Support NeoGAF

[CornBurrito]

So scum killed Sorian.

Why is Blarg still alive?

Blarg could theoretically be scum.

 

[CornBurrito]

However, a Blarg lynch is not for today imo.

If Blarg is town, scum will HAVE to kill him before he goes down the list with his power.

 

[CornBurrito]

I am vanilla Town.

Personally I think a role cop balances out the confusion a ton of watchers + sleepwalkers would cause. So I can believe town role cop quite easily. It also made Blarg a huge target for the arsonist so I don't think Blarg would claim role cop after someone claimed doused.

Unless Blarg claimed role cop before someone claimed doused.

 

[NeckToChicken]

Should I claim near the back end so someone has a slightly greater chance to trip up? If not, I could let the birds do the singing and fill in the notes afterwards...

 

[rac]

So scum killed Sorian.

Why is Blarg still alive?

whats your thoughts on a mass claim?

 

[Fat4all]

Should I claim near the back end so someone has a slightly greater chance to trip up? If not, I could let the birds do the singing and fill in the notes afterwards...

if you think that's best, then yeah.

I'm glad I waited until today to claim instead of yesterday, in retrospect.

 

[Blargonaut]

Sorian

 

[Blargonaut]

So scum killed Sorian.

Why is Blarg still alive?

Why are you? I mean, you're the Doctor

 

[Blargonaut]

I'm joking.

Or am I

ahahahaahaha

 

[franconp]

whats your thoughts on a mass claim?

It doesn't seem like a bad idea.

 

[rac]

im vanilla

 

[Kalor]

I'm vanilla town.

At this point I think rac or melonrabbit are scum. I'd had to look at how the other scum interacted with them before voting for one of them. I could see a world where Blarg is scum but I find it unlikely. A role cop makes sense for town.

 

[Fat4all]

fuckin' boring ice cream party up in here

 

[Fat4all]

can't anyone at least be neapolitan town?

 

[Fat4all]

i would certainly like to know why my ability pooped up around melon

 

[franconp]

Looking back at the day 3 votes after the new revelations:

Wee and Kark are tied with Launch close behind. This is 20 minutes before deadline.

Rac change his vote from Wee to Dusk:

Vote: Dusk Soldier

Blarg change his vote from Wee to Launch:

VOTE: LaunchpadMcQ

Fat who haven't voted yet voted Kark:

Vote: Karkador

So, who tried to save Wee there?

 

[Fat4all]

In that situation, rac went from scum to scum, Blarg went from scum to town, and I voted town straight up.

 

[Kalor]

i would certainly like to know why my ability pooped up around melon

I have a good idea but I'd rather hear from melon first.

 

[franconp]

In that situation, rac went from scum to scum, Blarg went from scum to town, and I voted town straight up.

Or: Rac went from one scum close to the lynch to another that didn't had any votes, Blarg went from scum to town and your vote closed the deal on Kark's lynch.

 

[rac]

its not my fault no one on the next day joined me in voting dusk

and i had already tried to jokingly claim neutral to try and help out kark

 

[melonrabbit]

Well, this is an exciting day.

Yes, I am the last scum. Congratulations! Town wins.

Settle down, CB. I am the Town RB.

I blocked you last night, Fat, because I was convinced that you were the arsonist. Clearly, I was wrong.

 

[franconp]

Well, this is an exciting day.

Yes, I am the last scum. Congratulations! Town wins.

Settle down, CB. I am the Town RB.

I blocked you last night, Fat, because I was convinced that you were the arsonist. Clearly, I was wrong.

I would like a list with all your actions so far.

 

[melonrabbit]

I would like a list with all your actions so far.

Fine.

Since I'm outta shots.

I blocked Fat last night and Blarg the prior night.

 

[NeckToChicken]

And now that you've named your targets, I'll finish this claim party.

I'm a gossip. I invite people at night and they're in a chat with me the following night.

Invitee list by night
1: Zubz (corpsed before making it in)
2: Blargonaut
3: CornBurrito
4: Sorian (Whoops)

I told Corn I'd invite melon night 4 but invited Sorian instead because I distrusted him.

I'm curious Blarg, was your vulture comment a call to invite Launch or did I misread that?

 

[Kalor]

Now it's a matter of finding out who's lying. I'm sure Melon is telling the truth about being a roleblocker and who her targets are but their alignment could go either way. I mentioned that I had a good idea earlier on why fats message was the way it was and it was that I suspected someone was a roleblocker.

 

[melonrabbit]

And now that you've named your targets, I'll finish this claim party.

I'm a gossip. I invite people at night and they're in a chat with me the following night.

Invitee list by night
1: Zubz (corpsed before making it in)
2: Blargonaut
3: CornBurrito
4: Sorian (Whoops)

I told Corn I'd invite melon night 4 but invited Sorian instead because I distrusted him.

I'm curious Blarg, was your vulture comment a call to invite Launch or did I misread that?

I'm not totally familiar with a gossip.

So, if I'm understanding correctly. The last person invited can invite the next person?

Also, how did Zubz not make it in when he died D2?

 

[NeckToChicken]

I'm not totally familiar with a gossip.

So, if I'm understanding correctly. The last person invited can invite the next person?

Also, how did Zubz not make it in when he died D2?

I'll elaborate:

I do all the invites (but was taking suggestions in my chat). If I invite someone night X, they show up night X+1. I invited Zubz night 1, but he was dead by night 2 so I got to stew alone for a while.

I also MUST invite someone each night or it is sent at random for me.

 

[NeckToChicken]

For ease of reference, I talked to Blarg night 3 and Corn night 4 (last night).

 

[Fat4all]

i never got an invite

 

[melonrabbit]

OK. Slowly understanding.

For ease of reference, I talked to Blarg night 3 and Corn night 4 (last night).

So you were confident enough in Blarg during the whole Zubz debacle to invite him or simply wanted him close by?

 

[melonrabbit]

i never got an invite

Bro, i feel you. My invited got handed to Sorian of all people.

 

[NeckToChicken]

I Just Decided to take a gamble. When Zubz flipped Night Watch day 2, I figured Blarg night 2 was either scum Blarg living life on the edge or town Blarg in a bind. He wondered if I was a jailer, in his zest to live another day or to know if he could act that night.

Inviting Zubz night 1 may have hastened his death, because he saw me act on him and that possibly lead to his "multiple people" line during day 2.

 

[franconp]

Fine.

Since I'm outta shots.

I blocked Fat last night and Blarg the prior night.

Why did you blocked Blarg?

He was a role cop.

 

[Fat4all]

Yeah, why block Blarg N3? By then he was pretty established to have an ability that's just informative and not negative, all in all.

 

[Fat4all]

Neck is pretty much town through and through at this point, I'm guessing since Corn and Blarg both have Neck as town as well Neck's claim can be corroborated by them.

 

[melonrabbit]

Why did you blocked Blarg?

He was a role cop.

Maybe.

We don't know his alignment and I waned to test him. Especially after he threw out Fran as a Doctor last second.

And I wanted to see what he would say, if anything. I would assume a Cop Town would mention it?

If you notice yesterday, he didn't reveal anything even after saying he would. Merely played around all day.

 

[franconp]

Maybe.

We don't know his alignment and I waned to test him. Especially after he threw out Fran as a Doctor last second.

And I wanted to see what he would say, if anything. I would assume a Cop Town would mention it?

If you notice yesterday, he didn't reveal anything even after saying he would. Merely played around all day.

How? Because the best way to test him would have been letting he post his results the next day to confirm another player. Roleblocking him doesn't help to prove nothing. It's even worse when you had only 2 shots and wasted one like that.

You are right that Blarg didnt said anything. I think he said he got some info at the start of the day but said nothing else.

I think he didn't reveal anything today, right?

 

[Fat4all]

I think he didn't reveal anything today, right?

not yet

 

[rac]

I agree with NecktoNeck being town. But I thought you said franconp was a big fat liar?

Looking at the votes yesterday, I think we can say kitsune is most likely town. Kitsune was at 5 votes. That's too close for comfort for scum to risk. Wee was a vote on kitsune.

You could say "oh its a bus" but wee was doused and we now know that wasnt a ruse. Scum would bus weemad before they would bus an undoused player.

looking back yesterday wee tried to change their vote

vote: acohrs

 

[NeckToChicken]

How? Because the best way to test him would have been letting he post his results the next day to confirm another player. Roleblocking him doesn't help to prove nothing.

I can see the line of thinking: "If I block him tonight and he still gives results tomorrow, then he's Just Lying." Blarg teased some, but I don't think he gave a stone cold result yesterday, barring his end of day "I'm gonna die" reads.

You may have hindered a little plan of ours for yesterday. Blarg and I could have had a little "fight" over him revealing my role that day and see who fell on which side. I was waiting for Blarg to initiate, but he either got cold feet (due to the block) or didn't see enough of a go-ahead from me.

Like Corn says, scum are on a strict time limit if they don't lynch Blarg now. Arsonist panic is over and they seem to have guessed wrong with Lunch.

 

[NeckToChicken]

^ Edit: "You may have hindered" reads better as "melon may have hindered" to make that second bit more clear.

 

[Blargonaut]

My reality is 2-shot

N1: Zubz
N2: franconp
N3: NeckToChicken invited me to Gossip hence I fronted him as another result of mine, suckers

 

[Blargonaut]

 

[rac]

Vote: Blargonaut

 

[rac]

you're the sucker

 

[melonrabbit]

How? Because the best way to test him would have been letting he post his results the next day to confirm another player. Roleblocking him doesn't help to prove nothing. It's even worse when you had only 2 shots and wasted one like that.

You are right that Blarg didnt said anything. I think he said he got some info at the start of the day but said nothing else.

I think he didn't reveal anything today, right?

The only thing thus far we had established as true was Blarg knew Zubz role. The following day he confirms you but then pulls some shady shit with that doctor stuff last second. So, I blocked to see what would happen the following day and he spent the day making promises and the only thing he (seemingly) claimed for fact was that Neck was Vanilla, which if we believe Neck today, we know isn't his role.

I can see the line of thinking: "If I block him tonight and he still gives results tomorrow, then he's Just Lying." Blarg teased some, but I don't think he gave a stone cold result yesterday, barring his end of day "I'm gonna die" reads.

You may have hindered a little plan of ours for yesterday. Blarg and I could have had a little "fight" over him revealing my role that day and see who fell on which side. I was waiting for Blarg to initiate, but he either got cold feet (due to the block) or didn't see enough of a go-ahead from me.

Like Corn says, scum are on a strict time limit if they don't lynch Blarg now. Arsonist panic is over and they seem to have guessed wrong with Lunch.

The bolded, yes. This is what I had hoped to do.

Obviously, I didn't know I was stepping on toes and that you were setting something up.

But that was my thinking at the time.

Now, I want pick up from yesterday and hear from Kit.

Vote: kitsunelaine

 

[NeckToChicken]

I have one more detail about my chat that is important. The contents of my chat remain between nights. Both my guests know this.

What this means is Corn saw everything Blarg left, including Blarg saying he had two shots. Which is why both Corn and I were trying to set the plate for Blarg to keep mum on having two shots why blarg aaaaAAAA

 

[NeckToChicken]

So, I blocked to see what would happen the following day and he spent the day making promises and the only thing he (seemingly) claimed for fact was that Neck was Vanilla, which if we believe Neck today, we know isn't his role.

To his credit, this very well could've been an attempt to protect me (or get me targeted by the arsonist for a cynical view?).

Don't worry about the plan stepping, most of my plans are terrible anyhoo.

 

[Blargonaut]

This is the endgame, secrets don't belong in the endgame

 

[Fat4all]

When I was in the third grade I acted like I read The Count of Monte Cristo for a book report, but I just cheated and copied the one my sister wrote the year before.