• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Magic: The Gathering |OT|

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bought my box today but am going to parcel the packs out over the next few weeks for fun drafts with friends. For $115 a box, you better believe I'm going to get as much enjoyment out of this as I can.

If I could afford a box, that's what I'd do. Do some drafts for my little group and any left over packs might be prizes for the draft matches.
 
Bought my box today but am going to parcel the packs out over the next few weeks for fun drafts with friends. For $115 a box, you better believe I'm going to get as much enjoyment out of this as I can.

Not a bad idea. I've been toying with the idea of going halves or thirds on a box and splitting up the cards each of us want but this sounds like a much better way of doing it.
 
Bought a fat pack today. Pulled a Mizzium Mortars, Vraska the Unseen, foil Abrupt Decay, and I'm pretty sure the other cards ain't even worth mentioning. Foil was nice but the only issue I have is finding someone to trade for it. ;[

*edit: yeah we are going to draft this Thursday with a personal box. Too bad I didn't buy the box. It came with a Supreme Verdict.
 
If you pretended that it was a curse that said "Deal 6 damage to target player unless he or she sacrifcies a creature", and couldn't be tutored up by other curses or Bitterheart witch. Yes, it would.
 
bonfire for 3 wipes the board except the 7/7 champion, next turn top decks a geralf's to do lethal after an alpha strike.

Yup, that's what bonfire does. lol.

So after casting Bonfire, he tried to cast Gravecrawler from the graveyard but wasn't able to even with one black mana open. Why was that?
 
For Standard? Nobody really knows yet.

There's been exactly one notable tournament since rotation. Not exactly a huge sample size, but it's a place to start:
http://sales.starcitygames.com//dec...te=2012-10-07&end_date=2012-10-07&event_ID=19

And these guys are always brewing stuff up:
http://forums.mtgsalvation.com/forumdisplay.php?f=716

Don't be fooled there, of course. Just because it says "Competitive" doesn't mean the deck is any good. All the "Competitive" forum really means is that you're not allowed to take budget into account when discussing deck builds.
 
I just opened the worst box ever :(

Mythic:

Necropolis Regent
Angel of Serenity

Notable Rares:

2x Deathrite Shaman (1 foil)
Detention Sphere
Temple Garden
Overgrown Tomb
Blood Crypt

Everything else was marginal or below $3 on coolstuffinc.

Sigh.
 
I just opened the worst box ever :(

Mythic:

Necropolis Regent
Angel of Serenity

Notable Rares:

2x Deathrite Shaman (1 foil)
Detention Sphere
Temple Garden
Overgrown Tomb
Blood Crypt

Everything else was marginal or below $3 on coolstuffinc.

Sigh.

What were you looking for?
Would love to try and get the foil Shaman off of you. I am determned to make it the MVP of the set.
Regent does suck.
Angel is not bad, I am on the fence about wanting to pick two up or not
 
What were you looking for?
Would love to try and get the foil Shaman off of you. I am determned to make it the MVP of the set.
Regent does suck.
Angel is not bad, I am on the fence about wanting to pick two up or not

I'm actually playing a Junk Reanimator deck :)

Playing Deathrite Shaman as a 3 of! Did some playtesting with it on Cockatrice and it seems like LOADS of fun, and can do ridiculous things.

Turn 1 Arbor Elf
Turn 2 Grisly Salvage + Deathrite Shaman
Turn 3 Jarad's Orders
Turn 4 Unburial Rites Worldspine Wurm

Just an example of something that happened yesterday :>

I'm not sure what I need yet cause my friend owes me some cards. When I know exactly what I'm missing, I'll post here and maybe we can find some trades.
 
I'm actually playing a Junk Reanimator deck :)

Playing Deathrite Shaman as a 3 of! Did some playtesting with it on Cockatrice and it seems like LOADS of fun, and can do ridiculous things.

Turn 1 Arbor Elf
Turn 2 Grisly Salvage + Deathrite Shaman
Turn 3 Jarad's Orders
Turn 4 Unburial Rites Worldspine Wurm

Just an example of something that happened yesterday :>

I'm not sure what I need yet cause my friend owes me some cards. When I know exactly what I'm missing, I'll post here and maybe we can find some trades.

Sounds good to me
 
I'm actually playing a Junk Reanimator deck :)

Playing Deathrite Shaman as a 3 of! Did some playtesting with it on Cockatrice and it seems like LOADS of fun, and can do ridiculous things.

Turn 1 Arbor Elf
Turn 2 Grisly Salvage + Deathrite Shaman
Turn 3 Jarad's Orders
Turn 4 Unburial Rites Worldspine Wurm

Just an example of something that happened yesterday :>

I'm not sure what I need yet cause my friend owes me some cards. When I know exactly what I'm missing, I'll post here and maybe we can find some trades.

Not to be a dick, but have you actually read Worldspine Wurm?
 
Even without that clause it's really that good of a reanimiation target compared to Angel of Serenity / Griselbrand / that green 7 life one as it does nothing against a lot of sorcery speed removal. It's solid with Sneak Attack / Through the Breach though.
 
Even without that clause it's really that good of a reanimiation target compared to Angel of Serenity / Griselbrand / that green 7 life one as it does nothing against a lot of sorcery speed removal. It's solid with Sneak Attack / Through the Breach though.

I'm really hoping someone brings a Through the Breach deck to PTRTR and puts up a good result with it.

Yeah, I'm playing 2x (probably 3x w/o worldspine wurm) angel of serenity, griselbrand, and 2x armada wurm.

There's a lot of debate about whether or not Griselbrand is actually a good reanimation target in standard or not. Drawing 7 cards is nice and all, but it's not nearly the beating it is in Legacy where you have the very real chance of drawing a Force of Will to counter the spell that's trying to kill Griselbrand. I've heard very reasonable arguments for playing Craterhoof Behemoth instead, especially if you're running a version of the deck that's heavy on mana dorks.
 
Cleaning lady at work saw all the pack wrappers from the box I opened in the garbage can.

She says to me: "You should not eat so much candy. It is bad for you."

;_;
 
Cleaning lady at work saw all the pack wrappers from the box I opened in the garbage can.

She says to me: "You should not eat so much candy. It is bad for you."

;_;

LOL

There's a big Magic tournament in Austin this weekend. I'm going to try to get Saturday off and go play with either Jund/BG/RB Zombies or Red Deck Wins. Anyone else planning to go to Texas State Championships 2012?
 
3xAVR draft, opened up an Entreat.

\o/

Now to put together my bomby (but otherwise awful) R/W humans deck.
 
3xAVR draft, opened up an Entreat.

\o/

Now to put together my bomby (but otherwise awful) R/W humans deck.

R/W humans was the only archetype I liked in 3xAVR. And as you say, it's not that good. If you assemble the pieces you can do some insane stuff (Goldnight Commander + Thatcher Revolt is crazy awesome).

But man - what a terrible, terrible limited format that was. Even though there's much more money potential in drafting that set over M13, I just can't bring myself to draft it.
 
I have a bunch of humans, Silverblade Paladin and Entreat the angels and I'm going to ride that to victory.

Won the first game, total blow out. Some slow UB deck that ran Taskmaster.

(He used Stolen Goods and stole my Silverblade Paladin but he had to sacrifice it next turn lolololol)
 
I just opened the worst box ever :(

Mythic:

Necropolis Regent
Angel of Serenity

Notable Rares:

2x Deathrite Shaman (1 foil)
Detention Sphere
Temple Garden
Overgrown Tomb
Blood Crypt

Everything else was marginal or below $3 on coolstuffinc.

Sigh.

I feel your pain on the mythics my man. Got those same two and a Niv. Whoopdie doo. Bad box is bad. My rares were similar as well, though I did get an Abrupt Decay.

I still have 3 packs I'm saving to draft. Doubt anything is worth anything in them. I don't think I'm paying as much as I did for a box next time -- this one soured me hard.
 
Oh shit, I just realized I'm doing 4-3-2-2 and not Swiss.

Decklist:

2 x Cathedral Sanctifier
1 x Midnight Duelist
1 x Somberwald Vigilante

2 x Kruin Striker
1 x Moorland Inquisitor
1 x Falkenrath Exterminator
1 x Lightning Mauler
1 x Thunderbolt
1 x Thraben Valient

1 x Emancipation Angel (I have no idea why she's in my deck)
1 x Entreat the Angels
1 x Silverblade Paladin
1 x Riot Ringleader
1 x Kessig Malcontents
1 x Angelic Armaments
1 x Thatcher Revolt

1 x Heirs of Stromkirk
1 x Havengul Vampire
1 x Vigilante Justice

1 x Spectral Gateguards
1 x Burn at the Stake

9 x Mountains
7 x Plains
1 x Seraph Sanctuary

Lost game 2, because I had to mull to 5.
 
Just finally finished up my Bant deck that I've been messing around with since release. Haven't gotten the chance to test it yet, but I will be tomorrow.

4x Avacyn's Pilgrim
2x Loxodon Smiter
3x Silverblade Paladin
3x Restoration Angel
2x Trostani, Selesnya's Voice
3x Thragtusk
3x Sigarda, Host of Herons
2x Armada Wurm
2x Deadeye Navigator

3x Abundant Growth
3x Rancor
4x Selesnya Charm
3x Cackling Counterpart

3x Temple Garden
4x Sunpetal Grove
3x Glacial Fortress
3x Hinterland Harbor
5x Forest
3x Plains
2x Island

I want to get +1 Loxodon Smiter and go down to only 2x Sigarda, probably. We'll see how it plays tomorrow.

Would also like a few Geist of Saint Trafts for the deck, but I exhausted my supply of readily available trades at the moment :P
 
A little weird that the thread's so slow so soon after release. I bought a case. I know. What an idiot. I was stoked though. A bunch of retired MtG friends and I got together this past Saturday and drafted 3 of the boxes. Through some luck, I wound up with a full set of Jace, and now's the scramble to try and trade stuff like Abrupt Decay while they're big money.

Drafting this set is difficult. It's very easy for me to be non-committal and take the best card in the pack even halfway through pack 2, and that's led to some really terrible 4-color aggro decks a few times. The coolest deck I saw drafted was my friend who first picked Sphinx of the Chimes, grabbed a Wild Beastmaster a few picks later, and went on to draft every copy of Giant Growth and Common Bond he saw from that point forward. The deck sucked, but he did manage to draw 8 extra cards in a turn once. In limited!
 
I'm really hoping someone brings a Through the Breach deck to PTRTR and puts up a good result with it.



There's a lot of debate about whether or not Griselbrand is actually a good reanimation target in standard or not. Drawing 7 cards is nice and all, but it's not nearly the beating it is in Legacy where you have the very real chance of drawing a Force of Will to counter the spell that's trying to kill Griselbrand. I've heard very reasonable arguments for playing Craterhoof Behemoth instead, especially if you're running a version of the deck that's heavy on mana dorks.

Eh, maybe less with mana leak and stuff gone now but I think Griselbrand is still a crazy card if you can cheat him out. He's huge whether it's a kill spell, a counter, or anything else you need to dig for. I've won a good amount of games after digging twice for a kill spell or similar.
 
I feel like the MTGO beta client is almost a step backwards from the current client.

It may look prettier but it's so clunky.
 
I think I am the only guy at the hobby shop that pronounces it 'mah-na', everyone including the owner says 'man-a'. Just looked it up and it seems I may be correct. I personally do not care how anyone says it, but which is the real deal? Or does everyone say it different?

Also it seems Thragtusk has gone up in price, was 12, now 17 plus. Sold out at a few places. Was going to buy 3.
 
I think I am the only guy at the hobby shop that pronounces it 'mah-na', everyone including the owner says 'man-a'. Just looked it up and it seems I may be correct. I personally do not care how anyone says it, but which is the real deal? Or does everyone say it different?

Also it seems Thragtusk has gone up in price, was 12, now 17 plus. Sold out at a few places. Was going to buy 3.

I say "man-a", a couple of my friends say "mah-na", I've never really noticed until you pointed this out.
 
He had no other zombies in play.

Late response but that makes sense.

LOL

There's a big Magic tournament in Austin this weekend. I'm going to try to get Saturday off and go play with either Jund/BG/RB Zombies or Red Deck Wins. Anyone else planning to go to Texas State Championships 2012?

Would love to check it out, but unfortunately I gotta apt hunt this weekend. Blah!

I think I am the only guy at the hobby shop that pronounces it 'mah-na', everyone including the owner says 'man-a'. Just looked it up and it seems I may be correct. I personally do not care how anyone says it, but which is the real deal? Or does everyone say it different?

Also it seems Thragtusk has gone up in price, was 12, now 17 plus. Sold out at a few places. Was going to buy 3.

I say 'man-a'. I always mispronounce Merfolk though and keep saying 'Melfork' for some reason lol.
I'm seeing Thragtusk for $15 at scg.com. May be a decent purchase to just buy the Gogari event deck for $25. Comes with Thragtusk ($15), Woodland Cemetary ($15) and Wolfir Silverheart ($4).
 
I'm going with either

V4ky3.jpg
or
kLjib.jpg


for states. I think the RB version looks better.

Edit: 2x Torch Fiend are coming out of the sideboard for something else. Maybe Appetite for Brains.

Edit 2: We should really make a MTG GAF IRC channel
 
I like the RB list too. If only for Aristocrat. She adds a lot, I think.

Has there been any discussion in here about Cyclonic Rift since release? I've been busy and out of the loop, but I'm thinking of adding it to my bant list later this afternoon.
 
Why does it cost so much? Do you have several mystic rares in it that cost $40/$50 a card?

8 shocklands, each of which are going for $10-$15, 7 mythics which are going for $15-20 each, and a ton of RTR rares which range from $5-15.

Mostly right now it's because the bulk of the cards are from RTR and this is a horrible time to be buying RTR rares :p

edit:

Sure, lets do a gaf mtg channel :)

I have no idea how to use IRC beyond joining and chatting, but we can use this one (irc.globalgamers.net #gafmtg) since this is the server that the gaf fighting game channel is on.

Just click this and pick a nick to join

http://widget01.mibbit.com/?server=irc.globalgamers.net&channel=#gafmtg
 
Had pretty good luck on my boxes. I didn't open a single Beastmistress though. Got every other card I wanted in playsets though. Sold all but 1 Jace and Vraska immediately.
 
Yeah, prices are ludicrous right now.

Armada Wurm at $15+? No way.

It doesn't help that so many "staple" cards in RTR are rare, either.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom