There was one last year I believe or the one before. It was basically any manga that had a chapter released in that same year was eligible.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Manga News/Discussion |OTS| Yeah I couldn't come up with a thread title ¯\_()_/¯
- Thread starter dramatis
- Start date
- Status
There was one last year I believe or the one before. It was basically any manga that had a chapter released in that same year was eligible.
hipsterpants
Member
usually, there was a bunch of drama over people posting lewd images/gifs a few months ago and I think some people stopped posting there, idk
I feel like the thread used to move a lot faster.
It was just too far ahead of its time for WSJ.
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
There's some poster overlap. I don't think it's really much different, but the manga thread is more chill, for the most part.
Relationships between the two shall surely improve when the Shokugeki no Soma and Prison School anime start
I haven't been there as long as some others, but a season or two ago it was moving faster.
8 X 11 Printer Paper
Member
eRobot really made me cringe when I read it's 3 translated chapters. I don't see any of the three new ones or the three older ones (Sporting, Judos and Cluster) surviving past 25 chapters.
I hope I'll get to vote Psycho Pass 2 as AOTY.
Orange volume 1
I'm not sure how I feel about the whole past/future storytelling, though I guess it's interesting seeing how things... were and are changing, and how things ended up in that... other timeline?
The setting is nice (although I'm not even gonna start to think about how that letter was sent back in time) and although the main girl is a bit maddening to watch with her stupid decisions this first volume was pretty good, especially thanks to having the focus shared a bit with the rest of the characters. It's gonna be interesting to see if she'll manage to save his life in 10 years' time.
Orange volume 1
I'm not sure how I feel about the whole past/future storytelling, though I guess it's interesting seeing how things... were and are changing, and how things ended up in that... other timeline?
The setting is nice (although I'm not even gonna start to think about how that letter was sent back in time) and although the main girl is a bit maddening to watch with her stupid decisions this first volume was pretty good, especially thanks to having the focus shared a bit with the rest of the characters. It's gonna be interesting to see if she'll manage to save his life in 10 years' time.
dakkumauji
Member
To be fair, Sporting Salt and Hi Fi Cluster aren't dead yet.
Yeah, it used to move a lot faster. Dunno, I stopped posting there some time back. I didn't care for what mostly everyone else was watching and I was basically dumping impressions so might as well just quit wasting my time with watch impressions ~_~
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
what's this?
Considering that apparently AnimeGAF look down on smut just for the sake of looking down on smut, I'm not really optimistic about it, but hey, correct me if I'm wrong.
To be fair, Sporting Salt and Hi Fi Cluster aren't dead yet.
Honestly it's kind of amazing how long Sporting Salt managed to last.
New WSJ series that started (and, for most of them, ended) this year.
8 X 11 Printer Paper
Member
All the manga's (except 2 of the new ones) that premiered in Jump during 2014 (Jump counts the year as December to December so we are on Volume 3 of 2015).
According to the Wiki, these are the 2014 series:
Iron Knight
Illegal Rare
iShojo
Stealth Symphony
Tokyo Wonder Boys
Hinomaru Sumo
My Hero Academia
Mitsukubi Condor
Yoakemono
Judos
Hi-Fi Cluster
Sporting Salt
Takujo no Ageha
E-Robot
Only Sumo and MHA are doing well (with the latter actually being a big hit). Everything else from Iron Knight to Yoakemono was swiftly cancelled. Except for iShojo which moved to another magazine (and nothing of value was lost)
Judos, Hi-Fi Cluster and Sporting Salt are all dead manga walking
Takujo no Ageha might do okay for a bit. We'll see.
E-Robot is garbage and hopefully Japanese kids can see that too
The first 2015 series is Gakku Hotei, and that will probably last a while. It's Ace Attorney Kids drawn by Takeshi Obata.
Iron Knight
Illegal Rare
iShojo
Stealth Symphony
Tokyo Wonder Boys
Hinomaru Sumo
My Hero Academia
Mitsukubi Condor
Yoakemono
Judos
Hi-Fi Cluster
Sporting Salt
Takujo no Ageha
E-Robot
Only Sumo and MHA are doing well (with the latter actually being a big hit). Everything else from Iron Knight to Yoakemono was swiftly cancelled. Except for iShojo which moved to another magazine (and nothing of value was lost)
Judos, Hi-Fi Cluster and Sporting Salt are all dead manga walking
Takujo no Ageha might do okay for a bit. We'll see.
E-Robot is garbage and hopefully Japanese kids can see that too
The first 2015 series is Gakku Hotei, and that will probably last a while. It's Ace Attorney Kids drawn by Takeshi Obata.
hipsterpants
Member
so is shounen jump just a huge risk/reward thing for potential authors? it seems to have a really low success rate.
TheRealTalker
Banned
So there will be Shonen Jump chapters this week/on Monday but not next week/after Monday
and no Chapters this week for the other Magazine publications (in example FairyTail)
correct or not?
and no Chapters this week for the other Magazine publications (in example FairyTail)
correct or not?
So here I was, minding my own business, opening Shiwasu no Okina's nude Asuka pic on Pixiv and made the unfortunate blunder to scroll down to comments:
Random person asking an artist, a pro h-manga artists no less.... to draw Naruto fanart. In case any of the Naruto readers ever wondered why you get dirty looks. Now I can't go appreciate that wonderful Asuka without that horrid comment staring me in the face... in plain English.
Random person asking an artist, a pro h-manga artists no less.... to draw Naruto fanart. In case any of the Naruto readers ever wondered why you get dirty looks. Now I can't go appreciate that wonderful Asuka without that horrid comment staring me in the face... in plain English.
8 X 11 Printer Paper
Member
2014 has been the 2nd worst year (tied for 2nd with 2003 until we see how long Hero survives) for new titles since the new millennium. With it most likely beating out 2010, who's only manga that survived over a year was Enigma (56 chapters). But 2010 only had 8 new mangas while 2014 had 16.
Hahahaha holy shit. It can't be for real, can it?
What are the odds that the one who posted that comment originated from the Naruto OT?
8 X 11 Printer Paper
Member
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
I liked the idea of iron knight.
=(
=(
dakkumauji
Member
I thought the one shot was nice.
The full series was well that was a nice idea for an one shot, now how the hell do we extend this.
Infinite Justice
Member
yea haven't seen a translation since so yea
To be fair, Sporting Salt and Hi Fi Cluster aren't dead yet.
can you call it lasting though since no one seems to give a fuck anymore
Cross Game 9-10
Well this was obvious coming off Touch, way too many hints at it the couple chapters before. Still sad. I quite enjoyed the romantic teasing of the kids up to this point, I quite expect that aspect to disappear for the rest of the series (much like it happened with Touch as well) and for that to be replaced with some less cute romantic story line with the other sister.
Well this was obvious coming off Touch, way too many hints at it the couple chapters before. Still sad. I quite enjoyed the romantic teasing of the kids up to this point, I quite expect that aspect to disappear for the rest of the series (much like it happened with Touch as well) and for that to be replaced with some less cute romantic story line with the other sister.
Infinite Justice
Member
Whoops was confusing Iron Knight with that garbage Holy Knight.
My bad :/
My bad :/
Laughing Banana
Weeping Pickle
Man, reading Moteki is like reading my own life.
It's so............... damn.
It's so............... damn.
Is Moteki still being translated?
I remember it seeming dead and just watching the live-action series.
Uso is shedding a tear somewhere.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
AnimeGAF is fine if you have thick skin; there's a lot of jaded dudes who hate everything.
We got a chapter at the end of October, so the translation doesn't seem like it's completely dead.... Just mostly dead.
I think the issue with Jump nowadays is how prominent manga piracy is. WSJ leaks about a week before it's officially leaked, meaning there's less of a demand to buy the volumes. However certain hits will obviously rise to the top like Toriko did briefly and now My Hero Academia. If My Hero Academia can carrying it's current momentum like Toriko wasn't able to, then it could very well be the next big series though it also needs some Western exposure as well.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
WSJ wishes Toriko was the next big thing
Yea jumped tried to plaster toriko all over everything pairing him up with goku and shit
Toriko's sales were pretty good at first. Afterall, a manga series doesn't sell 20 million copies of volumes and isn't considered a success. Regardless it did fail to carry it's momentum with it's mediocre anime TV series and also repetitive and stagnant storylines.
Laughing Banana
Weeping Pickle
Really? Compared to the rest of the boys like One Piece and Bleach, Toriko's story for me moves like a blietzkrig... it seems so restless in moving on.
Repetitive and stagnant, is in fact, is currently what I use to describe One Piece. But that's just me.
I am not familiar with the scene... maybe it's dead. If it is, then it's unfortunate :/ I really enjoyed what I read.
;(
Laughing Banana
Weeping Pickle
Yep. It is not just... modern enough.
No moe elements at all, hahaha. Even One Piece is rife with fanservice, as is Bleach.
8 X 11 Printer Paper
Member
Only HxH breaks that mold, but being on Hiatus all the time and having starving fans helps it out.
Nah at least one piece and bleachs art is clean?
Toriko is just like a bunch of shit mashed together
Hxh art was top tier when translated into anime. I dont think you could say the same with toriko
Madhouse vs. Toei man.
I imagine if Madhouse did Toriko, then the art would at least look decent.
Hell, if Madhouse did most Jump manga, they would look amazing.
AquaWateria
Member
Well that's a given since Toei was the one that animated Toriko. I mean look at World Trigger the animation/art is crap and it also doesn't help that it's getting 50 episodes.
Bros.
Toriko doesn't have stuff like Law's or Robin's flashbacks in it's ranks when it comes to it's story. All Toriko is from arc to arc is just random adventures. It's cool and enjoyable, but any of the plot relating to things like "GOD" for example is still largely untouched upon or really given any sense of endgame. Everyting in One Piece is leading up to the end on an arc by arc basis. You still get the sense of adventure, but also a great story (well, not all the time) that builds up the world itself and will ultimately lead to the endgame goal.
One Piece has pacing issues, but stagnant or repetitive is not.
One Piece is perfect in every single way. It is fact as it is written down in the stone tablet I have sealed within my closet for when the end times are near, I shall shower everyone with the good news that is One Piece. One Piece is love, One Piece is life.
It does have some minor issues but being a manga for more than 20 years and still hitting striders in sales has to mean something, especially when it destroys the competition in numbers. Even its previous volume is still higher up compared to other volumes.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked