• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Manga Discussion/News Thread |OT5| We Post on Wednesdays

Status
Not open for further replies.

Big One

Banned
Using introduction time for 3 characters that are, for all intents and purposes, not going to matter in a a chapter or so is not really my idea of good pacing.
Characters not being relevant in later chapters has nothing to do with pacing (it has to do with storytelling). Regardless this chapter had about what is, at average, a volume's worth of what Bleach usually contains.
 

Freshmaker

I am Korean.
Using introduction time for 3 characters that are, for all intents and purposes, not going to matter in a a chapter or so is not really my idea of good pacing.

Don't forget the Hamtaro guy and his bossy girlfriend. They're not gonna matter either.
 

Articalys

Member
Sket Dance 196

Mimori is amazing.

I still wonder how they can't seem to improve over their once-a-week release schedule though. I wish someone faster would just come along and steal the series from them.
 

Sai

Member
Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei 6

NmZYS.png
Tatsuya's that dude.

Light novel stuff:
Read summaries of the stuff to come, and Tatsuya really is ridiculously broken though. That whole underdog act is obliterated in the later volumes.

Really interested in seeing how their involvement with the Yotsuba family plays out... And I'm thankful it didn't go into the ridiculous harem/romcom territory—though the guy's popular, it isn't really entertained much.
 

Stat Flow

He gonna cry in the car
The introductions...weren't really introduction time. He simply showed them, and also put what seat they were to show what the Quincy's were fucking with. It's not like we got their story or anything. This chapter was well paced, as the arc has been.
Really shows that people dunno wtf they want from Bleach.
This is mostly it.
 
I think the introductions thing can be good if it's executed right, since it's a subversion. Something like Kumagawa one-shotting the 6 characters at the end of the Flask Plan arc.

Though I don't think this chapter of Bleach really did it well.
 
Bleach has always been basically an anime in manga form but now that Kubo is doing some actual manga-style storytelling people get mad. Really shows that people dunno wtf they want from Bleach.

I never like Bleach and have no false illusions of it ever being able to "give what I want", it's too far down the rabbit hole for that.


I'm just extremely surprised this is what's apparently considered a great Bleach chapter by some.


The last time I liked Bleach it was still about a boy who could see ghosts.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
I see Big One emerged from the Big Cave that he sleeps in from Thursday-Tuesday.

Nisekoi

She's probably lying, or he made a lot of promises.
 

Soma

Member
Kimi no Iru Machi 1-54

I... I think I understand where all the rage comes from.

But

the fact that I'm relatively early in this series is rather frightening.

Oh my god. What have I gotten myself into?
 

Laughing Banana

Weeping Pickle
I see Big One emerged from the Big Cave that he sleeps in from Thursday-Tuesday.

Nisekoi

She's probably lying, or he made a lot of promises.

You just can't help it, can you? Hahaha.

As for NISEKOI, yea I get this feeling that she's not really telling the truth. I don't know why.

And for crying out loud, I know this is a common cliched trope used by everyone and their mothers but a lot of the situations in NISEKOI can be resolved in 10 minutes tops if the main character is a bit assertive instead of spewing "it can't be, it can't be, it can't be, nah it can't be"

...And oh yeah, Onodera for life!

Kimi no Iru Machi 1-54

I... I think I understand where all the rage comes from.

But

the fact that I'm relatively early in this series is rather frightening.

Oh my god. What have I gotten myself into?

Just get out from that death-trap, really. There are tons of other great romantic series you can jump into without having to suffer the utter stupidity of Souji's characters (his art is rather nice though, I admit)
 

Soma

Member
Just get out from that death-trap, really. There are tons of other great romantic series you can jump into without having to suffer the utter stupidity of Souji's characters (his art is rather nice though, I admit)

I'm thinking about it. The masochist in me keeps wanting to see how far down the rabbit hole goes though. Coincidentally I was thinking about reading Suzuka at some point but I've held that off for a while since I've heard mixed thoughts on that too.

Anyone have any recommendations that are (somewhat) similar but less stupid?
 
Bleach

This plot seems out of the left field given the overall narrative...I mean, Soul Society knew nothing of a whole other nation massing its forces...? None of the Quincy look interesting to me apart from their king...Also, why is Ichigo still weak compared to his former self exactly?
 

Solune

Member
Nisekoi 26
Tsugumiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii

Nisekoi 27
Two ok chapters in a row? No way, no f-u-c-k-i-n-g way.

Photo Kano - Sweet Snap 1-6
So, some how I tricked myself into reading this rubbish. It's based on a PSP galge somewhat like Amagami I guess I got hooked by Siliconera "Pokemon Snap with Dating Sim". I mean who doesn't like Pokemon Snap.

Anyways this version is alright, it focuses on the childhood friend arc mostly, the art is inconsistent but ok and there's pantyshots for no reason in panels that sometimes make no sense, like they are placed in a way that the reader sees them and the MC doesn't. Going lower than regular harem standards.

Photo Kano - Your eyes only 1-4
Goes in with the same setup but introduces more characters and surprisingly doesn't feature any gratuitous shots. The art is also better than Sweet Snap. All in all I wouldn't pick it up, I was expecting something like Ginen Shounen not that that is any good but, something about cameras is interesting. I want something like Fatal Frame though.
 

Kincaido

Got 99 problems and only one of them is a waifu
Nisekoi 27

Raku probably made a promise to both girls and forgot one of them. Either way we all know that Raku and Chitoge are slowly developing feelings for each other and the she's gonna win in the end. Sorry Onodera fans.

Bleach 494

Lol at Kira going down so easy. I'm interested in the Quincy girl.
 

Kusagari

Member
Toriko:

And shit just got real. Toriko's power up is insane, and it sounds like that was nothing compared to what he can really do. Could we see a 100 ren punch on Chiyo?
 

Envelope

sealed with a kiss
Nisekoi 27

Raku probably made a promise to both girls and forgot one of them. Either way we all know that Raku and Chitoge are slowly developing feelings for each other and the she's gonna win in the end. Sorry Onodera fans.

Bleach 494

Lol at Kira going down so easy. I'm interested in the Quincy girl.

SuvGX.jpg


My waifu, do not touch
 

BatDan

Bane? Get them on board, I'll call it in.
Toriko

Damn! Not since Jotaro's beat-down of Steely Dan has multiple pages of punching been so badass. Definitely a game-changer for Toriko.
 

gunbo13

Member
Characters not being relevant in later chapters has nothing to do with pacing (it has to do with storytelling). Regardless this chapter had about what is, at average, a volume's worth of what Bleach usually contains.
Character reveals and removal have everything to do with pacing. And your desired pacing leaning more towards franticness does not mean a chapter is good nor does it imply "proper" pacing. All you seem to be stating each week is that a chapter is objectively bad if it doesn't suit your tastes or good if it does. That's why I can't take your opinions seriously since you don't understand what objective actually means. The dynamics of pacing it seems as well.
Boin BoinOnsen 1

Lolwhat.It's not smut, it's straight-up porn.
You should read tags.
 
Gotta love how mangagaf doesn't give a fuck about spoilers.

Funny how Kubo doesn't give a fuck about kiba, but the filler dudes tend to love him. His sword probably has one of the more interesting properties. The potential of a broken ass bankai is there.

Gotta love how like ~500 chapters in, they finally turn off god mode for all the cast. Wonder which captain will bite the dust first.

Naruto
Wait.. when did mandara have an army of giant shark men?? Eh who the fuck cares anymore. naturally uchiha has a new trick up their sleeves every chapter.

one piece

some more setup. A bit confused what the baddie is after or w/e.
 
Gotta love how mangagaf doesn't give a fuck about spoilers.

Funny how Kubo doesn't give a fuck about kiba, but the filler dudes tend to love him. His sword probably has one of the more interesting properties. The potential of a broken ass bankai is there.

Gotta love how like ~500 chapters in, they finally turn off god mode for all the cast. Wonder which captain will bite the dust first..

Captain Commander Yamamoto, if he dies then this arc will rival that of the Arrancar Saga, hands down.
 

upandaway

Member
Toriko

That punching segment was so long :lol seriously. It was hilarious.

Things are becoming more and more real. I would have never predicted this 3 chapters ago. The arc suddenly got crazy.

Now I want new calorie calculations with Food Honor.
 

Esch

Banned
Toriko

That punching segment was so long :lol seriously. It was hilarious.

Things are becoming more and more real. I would have never predicted this 3 chapters ago. The arc suddenly got crazy.

Now I want new calorie calculations with Food Honor.
chiyo's face is scaaary ._.
 

upandaway

Member
Whatever it is that's on her neck, it's not a face. It's like.. a black hole... with hair buns.

Also funny seeing Toriko all hippy and calm like that as a result of Food Honor. He wasn't exactly known for his anger management issues to begin with, but that was pretty good.
 
Naruto

Unlike some here, I actually enjoy the Kage vs Madara battle and the combination attack was cool. Sadly it amounted to another Susanoo form and a painfully predictable ending of Madara owning the kages only to disappear right before he kills them due to Edo Tensei being cancelled. Kinda undermines the whole fight but at least there have been some sweet jutsus in this battle, namely from Madara. It's kind of sad that fully resurrecting Madara and having him betray Tobi and becoming the final villain would be a more interesting turnout than Tobi as the final antagonist. Madara is truly a beast and finding a way to defeat him without the Edo Tensei shit would have been a pretty cool endgame. Oh well. I just want to see what Tobi is truly made of at this point. We've seen his parlor tricks, what kind of attack jutsus can he pull out of his hat?

