- I think this show just got sadder and sadder with each season. This was by far the saddest season. I hope the writers are happy...
- I was rather dissatisfied with how little Arnold was in it. I was hoping that he'd show up at at some point at the end, like Geoffrey did for Season 1's funeral, but I guess in some way, it just makes sense. Sometimes, after a breakup, that person is just gone from your life, even after months together. Still weird because Arnold knew Rose from the psych hospital... I hope Arnold got closure off-camera. Still, we didn't even see Josh's reaction to Arnold's voicemail about him dating someone new. They seemingly dated for a really significant amount of time, so it was odd how quickly he left the picture. This is compared to Geoffrey who can't seem to leave the picture. At the same time, if it was an intentional narrative decision, it makes sense and feels realistic.
- Speaking of Geoffrey, I'm really glad they acknowledged that Josh and him simply aren't compatible (probably to address people who really liked Josh with Geoffrey)
- I know they kind of introduced it in Season 3, but Arnold really became a character associated with his sex drive for me by the end of this season.
- Claire was unusually absent, too, but I guess they needed someone to fulfill the role of someone who doesn't know how to handle someone else's grief.
- Josh is a surprisingly good actor. I'm not sure why I find that surprising, but I do.
- I wonder what was in Rose's suicide letter to Josh (I'm pretty sure the note said "Josh," yeah?), but I guess it ultimately wouldn't be anything surprising or something that we needed to hear. I'd have liked to know that Josh at least read it, though.
- I really liked that they addressed the weird mystery of never saying what Alan's dad did but him being very wealthy and always working.
- When Josh said that the last few conversations he had with his mom made him wonder if she had been saying goodbye, I tried to think if I just hadn't been picking up on it. But I don't think it was in the writing of the previous episodes and he was referring to conversations off-screen.
- This season had the sense of closure I was looking for from the other seasons, but it was not a happy closure.
- I could see this being the last season because of that closure, but I hope it's not because I'd like something happier and hopeful.
- I'm sad that they changed sets for the houses.
- I couldn't believe how much Rose's house was sold for, but I guess those were Australian dollars and not US ones.
- This season had me feeling...bleak. Claire randomly disappeared (with the only explanation given being a particularly dark one from Arnold), Rose died, and everyone broke up. The only happy ending was maybe Hannah? But really, it seemed rather hopeless.
- I'd like a happy and optimistic Season 5 (with some drama and downs, of course), and for the show to wrap up there.
- If I had to pick someone from the existing cast for Josh to end up with, I think I'd most prefer Patrick because he has the most connection with and least baggage with Josh. They felt like a right place but wrong time kind of deal. I'd also be content with it being Arnold or a new character introduced next season.