Alright, finally finished this after ~40 hours. I have mixed feelings. On the one hand, the music, graphics and mechanics (specially in-battle) are great. They're as good as they've ever been in this franchise, if not better. However, the game does make some mistakes. First of all, there are waaay too many "overworld" mechanics. The Luiginary works and the crazy amount of special jumping/drilling/flying/hammering/etc actions as a way to hinder and control progression was not a very good idea and by the end made traversing through most areas a pain. It also made tutorials happen waaaay too often, up to the last dungeon in the game.
And of course, its biggest sin is in overstaying its welcome. The fact that it reminded me of L.A. Noire for being the other game I've really hated for this reason speaks very badly of this game. It just barely managed to keep my interest to the end, but a M&L game should never be 40 hours long. I would have been more than happy with a 25-hour game. The fetchquests which at least didn't happen very often coupled with the extremely long platforming sections could have been reduced significantly to make this happen. Same for some gimmicky parts such as the on-rails sections of Dozing Sands.
All in all, even though it seems like I hated it, in truth I did really enjoy it. The battles were as good as they've always been in this franchise and pretty fast-paced. The story was decent and some parts made me laugh. As I said, the visuals and audio are absolutely top-notch. I was surprised with how deep the item/rank perks/badge variety was, even though it did feel like it could be very abused to make the game easier. I don't regret buying it for one second.
I ended up with rainbow ranks for both bros, all Pi'llos rescued and most expert challenges beat. I don't think I'll be doing New Game Plus anytime soon though
Edit: Some other comments related to previous posts I've noticed:
- As mentioned on the previous page, I didn't grind at all. I did purposely repeat some battles to reach rainbow rank earlier, but then found out it wouldn't have been necessary.
- The bosses weren't that hard. The only one I had trouble with was
, all the others took me one try.
- I had no issue with the gyroscope/accelerometer, although I think I got better results when tilting the 3DS very lightly. Maybe it could have been adjusted better.
- Used tons of beans.
- What's the point of the
? Is there any reason why I should want to collect/clear all of them?
-
: Best character.
- Giant battles kick all sort of ass.