Bleach

Boring again. This chapter also felt like half a chapter it was so quick. I realize that the plot progressed and I have no complaints there, I just don't give a shit about any of the characters that were just wiped out, they are all just fodder which is how you have to start, of course. This brings me back to how the Naruto war started and the complaints on here. Guess I shouldn't be a hypocrite and just be patient until the few interesting characters take the stage. I do like that the Quincies are fucking shit up in SS, however. It's a pretty big plot hole how they are this strong but didn't try to stop Aizen from destroying everything earlier. Maybe that will get explained later, we'll see.

One Piece

Also boring this week but at least we got to see what happened to Zoro's party finally which is good. Everyone is together now so next chapter should be far more interesting. Law is going to have to get used to Luffy's shenanigans haha

Reborn

Wow, they actually more or less answered both of my remaining questions already! Why Bermuda is still in the arcebelano form and where the eighth element came from. Although that latter was a bullshit explanation but at least we know where it came from. Really weird for me that Reborn has been the most interesting shonen these last two weeks. Now that all the revelations are largely over, that will change as it will go back to typical fair. Fight against Bermuda and his top guy should be interesting at least. Also, although I feel the future arc still felt like the best way to cap off the series, I will say checkerface is an antagonist worthy of endgame and stronger than Byakuran being that he controls the triumvirate of power or whatever the hell it's called. I look forward to learning more about him and seeing what he can do in the future as well as the true significance of the pacifiers.

Do series ever end without the mangaka announcing that it's on the final arc? I could see the series ending with this arc, but you never know. The Arcebelano/pacifiers and the Vindice were the only remaining and ongoing mysteries in the series so there's really no need to continue after this.

Fairy Tail

What the hell? They talk up the strength of the monsters, there's only one S class so you expect it to be a beast and a good fight for Erza, and then she just unceremoniously beats all of them pretty much off screen? WTF? LAME.
 
Captain Commander Yamamoto, if he dies then this arc will rival that of the Arrancar Saga, hands down.
Yeah, his telling 3rd Seat Genshirou to stay behind and protect the court made me think. I've got a feeling we're gonna see Yamamoto go Bankai against the Quincy Emperor, with Yama-jii being killed to demonstrate the power of the new Quincy order.
 
Reborn. Really weird for me that Reborn has been the most interesting shonen these last two weeks. Now that all the revelations are largely over, that will change as it will go back to typical fair. Fight against Bermuda and his top guy should be interesting at least. Also, although I feel the future arc still felt like the best way to cap off the series, I will say checkerface is an antagonist worthy of endgame and stronger than Byakuran being that he controls the triumvirate of power or whatever the hell it's called. I look forward to learning more about him and seeing what he can do in the future as well as the true significance of the pacifiers.

Do series ever end without the mangaka announcing that it's on the final arc? I could see the series ending with this arc, but you never know. The Arcebelano/pacifiers and the Vindice were the only remaining and ongoing mysteries in the series so there's really no need to continue after this.


Thats how I feel, its got quite good for a bit.

I do think she could keep continuing Reborn on, I think there is appeal in people wanting to see the characters older, and at least slightly older future versions as true vongola mafia.
 

Trickster

Member
Beelzebub

Bringing the lulz as always, great chapter.

Toriko

Dat punch! This whole situation seems so similar to the sitaution in dbz, where goku was being trained by king kai in heaven, and managed to return in time to save the day. I love it!
 
Thats how I feel, its got quite good for a bit.

I do think she could keep continuing Reborn on, I think there is appeal in people wanting to see the characters older, and at least slightly older future versions as true vongola mafia.

At least the future arc gave some impressions of that but usually something along those lines is right where a series ends. Reborn's ultimate goal is to get Tsuna to become the Tenth, to truly embrace it. If things are built up to that goal, the series could end with the ceremony. Much like I expect Naruto to become Hokage at the end (probably a quick jump to the future for a panel or two) but I don't expect to see him do anything as Hokage.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
At least the future arc gave some impressions of that but usually something along those lines is right where a series ends. Reborn's ultimate goal is to get Tsuna to become the Tenth, to truly embrace it. If things are built up to that goal, the series could end with the ceremony. Much like I expect Naruto to become Hokage at the end (probably a quick jump to the future for a panel or two) but I don't expect to see him do anything as Hokage.

Awkward chapter/arc about him and his girlfriend trying to lose their virginity. [/kenakamatsu]
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
If he gets with Sasuke the Hinata freak fandom will rage! Too controversial!

Well, I mean, I don't think he's planning to make Naruto gay after 500 chapters of him clearly being straight.

I got around to reading that chapter and it sucked. Why doesn't Itachi just tell Sasuke he's a fucking asshole, instead of being like, "NARUTO WILL SHOW YOU THE WAAAAAAAAAAY"
 
Well, I mean, I don't think he's planning to make Naruto gay after 500 chapters of him clearly being straight.

I got around to reading that chapter and it sucked. Why doesn't Itachi just tell Sasuke he's a fucking asshole, instead of being like, "NARUTO WILL SHOW YOU THE WAAAAAAAAAAY"


Have to add that Naruto is the Messiah for them all
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom