The Kodansha's Learner guide seems pretty good to me to learn Kanji from. The vocab for new Kanji only uses Kanji you've already learnt, which streamlines things and saves time, it sorts the vocabulary by meaning and it tells you which words are common and worth memorising. I'm about 500 Kanji in at the moment. Still 1,800 to go...
I agree with most of what you said but wut. うえ isn't written as 上え, it's just plain old 上。And Ive seen 上 by itself plenty of times. Although you probably mean that it's more common to combine it with other words/kanji in which case I agree with you.
Speaking of which, I've been doing my own version of whiteboard, substituting Genki's kana vocab for the full kanji versions. It means I'm learning stuff like 国際関係 before some more essential things, but I'm having fun with it.Kanji and the whiteboard method are straight up taking lives in that last page, RIP, Kilrogg post if you are okay
And aren't you taking classes in Japan?There's a girl in class with who's always complaining when the teacher gives a an article written in Japanese (the class is like half English/half Japanese) and she never makes an effort to read it. "Oooh but it's too hard. I don't have enough vocabulary!"
Yeah no shit, then read the thing and pick up new words while doing so. Drives me nuts lol
Do you guys know any YouTube channel where it's just some Japanese person talking to the camera about anything, preferably with Japanese subtitles? Been watching Bobby Judo's videos, but he kinda noticeably has an accent (well, he's American, duh), so not that good for shadowing... and the subtitles are in English.
I didn't get an opportunity to study Hiragana and Katakana before the lesson, but need to get on that now as our homework is to memorise and recognise the first 15 Hiragana, so a-so.
Does anyone have some good tips on methods for that? I've never really studied symbol recognition like this before.
I didn't get an opportunity to study Hiragana and Katakana before the lesson, but need to get on that now as our homework is to memorise and recognise the first 15 Hiragana, so a-so.
Does anyone have some good tips on methods for that? I've never really studied symbol recognition like this before.
The teacher did mention most of the focus would be on Hiragana during the course, with some Katakana but no real study of the Kanji. It is only a 9 week beginner course though so some compromises have to be made somewhere.
99% of Japanese shows come with Japanese "subtitles" (they're called テロップ in TV lingo) out of the gate, including the news. They're not subtitles in the traditional sense that they show every single word the speaker says, but they do show the most important things the speaker is saying. They also "dress up" the テロップ to pretty good effect (like using decorative fonts). They're not only good for following along, they're also very good for practicing and learning kanji.
So I say, just go straight to the source: Japanese TV.
Kanji and the whiteboard method are straight up taking lives in that last page, RIP, Kilrogg post if you are okay
Google Japanese TV
Fifth hit is a reddit sub called Japanese TV
Download a Firefox or chrome plugin that downloads videos off daily motion or YouTube or whatever
Download VLC
Double click the video file
Say what now? I'm still alive and kicking, brah.
Though I'll admit I'm skipping today, we were doing an afterwork party and I had to stay until late. I'm exhausted, going to bed. Thank God I don't have anything special tomorrow evening + the whole weekend to make up for tonight's laziness.
Despite this early hiccup, I'm quite pleased with how I'm able to keep this up for now. Self-motivation and self-study have never been my forte, but for once I feel like I can really do it.
Say what now? I'm still alive and kicking, brah.
Though I'll admit I'm skipping today, we were doing an afterwork party and I had to stay until late. I'm exhausted, going to bed. Thank God I don't have anything special tomorrow evening + the whole weekend to make up for tonight's laziness.
Despite this early hiccup, I'm quite pleased with how I'm able to keep this up for now. Self-motivation and self-study have never been my forte, but for once I feel like I can really do it.
Just keep in mind that at some point your writing list will grow out of control and you'll need to cull older words. I'm convinced expert is a mutant from outer space 'cause you'd need to write each word in 2 seconds without ever slowing down to finish a writing list of >5,000 words in 3 hours haha
I had trouble getting faster than 8 seconds / word. My best time was 7.3 s/word. Which means it'd have taken me 10 hours to write 5k words haha
you can do it. just dont skip any more days/add another 5 kanji per day for the next week to make up for the lost day.
drop 2 of the 3 words when you're 3/5 days past the day. EG at Day 5 you can write 1 word for Days 1 and 2, but D3, 4, 5 you need to write them all
8 seconds is way too slow, granted i had that fear at one point. after a month you should get fast enough, you also need to learn to write faster too.
Kanji is difficult. I used to learn them one by one, but I really get way more out of Kanji if I write them in a sentence. How I do it is take an article (I use satori reader) and copy out the whole article in Japanese then I translate it line by line over and over until I can say it in Japanese and say it in English. Here is an article I just finished learning:
明子の日記、留学一日目。
待ちに待った留学一日目。東京から直行便でアメリカのシアトルへ。ドキドキの一日だった。ホストファミリ-が空港まで迎え来てくれていて、さっきホスト宅に到着した。家の中を案内されて、夕食を一緒に食べて、私の部屋に案内された。ホストマザーのジンジャーさんとホストファーザーのスコットさん、二人ともすごく親切そう。二人の子供達も、とても可愛い!食卓での会話は英語が速すぎて全く理解できなかったんだけど、わたし、大丈夫なんだろうか?やっていけるんだろうか?超、不安。夢見てやって来たはいいものの、アメリカで一年間も!ひょえ~、とんでもないことをしたような気もする。でも、頑張らないと!今日は疲れたので、寝ます。
Sorry if it's a little difficult to read. I find this a much more effective way to learn Kanji and Japanese in general (at least for me).
Google Japanese TV
Fifth hit is a reddit sub called Japanese TV
Download a Firefox or chrome plugin that downloads videos off daily motion or YouTube or whatever
Download VLC
Double click the video file
Why do you do the English translation? Not a criticism of what works for you, but I'm just wondering what purpose it serves at that point.
N1ゲットしたぜ!
Language Knowledge (Vocabulary/Grammar) 33 / 60
Reading 48 / 60
Listening 31 / 60
Not thrilled with my score, but for what was intended as a trial run before the real deal in July? Holy shit! Unless I have scheduling issues I'll be planning to sit it again in four months. Expecting much better this time!
Took my test in Berlin, Germany and can't even find where to check... I'm so curious (¯―¯٥
N1ゲットしたぜ!
Language Knowledge (Vocabulary/Grammar) 33 / 60
Reading 48 / 60
Listening 31 / 60
Not thrilled with my score, but for what was intended as a trial run before the real deal in July? Holy shit! Unless I have scheduling issues I'll be planning to sit it again in four months. Expecting much better this time!
N1ゲットしたぜ!
Language Knowledge (Vocabulary/Grammar) 33 / 60
Reading 48 / 60
Listening 31 / 60
Not thrilled with my score, but for what was intended as a trial run before the real deal in July? Holy shit! Unless I have scheduling issues I'll be planning to sit it again in four months. Expecting much better this time!
as a recovering Heisig patient, my current belief is that separating learning the kanji from learning the readings results in a massive waste of time.
i went through the whole method, learned everything, and yes, i can say i "know" the official list kanji in that i can recognize, write, and give a base meaning.
that "knowledge" is basically useless though since you can't read with it.
i am now going through the much more difficult process of getting all the readings for each of those kanji, and right now it makes the time spent on heisig feel so wasted. i've made a deck with all of the official list kanji, and for each card, i look up the kanji in the Kodansha Learner's Dictionary (discussed on this page) and add vocabulary for the readings. basically the front of the card is vocabulary illustrating all the readings, the back has the kana, english definition for the vocab. it was a pretty easy deck to make in anki. i'll be done by the end of the summer, barring major setbacks.
i don't know what the right answer is though. the guys here swear by the "whiteboard method" but that is a learning method & time commitment that do not mesh with my life. tofugu.com offers wanikani that essentially merges a variation of heisig with learning readings at the same time (but the downside is that it's a subscription service). kodansha publishes a learner's course that does the same thing - learn kanji plus readings.
as for the others, i have nothing but good things to say about genki I and II. i like a textbook for organized study and genki fit the bill. i'm ready to take the training wheels off and move to Tobira (all in Japanese).
read the links (maybe they're in the OP) about the whiteboard method (and the link to the listening method someone posted recently) because even if you're like me and don't want to use those, there's still a lot of useful information that will help you study.
the 3 Grammar books (Basic, Intermediate, and Advanced) are consider essential, but you can start with Basic
Tae Kim's Guide to Japanese is still free online and absolutely worth using as supplement to whatever text you use.
Thanks for the response!
Your opinion on Heisig is kind of more or less what I was always afraid of when I jumped into it. It obviously works for a lot of folks but I'm not sure if it's for me necessarily. The whiteboard method doesn't really work for my schedule (I literally do not have that much time some days after work), but is probably something I would have definitely done 15-20 years ago.
Genki seems to be very popular (IIRC it's the top recommendation on reddit), but Kodansha also seems very interesting with it striking somewhat of a middle ground between Heisig and more conventional methods so I'm leaning towards one of those two.
What are the 3 grammar books you're referring to?
If you're okay with stuff that's only slightly sketch and don't mind paying, I can PM you a good place to start.I tried watching some Japanese TV a while ago, but I could only find some sketchy streaming sites. Is it on some japanese Youtube equivalent? The ability to pause and rewind is too important to me.
genki serves a different purpose, teaching you vocabulary and grammar. it's very hand-holding but i appreciated that at first. if you're going to take the book approach (like i do) you'll want a text for grammar/vocab and separate text for kanji. but you can totally skip buying genki at first to save money and just rely on Tae Kim's site for now.
the 3 grammar guides are the Basic, Intermediate, and Advanced Dictionary of Japanese Grammar. Basically just filled with exhausting detail on the grammar points for those levels. tofugu review here: https://www.tofugu.com/reviews/dictionary-of-basic-japanese-grammar/
N1ゲットしたぜ!
Language Knowledge (Vocabulary/Grammar) 33 / 60
Reading 48 / 60
Listening 31 / 60
Not thrilled with my score, but for what was intended as a trial run before the real deal in July? Holy shit! Unless I have scheduling issues I'll be planning to sit it again in four months. Expecting much better this time!
I'm confused on how the scoring for the JLPT works. I read that you need 19/60 for all three areas, but how are these points calculated?
Ah okay that makes sense. So just as an example you could do something like Genki (Vocab/Grammar) + Kodansha (Kanji) and then supplement those two with the grammar guides, Kanji learner guide, websites etc? Can you tell I've never learned another language before? (I'm okay at ASL/SE but I feel like that doesn't count)
If you're okay with stuff that's only slightly sketch and don't mind paying, I can PM you a good place to start.
Whiteboard people, how did you guys approach grammar with it? I'm having trouble knowing what would be important to put as a memory trigger (just a "____masu" thing or an example sentence too?). Do you guys also try to remember exceptions to a rule?
Whiteboard people, how did you guys approach grammar with it? I'm having trouble knowing what would be important to put as a memory trigger (just a "____masu" thing or an example sentence too?). Do you guys also try to remember exceptions to a rule?
A little late but I just passed N3. That's after doing Genki I and II in a classroom setting, but Genki II was done during my year in Japan. Also, I didn't study at all for two years between completing Genki I and starting Genki II.
I should be able to pass N2 in December. Hopefully I'll be in Japan at that time on the JET Program.