• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Katawa Shoujo |OT| (VN, Free, Waifus, etc)

I

iKeepPlaying

Banned
Are there more than 1 ending with every girl?
Cause I just finished my first run, and I got Lilly's route. And I want to know if I have to finish the game again to get another ending with her.
 
J

Jintor

Member
Ah... I think it's a testament to the strength of the writing in all paths that they all seem like incredibly 'correct' choices. I thought that I'd have more trouble... uh... accepting Lilly in this path, but (midway through Act 4) and I'm incredibly, incredibly invested.

There are more than one ending, but they're "Bad Ends" (for a given value of bad)
 
B

Basileus777

Member
iKeepPlaying said:
Are there more than 1 ending with every girl?
Cause I just finished my first run, and I got Lilly's route. And I want to know if I have to finish the game again to get another ending with her.
Click to expand...

Each character has a bad and sometimes also a neutral ending. In Lilly's case
it's not really worth seeing because it's the same as the good ending, except it just cuts off earlier.
IIRC Hanaka and Rin have 3 endings, the rest have 2.
 
V

Venfayth

Member
There's a walkthrough on the official forums, it's a huge diagram that shows all the different endings and the paths you can take to get there (not just the specific answers, it shows all the interconnections and flags and stuff). I would post it but I'm afraid to go to those forums from my work computer :p
 
B

Basileus777

Member
Acullis said:
There's a walkthrough on the official forums, it's a huge diagram that shows all the different endings and the paths you can take to get there (not just the specific answers, it shows all the interconnections and flags and stuff). I would post it but I'm afraid to go to those forums from my work computer :p
Click to expand...

This is the link the to the flowchart you are talking about. Obviously there are potential spoilers, so don't look at routes you haven't completed.
 
J

Jintor

Member
Hanako's development in Lily's route is delicious. The whole thing integrates so well with Hanako's route proper.
 
I

iKeepPlaying

Banned
Dynamite Ringo Matsuri said:
Yes, each girl has got a few bad endings as well. I havent seen one yet, but they are apparently worth seeing as well.
Click to expand...

:eek: Thanks.
And Basileus, I won't read your spoiler for obvious reasons. But I got the ending where
Hisao goes to the airport trying to stop Lilly from going to Scotland. Then he gets a heart attack, and soon after he awakes in a hospital bed, Lilly enter and says that she's going to stay with him.

Which ending is that? I haven't read a single guide or anything. So I don't know if I did something wrong.
 
B

Basileus777

Member
iKeepPlaying said:
:eek: Thanks.
And Basileus, I won't read your spoiler for obvious reasons. But I got the ending where
Hisao goes to the airport trying to stop Lilly from going to Scotland. Then he gets a heart attack, and soon after he awakes in a hospital bed, Lilly enter and says that she's going to stay with him.

Which ending is that? I haven't read a single guide or anything. So I don't know if I did something wrong.
Click to expand...

That's the good ending. You could actually read my spoiler, having seen the good ending already.
The bad ending for Lilly is the same as the good one except it cuts off earlier. There are no new scenes in it.
 
V

Venfayth

Member
iKeepPlaying said:
:eek: Thanks.
And Basileus, I won't read your spoiler for obvious reasons. But I got the ending where
Hisao goes to the airport trying to stop Lilly from going to Scotland. Then he gets a heart attack, and soon after he awakes in a hospital bed, Lilly enter and says that she's going to stay with him.

Which ending is that? I haven't read a single guide or anything. So I don't know if I did something wrong.
Click to expand...

I'm pretty sure that's
the good ending
.

edit: beated :<
 
D

Dynamite Ringo Matsuri

Member
Jintor said:
Oh fuck. God Lily's neutral (bad?) ending. Fuck. Tears everywhere. Oh god.
Click to expand...

Damn... Looks like I'll have to set aside a bit of time tonight to land on her route :\ I really wish OnScripter on iPhone supported this, that would be an amazing way to kill time during downtime. Then again maybe I don't want people to know why I'm sobbing at work lol
 
J

Jintor

Member
It's not actually that bad, but, uh... personal things... brought to the surface.

I broke up with my girlfriend just before New Year's, not over similar reasons or anything, but...

I'm... I'm going to make myself some breakfast, maybe play some Dark Souls, then try again.

Does it seem to anybody else like sometimes the game skips decision points? I can't tell if it's because I'm hitting A too fast and it just takes the first decision for me. I know I did this at least once with Rin and it fucked me over.
 
B

Basileus777

Member
It doesn't skip past decision points even in skip mode, so that's odd. Holding down the ctrl key or anything other than a mouse click on a decision doesn't do anything either.
 
I

iKeepPlaying

Banned
Basileus777 said:
That's the good ending. You could actually read my spoiler, having seen the good ending already.
The bad ending for Lilly is the same as the good one except it cuts off earlier. There are no new scenes in it.
Click to expand...

Acullis said:
I'm pretty sure that's
the good ending
.

edit: beated :<
Click to expand...

Oh, I'm glad! Thanks, both of you. I guess that I won't be playing the game again. I loved Lilly's relationship with Hisao, it resembled a lot to my own life. It was kinda creepy in a way.

BTW, I'm the only one that hated Kenji and seriously disliked Rin? I just couldn't stand those seriously long and irritating monologues of Kenji. And Rin... dunno, I just didn't feel her. Maybe not my cup of tea.
 
J

Jintor

Member
Dynamite Ringo Matsuri said:
That is weird. I've never had it skip past a decision point before.
Click to expand...

Basileus777 said:
It doesn't skip past decision points even in skip mode, so that's odd. Holding down the ctrl key or anything other than a mouse click on a decision doesn't do anything either.
Click to expand...

It feels like it only does it on first readthroughs. I always get them on skipthroughs/catchups. Maybe it's because I'm playing it with a controller.

I kind of like it. It's almost like reading a story, then reading it again and being like "No, Hisao, you fuckup, do this thing instead of the thing you just did automatically!"
 
R

RyougaSaotome

Member
iKeepPlaying said:
BTW, I'm the only one that hated Kenji and seriously disliked Rin? I just couldn't stand those seriously long and irritating monologues of Kenji. And Rin... dunno, I just didn't feel her. Maybe not my cup of tea.
Click to expand...

Did you play her route yet? I liked her as a friend in all of the other routes but I wasn't sure how I was gonna dig anything past that.

I was a mess of man tears last night after finishing it.
 
I

iKeepPlaying

Banned
RyougaSaotome said:
Did you play her route yet? I liked her as a friend in all of the other routes but I wasn't sure how I was gonna dig anything past that.

I was a mess of man tears last night after finishing it.
Click to expand...

Fuck, I just wanted to do one walkthrough... But I'm getting curious about how much the personality of every character "changes" when you pick one or another route.
 
R

RyougaSaotome

Member
iKeepPlaying said:
Fuck, I just wanted to do one walkthrough... But I'm getting curious about how much the personality of every character "changes" when you pick one or another route.
Click to expand...

I would recommend playing all the routes. They're all very different from one another and Hisao's development is completely specific to each path.
 
R

RyougaSaotome

Member
iKeepPlaying said:
Which one is the most similar to Lilly's path? Or if there isn't any similar, which one is the second best?
Click to expand...


This is a hard one to answer because each person will take something different from each path. For me, Emi's pretty much mirrored a relationship with someone very dear to me in the past, so I preferred it most. Shizune's is very different from the rest, focusing more on a three-way friendship. Rin's is an emotional roller coaster. Hanako's is good, but I prefer her development during Lilly's route.
 
J

Jintor

Member
I think Lily as Main Girl would possibly be the best choice for a 'single route'-style anime or manga.

But I also think such a thing would be impossible. IMPOSSIBURU
 
I

iKeepPlaying

Banned
RyougaSaotome said:
This is a hard one to answer because each person will take something different from each path. For me, Emi's pretty much mirrored a relationship with someone very dear to me in the past, so I preferred it most. Shizune's is very different from the rest, focusing more on a three-way friendship. Rin's is an emotional roller coaster. Hanako's is good, but I prefer her development during Lilly's route.
Click to expand...

I know right? (Hanako in Lilly's route spoiler:)
I liked Hanako a lot by the end of Lilly's route.
I think I saw 2 probable outcomes of the social development of Hanako when Lilly and Hisao told her about their relationship.
1.- Hanako would freak out and her social development would go to hell.
2.- Hanako being actually happy for the couple and starting to be more outgoing.
And I'm really glad that she went with number 2. Although... I wouldn't mind seeing number 1.

I think I will do Emi's route next.
 
G

Garcia el Gringo

Member
I really want to see for myself why everyone is having extra feels for Rin. So I'm about to start her route asap. I want to release the manly tears that I couldn't quite get out in Hanako's route.

Then I'll check out Emi, Shizune and the bad/good endings I missed.

I'm looking forward to Lilly's route the most, so I'm thinking of saving her for last to end on a good note. Is that a good idea?
 
I

iKeepPlaying

Banned
Garcia el Gringo said:
I really want to see for myself why everyone is having extra feels for Rin. So I'm about to start her route asap. I want to release the manly tears that I couldn't quite get out in Hanako's route.

Then I'll check out Emi, Shizune and the bad/good endings I missed.

I'm looking forward to Lilly's route the most, so I'm thinking of saving her for last to end on a good note. Is that a good idea?
Click to expand...

Yeah, she's the waifu among waifus.
 
R

RyougaSaotome

Member
Garcia el Gringo said:
I really want to see for myself why everyone is having extra feels for Rin. So I'm about to start her route asap. I want to release the manly tears that I couldn't quite get out in Hanako's route.

Then I'll check out Emi, Shizune and the bad/good endings I missed.

I'm looking forward to Lilly's route the most, so I'm thinking of saving her for last to end on a good note. Is that a good idea?
Click to expand...

I think Lilly's is arguably the best route to end on. Shizune's sort of has an overall sense of closure, but it's a bit bittersweet/melancholy?
 
D

Dynamite Ringo Matsuri

Member
iKeepPlaying said:
Fuck, I just wanted to do one walkthrough... But I'm getting curious about how much the personality of every character "changes" when you pick one or another route.
Click to expand...

It's not just the characters that change, Hisao himself changes. As Jintor mentioned, Act 1 seems to be about establishing what kind of person Hisao is, and that change is carried over to whichever girl he pursues. And the characters are much deeper than they appear obviously. Rin appears to be laconic and wishy washy, but there's a damn good reason (and a really sad one at that) as to why she's like that.

SteveO409 said:
So much emotions playing this game....god damn 2012 game of the year
Click to expand...
Moar like GAME OF THE FOREVER. I kid, but yeah, this will likely be my 2012 game of the year, unless Bioshock Infinite or The Last of Us will blow my mind and bring the feels. I just can't see anything else affecting me this much.

Jintor said:
I think Lily as Main Girl would possibly be the best choice for a 'single route'-style anime or manga.

But I also think such a thing would be impossible. IMPOSSIBURU
Click to expand...
I reject this sentiment. Ojousama does nothing for me. NASINGU
 
J

Jintor

Member
She wasn't doing anything for me until the end of the third act, it's true!

I have to try whatsit. To The Moon. I need to see if that's as good as KS. Or maybe the other way around.
 
P

Proven

Member
Just finished Hanako's route. The endings beforehand were described to me as good, ok, and bad.

But the "ok" ending is just as bad as the "bad" ending! Misstep is obviously something horrible, but the point that should have been learned after her good ending is that she doesn't want to be treated as a thing to be protected! The other ending, Cut Petals, is just as horrible as the way you treat her in Misstep, the only difference is that her reaction is in the opposite direction! Instead of pushing you away for treating her like that, she resigns to be treated like that for the rest of her life, even from someone that she wanted to be different for her! How can anyone call that "ok"?

Rant over. My final runthrough will be for Rin, the one I liked the most after first impressions.

RyougaSaotome said:
I think Lilly's is arguably the best route to end on. Shizune's sort of has an overall sense of closure, but it's a bit bittersweet/melancholy?
Click to expand...
I'd say Shizune's best to end on, if only because at the end of the day you can't take these girls with you. They leave you with an experience to be treasured, for sure, but you still have to move on with your life without them.
 
J

Jintor

Member
Yeah, I do find the "I'm in love with a 2d character" things weird. I mean... this is about Hisao and whoever, not you and whoever. It's easy to conflate the two, but it's something I automatically step around.
 
D

Dynamite Ringo Matsuri

Member
Jintor said:
Yeah, I do find the "I'm in love with a 2d character" things weird. I mean... this is about Hisao and whoever, not you and whoever. It's easy to conflate the two, but it's something I automatically step around.
Click to expand...

Clearly your resolve is weak, and you are not hasubando material. ;)

I'm sure no one here is actually in love with any of these characters and is planning to marry their computer or some shit. The characters just endear themselves to you in the same manner as some players might find with Alyx of HL or April Ryan of Longest Journey.


And the preview for To the Moon at ShackNews was pretty interesting. It seems kind of like Eternal Sunshine in a way. I dig the 16 bit pixel art, but part of me is skeptical in that the artwork is too limited in supplementing/conveying emotion, so the onus is then on the quality of the storytelling. Still, very interesting, and at 4 hours, not a timesink thankfully.
 
J

Jintor

Member
Dynamite Ringo Matsuri said:
I'm sure no one here is actually in love with any of these characters and is planning to marry their computer or some shit. The characters just endear themselves to you in the same manner as some players might find with Alyx of HL or April Ryan of Longest Journey.
Click to expand...

I just keep forgetting to put my /v/ and /a/ filters on.
 
R

RyougaSaotome

Member
Proven said:
I'd say Shizune's best to end on, if only because at the end of the day you can't take these girls with you. They leave you with an experience to be treasured, for sure, but you still have to move on with your life without them.
Click to expand...

I think I liked the idea of Shizune's ending over the execution of it.
I felt like Hisao and Shizune never really clicked, and the whole him telling her he loves her felt awkward, especially without a response from Shizune. Because the whole story was more about the drama of three friends, I never felt like Hisao ever really opened himself up to any of them because he was so busy trying to find a way to be there for the both of them. After I finished it, it just didn't feel as satisfying or filled with closure as Lilly's did I guess.

Closure in terms of graduation, definitely. Just not anything else.
 
P

Proven

Member
RyougaSaotome said:
I think I liked the idea of Shizune's ending over the execution of it.
I felt like Hisao and Shizune never really clicked, and the whole him telling her he loves her felt awkward, especially without a response from Shizune. Because the whole story was more about the drama of three friends, I never felt like Hisao ever really opened himself up to any of them because he was so busy trying to find a way to be there for the both of them. After I finished it, it just didn't feel as satisfying or filled with closure as Lilly's did I guess.

Closure in terms of graduation, definitely. Just not anything else.
Click to expand...

More or less agree. Still, afterward I felt a lot more fond of Shizune. I think it's in part because it reminded me of a friend I was close to in high school, and how we graduated. When I finish all the routes and rate them, I'm guessing that Shizune won't be last for me.
 
R

RyougaSaotome

Member
I can't even imagine how 4LS must be feeling right now with the kinds of reactions they're getting from this game.

To say that a lot of people like it seems like an understatement.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Visual Novels |OT| "I am the bone of my sword..." ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) GAF Visual Novel Community
|OT| Community
0
1K
Komatsu replied
Manor Lords |Early Access OT| Good manors are made up of peasant sacrifices
|OT| Indie 2
81
6K
Rentahamster replied
ASUS ROG ALLY | OT + Review Thread | Steam Deck but ROGher
Analysis Review Hardware 9 10 11 12 13
605
57K
MacReady13 replied
Picross |OT| Nonograms and Numbers and Nonsense
35
3K
Maiden Voyage replied
Life is Strange: Double Exposure | Review Thread
Analysis Review
17
1K
rkofan87 replied
Top Bottom