• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Man dies 1 week after violent Baltimore police encounter.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Enzom21

Member
I would love to know the other very real possibilities.

I would like to know this as well. I am sure it has something to do with the victim not forgiving or properly educating these cops.

Really? Are we really play this game that you dislike me so much even though I agree 99% this is police brutality I still have some other agenda?
What does liking you have to do with anything? He asked you a question because you posted this.

There's a very real possibility something else transpired. Given on what is known it's most likely police the brutalized him. There could be an outlier reason as for how his injuries came about but I'm putting my chips with police brutality.
 

Rembrandt

Banned
Really? Are we really play this game that you dislike me so much even though I agree 99% this is police brutality I still have some other agenda?

You said there were other very real possibilities. List some. I'm just genuinely curious because I can't think of any plausible ones.

tripped and fell.

Offered to beat himself up to show the cops that he understands their job.

I would like to know this as well. I am sure it has something to do with the victim not forgiving or properly educating these cops.

Maybe he reached his hand out in solidarity and the cop misconstrued it.
 

JDSN

Banned
I hope the family doesnt bring racism into the conversation, talking about incompetence is cool, talking about brutality is okay, mentioning corruption is a posibility that yoy gotta at least entertain, you can mention this facts with past data and stats but boy just mentioning the color of the skin of the victim and the gofundme gets online real fast.
 

Volimar

Member
I hope the family doesnt bring racism into the conversation, talking about incompetence is cool, talking about brutality is okay, mentioning corruption is a posibility that yoy gotta at least entertain, you can mention this facts with past data and stats but boy just mentioning the color of the skin of the victim and the gofundme get online real fast.

Sad but true.
 
You said there were other very real possibilities. List some. I'm just genuinely curious because I can't think of any plausible ones.
Yes. There could be another reason for his injuries outside of police brutality. I'm betting on brutality because the information doesn't add up. Could there be another reason for how he got hurt? Yes. Nothing wrong with acknowledging that. That doesn't mean that's what I'm backing.

Tackled wrong, fell, hit with bike, etc. These are things that could happen. Again, I am still on the side of police brutality. Any other things you want to know?
 

Rembrandt

Banned
Yes. There could be another reason for his injuries outside of police brutality. I'm betting on brutality because the information doesn't add up. Could there be another reason for how he got hurt? Yes. Nothing wrong with acknowledging that. That doesn't mean that's what I'm backing.

Tackled wrong, fell, hit with bike, etc. These are things that could happen. Again, I am still on the side of police brutality. Any other things you want to know?

Now, the post you quoted said:

According to a police timeline he was fine when he was loaded into a van to be taken to the district station, but was injured by the time he got out. He suffered a broken vertebra and an injured voice box, his family said.

Was he tackled wrong or hit with a bike in the van? Still got any very real possibilities?
 
Now, the post you quoted said:



Was he tackled wrong or hit with a bike in the van? Still got any very real possibilities?
Well, if you want to be 100% certain about how every thing transpired with the current information you can. I'm on the side of police brutality and am open to the possibility it wasn't that.
 

hoola

Neo Member
They haven't released any info because they are too busy planting evidence and coming up with a story to protect themselves. "he flinched towards his pocket and I feared for my life, so i kneed him in the throat and broke his bones, but that is ok because we are trained to do it."
 

Jonm1010

Banned
Im not sure what you two(rembrandt and Subpar Spatula) are arguing so much for.

One guy thinks that there is such a small chance that something other then police brutality was the culprit, that the idea of suggesting an alternative right now seems silly.

The other guy thinks that the evidence overwhelmingly points to police brutality but in a adherence to ultra caution he doesnt want to make any declarations of an absolute nature.

To me it seems like both of you think that this is likely police brutality, both want investigations, both want justice, both are suspect of the police. Why is this small difference in how you are approaching initial judgement as an outsider such a contentious discussion?

Maybe I looked over some posts of your alls and maybe I am missing something that should be obvious.
 

atr0cious

Member
Lol, I remember one time I shared a ride to jail with one dude, when I still lived in Texas. He had a huge fucking gash in his forhead, with a shitty piece of gauze hanging off, and the rest of his face wasn't much better. Turns out the cops didn't like him making them wait to say goodbye to his family when they came to pick him up, so after loading him into the car, they drove around the corner, pulled him back out of the car and smashed his face into the concrete. When he complained to the jailers about this, they laughed and said, "Yea them Ft. Worth boys don't play around." All I had was a cop pull me out of my own car and say my dad's camera was stolen property, but at least I didn't get my face smashed in.
 

Enzom21

Member
Lol, I remember one time I shared a ride to jail with one dude, when I still lived in Texas. He had a huge fucking gash in his forhead, with a shitty piece of gauze hanging off, and the rest of his face wasn't much better. Turns out the cops didn't like him making them wait to say goodbye to his family when they came to pick him up, so after loading him into the car, they drove around the corner, pulled him back out of the car and smashed his face into the concrete. When he complained to the jailers about this, they laughed and said, "Yea them Ft. Worth boys don't play around." All I had was a cop pull me out of my own car and say my dad's camera was stolen property, but at least I didn't get my face smashed in.

Are you and was the other dude rich in melanin?
 

YoungHav

Banned
I have a feeling this is going to be a story like that black dude that shot himself in the head while handcuffed in a police vehicle.
 

lednerg

Member
That guy wasn't "fine" when they brought him into the van. His feet were dragging on the ground as they carried him in.
 
Police report says Freddie Gray had knife, arrested 'without incident'

City police wrote in court documents that Freddie Gray was arrested "without force or incident" for having a switchblade knife and suffered a medical emergency during transport.

The account is provided in charging documents filed in District Court, where officer Garrett Miller wrote that Gray was stopped because he "fled unprovoked upon noticing police presence." When Gray, 25, was stopped, they found a knife clipped to the inside of his front pants pocket and placed him under arrest.
 
arrested "without force or incident"
his voice box was partially crushed, and three bones in his neck were broken
Would you like a do-over on that statement? Having your neck bones and voice box shatter can't just be brushed aside as "a medical emergency". These things do not just happen, so the part where they explain how it went down is pretty crucial.
 

zeemumu

Member
If you have any qualms with me you're free to PM me. I'll happily engage you there but if you're going to follow me around in a bitter manner trying to call me out then please don't engage me. You're not doing anything but being an annoyance when that happens.


Actually, I'll do what I damn well please, which is if you come into a topic being wrong, I'll be there to show you exactly how. No one's bitter at you, in fact, I deal with people like you all the time, and I correct them when they are wrong too.

gallery_1_6_4517600.gif
 

Enzom21

Member
Rich is a word I associate with positive scenarios. We have more than our fair share of melanin, yes.

Then I am not surprised.


They suspended the six cops but I doubt anything will come of this.
http://www.cnn.com/2015/04/20/us/baltimore-freddie-gray-death/
Police Commissioner Anthony Batts said that police plan to conclude their investigation by Friday, May 1. From there, the case will go to the state's attorney's office, which will decide whether or not to file.

Gray was arrested a week ago Sunday. He "gave up without the use of force," according to Rodriguez.

An officer apparently took his Taser out, and was prepared to use it on Gray, but he never deployed it.

"None of the officers describe using any force against Mr. Gray," said the deputy police commissioner.

A total of six officers were involved in the arrest, and all six have been suspended.
 
Can't really see anything in the video that would result in the injuries described. Seems like they worked him over in the van (possibly as "punishment" for the chase) and it got out of hand.
 

Coins

Banned
I just saw the video in this. How was he ok when they loaded him into the van? He was dragging his feet like he was already paralyzed.
 
Five officers in Freddie Gray case gave accounts of incident

Five of the six officers involved in the arrest of Freddie Gray have provided statements to Baltimore police, leaving Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake frustrated that one has not.

Rawlings-Blake aired her feelings about what she saw as a delay in the investigation Tuesday during an interview that was televised nationally. That annoyed the Baltimore police union, which criticized the mayor for what members said was misleading rhetoric about rules governing officer discipline.

Rawlings-Blake has said in interviews that investigators have not "fully engaged" all the police officers involved in the arrest of Gray, who died Sunday while in police custody. She blamed the state Law Enforcement Officers' Bill of Rights for the delay.

"I don't understand how she can continually say they're not cooperating," Michael E. Davey, an attorney for the police union, told The Baltimore Sun on Wednesday. "They are. They did. And they're lucky they got those statements before I got involved."

http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/ma...eddie-gray-mayor-comments-20150422-story.html
 
Baltimore PD seem to really be trying to protect these officers. News has been really slow to come out on this still. Seems like everyone is waiting around for info.
 

Exile20

Member
Something like what happened in 2005 to another Baltimore man, who also suffered ultimately fatal spinal injuries after being placed in a police van.

In the earlier spinal injury death, 42-year-old Dondi Johnson was arrested for public urination and loaded into a police van similar to the one that would later be used to transport Gray.

“Mr. Johnson got into the back of the van without assistance,” court papers say. “He obeyed the officers’ commands and did not threaten any of the officers or act violently.”

Johnson gave no sign that he was in physical distress when he was locked in the van with his hands cuffed behind his back. Police Officer Nicole Leake would later testify that she failed to put him in a seatbelt as required by Department General Order K-14 because the nature of the charge against him suggested he had a full bladder.

Leake would deny that she gave him what is known in Baltimore as a “rough ride,” where the van is driven in such a fashion as to jounce and jangle the prisoners. She did estimate that she reached a nearby police station in less than half the time it would have taken at the speed limit.

“When she arrived at the District and opened the back door of the van, Mr. Johnson was lying on the floor of the van and could not move,” court papers say.

Leake asked two other officers to take Johnson from the van.

“She did not call for medical assistance because Mr. Johnson did not ask for it, and she thought he was lying,” court papers say.

Police Officer Michael Riser asked Johnson to get up.

“[T]he bitch was driving like an a--hole,” Johnson replied, according to court papers. “I fell and I can’t move.”

Johnson underwent surgery for a serious spinal injury. He died two weeks later, and his family filed suit.

More at the link
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articl...istory-of-accidentally-killing-its-perps.html
 

Culex

Banned
Update:

No video captured what happened to Freddie Gray inside the police van where officers heaved him into a metal compartment after pinning him to a sidewalk. The cause of his fatal spine injury has not been revealed.

But a troubling detail emerged as hundreds of protesters converged on City Hall again Thursday: He was not only handcuffed and put in leg irons, but left without a seat belt during his trip to the station.
 

patapuf

Member
So shackled completely then given a "rough ride" where without being able to use neither hands nor feet to try to stabilize himself was tossed around like a penny in a piggy bank.

If this is common practise i kind of understand why they are trying hard to keep it secret.
 

RyanDG

Member
The police union spokesman referred to protests as being like a lynching according to a quick report that played on cnn yesterday. Considering the circumstances, I felt that was a horrible choice of words and really emphasized the disconnect law enforcement has with their communities in response to these occurrences.
 

Aselith

Member
What is this rough ride even about? Is it just sadism or what? I don't understand why someone would do that or think it's ok.
 

lednerg

Member
I wonder if any security cameras on the streets caught the van driving erratically. Of course, I'm not expecting the police to bother knocking on doors trying to find that footage.
 
The stone-walling going on with Baltimore PD is appalling. They have so much time to get an official story together. Can't wait to see how they try to justify this and absolve themselves of wrongdoing.

No excuse for a man having his spine severed in police custody.
 

GQman2121

Banned
So people have been protesting downtown for the last few hours, but now that the sun is down, tons of people have hit the streets and are now blocking traffic at the busiest intersection and tourist destination in the city.

Orioles game is currently going on about a half mile away from this location against the Red Sox, so all of the local hotels have tons of people in for the game including media.

Police are now moving with force to get people out of the streets. It's being shown live on three of the four (NBC, CBS, FOX) major networks.

Baltimore sun is live blogging HERE

Boston Globe have images from today HERE
 

jay23

Member
There needs to be some sort of reform at the federal level to deal with police brutality. The whole we will investigate our own isn't obviously cutting it.

Something along the lines of the NTSB that investigates accidents. An independent federal agency with no ties to the local police that investigates all excessive force cases.

This

Wonder how many more people have to die before something changes.
 

Fusebox

Banned
"I don't understand how she can continually say they're not cooperating," Michael E. Davey, an attorney for the police union, told The Baltimore Sun on Wednesday. "They are. They did. And they're lucky they got those statements before I got involved."

That thin blue line really isn't very thin anymore.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom