Wow is all I can say. I've been waiting for this game to come out since it was announced. Went and gladly spent my $60 this morning for it and came home and spent about 3 hours with it. After those three hours I turned off my Xbox and was speechless....
I want to know how Bioware thought this game was ready to be released. I feel like I just paid $60 bucks for a crappy beta. The frame-rate is so bad I can barely concentrate on what I'm doing. I'm all for good graphics Bioware, but when you make the game skip around like this, it just sucks me right out of the experience. Almost every movement I made resulted in a choppy few seconds and made me sigh. When I read reviews I read that the frame-rate would dip at times during battles, not little stutters and drops as I'm jogging along. Bad frame-rate can instantly ruin a game for me sadly. I can play a game with terrible graphics as long as it runs smoothly. Hell, I still play Counter-Strike on occasion.
My next big problem was with the AI. I understand that this is an RPG and I shouldn't expect the greatest combat and enemies in a video game, but I would like enemies that did fight back. I had three Krogans charge me earlier and took down my two teammates within two seconds, I ran back took cover and just kinda waited for death to come, hoping my shotgun would prevail. Luckily for Sheperd, the Krogans just decided to stand over the bodies of my fallen comrades and stand there as I pumped round after round into them while the third one ran back to his initial spot. This happened more than once, and not just with the Krogans. I had a few Geth do this kind of stuff as well. Oh and my teammates made me feel like I was slaying Locust with my man Dom all over again.
Finally, the guy who played Sheperd. Every time he said something that was suppose to be serious, I just kinda laughed. It's like Bioware watched a bunch of corny movies and decided that's what kind of writing they should use for the protagonist. This isn't a big deal, just something I felt like mentioning really.
Now don't get me wrong, Bioware did a lot of great things with this game. The setting is amazing, the story was really intriguing, the combat system felt like it was going to be fun, the inventory system looked like it was going to be fun to collect armor and weapons, but they just failed to deliver it to me. The horrible FPS and terrible AI/buggy AI just sucks me right out of the game, and aren't RPG's all about immersion?
In my opinion it just needed more time for development in order to smooth out the wrinkles and make all those top notch ingredients come together in a smooth fashion. I don't know who to really blame for this, Microsoft or Bioware, but for me this is the most disappointing game of the year for the Xbox 360.
P.S. I was never excited about Assassin's Creed, so don't throw that at me. ;p
7/10