but then i kind of hesitate to recommend it, since the review scores are low, and it might be one of those games most people won't "get."
i thought lament was pretty decent, personally, but i lost interest about halfway through. i should get back to it at some point. it exceeded my extremely low expectations, anyway.
I'll second Wario's recommendation of ZOE2. I'll also suggest Legacy of Kain: Defiance. Its a little rough around the edges but is a suitable DMC clone, definately better than DMC2.