Diablo 3 is not an option for you? no interest?
My experience with Diablo is almost zero, I think I played it once. All clues point towards 3 being fantastic, so I will probably dig it a lot - I like good games, don't care that much about genre. The thing that sadly puts me off nowadays, are games that you have to invest a lot of time in to really get something out of it. I used to love these type of games too, but lately I only seem to enjoy games that can be played in short bursts. Diablo 3 seems like a big time investment, building your character, looting items etc.
Weirdly enough I play these short burst games in quite long sessions though, so my complaint doesn't even make sense.
On top of that, I've been waiting for Max Payne 3 for years. I must play it.