The problem isn't with the general look of the character.
The problem is we know who they are based off and they kinda missed the mark last time and now it's just gotten worse which it shouldn't.
If the character was based off Annette O'Toole it would be a different story.
If you look at the actors they are instantly recognizable to the characters in game, so Insomniac can capture them perfectly
You could literally cast them as the live action versions
But Mary Jane isn't even close
The first Spider-Man was actually closer but still off, but at least you could see her somewhere in there
But who is this?
Okay maybe it's a old photo so she's changed but still not even close.