CornBurrito]

According to their Roles I've unearthed, we can cross myself, franconp and NeckToChicken off this list as 91%-likely Town--

"Player List:

6) NeckToChicken [m] (new)
13) franconp [m]
16) Blargonaut

8) kitsunelaine [f] (new)
12) rac [m]
14) Fat4all [m]
15) melonrabbit [f]
17) Kalor [m]
18) CornBurrito [m]"

--so it's in this pool of 6 we gotta dive into. Six shots more than enough to kill anything that etc.

I agree with NecktoNeck being town. But I thought you said franconp was a big fat liar?

Looking at the votes yesterday, I think we can say kitsune is most likely town. Kitsune was at 5 votes. That's too close for comfort for scum to risk. Wee was a vote on kitsune.

You could say "oh its a bus" but wee was doused and we now know that wasnt a ruse. Scum would bus weemad before they would bus an undoused player.

 

[CornBurrito]

Or in other words, I think your list should look like:

12) rac [m]
14) Fat4all [m]
15) melonrabbit [f]
17) Kalor [m]


Gut feeling makes me lean on melon and rac.

 

[rac]

i dont buy it

 

[CornBurrito]

i dont buy it

"It" being what?

That kitsune is most likely town? I can elaborate even further.

 

[kitsunelaine]

...Well. I definitely wasn't expecting THAT from the arsonist. I'm happy so many scum got done.

And yeah, I stand by my roleclaim as vanilla town. I was incredibly suspicious of the people who started voting against me, thinking that maybe Acohrs was scum and they were rallying to save him and lynch a townie in his place, but lordy was I wrong with that assumption.

 

[Blargonaut]

I've decided I don't doubt my franconp result. Like I said B4, I probably would've had the yucky Factional-kill show up in my result as a detected Power if he was a Mafia goon, IMO. So he's most likely definitely (Town) Vanilla

 

[rac]

"It" being what?

That kitsune is most likely town? I can elaborate even further.

nah that i can get

 

[CornBurrito]

Blarg, necktoneck, what do you two think of a mass role claim right now?

 

[Blargonaut]

Or in other words, I think your list should look like:

12) rac [m]
14) Fat4all [m]
15) melonrabbit [f]
17) Kalor [m]


Gut feeling makes me lean on melon and rac.

alright

What about you

 

[CornBurrito]

nah that i can get

Fair enough.

If it helps, I lean slightly more on Melonrabbit than you.

 

[NeckToChicken]

You know how Blarg hates paperwork, so my only stipulation is you get his answer first.

 

[CornBurrito]

alright

What about you

You can't discount me. If I'm scum I bussed weemad hard, and that would be ideal because I'd have known he was doused by the arsonist anyway.

I can discount me because I know my own role.

 

[Blargonaut]

wait

Who did scum kill

 

[kitsunelaine]

Also if y'all are wondering why I didn't jump in to defend myself while the lynch train was happening, I was asleep. Timezones are a pain.

 

[Fat4all]

wait

Who did scum kill

Sorian

 

[CornBurrito]

Sorian

Did Isacc claim doused?

 

[Fat4all]

Did Isacc claim doused?

they the very first to claim doused, ya?

 

[rac]

Did Isacc claim doused?

on two different days

 

[CornBurrito]

they the very first to claim doused, ya?

Ok just making sure.

In which case, yeah Sorian was killed. Which is a dick move lol.

 

[NeckToChicken]

on two different days

I believe that was just him reaffirming his gassed status (in maybe an inelegant way).

 

[CornBurrito]

6) NeckToChicken [m] (new) - ???
13) franconp [m] - claimed vanilla town I believe
16) Blargonaut - claimed role cop

8) kitsunelaine [f] (new) - claimed vanilla town
12) rac [m] - ???
14) Fat4all [m] - motion detector
15) melonrabbit [f] - ???
17) Kalor [m] - ???
18) CornBurrito [m]" - ???


5 unclaimed, 4 claimed.

Mass role claim?

 

[Blargonaut]

Blarg, necktoneck, what do you two think of a mass role claim right now?

You know how Blarg hates paperwork, so my only stipulation is you get his answer first.

You shut up I fucking love paperwork, I love to fold and staple creases together because I hate using glue to seal my paper cuts

everyone do it

 

[franconp]

So scum killed Sorian.

Why is Blarg still alive?