• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Mechanical Pencils

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bagels

You got Moxie, kid!
Welcome to part 3 of my growing series on antiquated ways to write junk!

Part 1 - Wooden Pencils
Part 2 - Fountain Pens
Part 3 - Mechanical Pencils

Once more,
wRaC14Z.jpg

It's actually much easier to answer this question for mechanical pencils, vs. wooden pencils or fountain pens.


The mechanical pencil has overtaken just about every type of writing utensil as the last word in utilitarian writing. Even the ubiquitous cheapy bic ballpoint pen has a tendency to crap out right when you need it most.

Mechanical pencils have long been favored by eminently practical folks, like engineers, accountants, scientists, and other professional nerds. On the other hand, you can imagine the serious writing enthusiast looking down his nose at such a purely...practical tool. The late Count Roland Lothar Wolfgang Christian Ernst Wilhelm von Faber-Castell undoubtedly spent his declining years sitting in the family castle, caressing a solid gold fountain pen, and silently seething at the unwashed masses and their unceasing demand for their ludicrous "clicky pencils!" HARUMPH!

But as handwritten anything has gone the way of the dodo, even mechanical pencils have quietly become serious writing tools. You can now blow as much money as you'd like on a single pencil. At the same time, the big manufacturers in Germany and Japan have really expanded the options in the $5-15 "appeals to students and/or the homeless" segment.

There's a little bit less to say here about mechanisms and how individual pencils write (well, hypothetically. It won't stop me from writing 10,000 words). The beauty of mechanical pencils is that you can spend a few cents more on premium leads and pop them in any pencil you like to get a nice writing experience. Things like weight and balance are still important, but you're fundamentally paying for something nice to hold a piece of lead.


Pencil Leads

Mechanical pencil leads are graded just like the leads in wooden pencils.


The range is a bit narrower for mechanical pencils. Almost every pencil will come with HB (same as #2 in the moronic US system) leads. Mechanical pencil HB strikes me as quite a bit softer than a wooden pencil HB. You'll find the next few grades towards the softer/darker end of the scale - B, 2B, 3B, 4B - are the easiest to find. Pentel produces premium leads in a range from 4H to 4B, with the curious inclusion of "HB Hard" and "HB soft" grades as well. The specifics of your lead preference are NOT the kind of things I'd recommend discussing on a first date.


Just like with wooden pencils, the grading of mechanical pencil leads is by no means uniform. It varies between brands, and even between different product lines from the same manufacturer.

A little plastic case with either 20 or 40 leads will cost you $3-4. So if you really want to zero in on the lead FOR YOU, go a grade or two harder or softer than HB and either set aside a few pencils for different grades or palm off the grades you don't like on your cretinous friends. They're shoving more leads in the wrong way with their disposable bic pencils so they can save 10 cents. Are they really going to notice?

Most people will be happy with HB. The "premium" leads are made to resist snapping, which is otherwise a problem for heavy-handed writers like me.

The bigger divide in pencil leads is, of course, .5 vs .7 mm diameter. Wars have been started over this topic (which ones? All of them). You can actually find 0.3 mm and 0.9 mm pretty easily (1.1 mm is not hard to find, either), if you favor a really needle-y point, or want something approaching a lead holder. You can even find 0.2 mm and 0.4 mm "special edition" pencils for writing down your PUNK ROCK SONG LYRICS, you non-conformist, you!

I meet way more people who favor 0.5 than 0.7 mm leads, but with a 0.7 or 0.9 mm, if you hold your pencil at a fair angle, you can get a nice chiseled tip. Then, you can rotate the pencil in your hand to get very thin or very thick lines. I favor 0.5 mm most of the time, but change is the spice of whatever.

You can also find colored leads (usually red or blue, but other colors are available), but I have no experience with them.



4 Features You Might Be Interested In

1.) The retractable tip (RT).


Please hold down the giggling.

The final, needle-like lead sleeve on many pencils can cause issues. For starters, putting a pencil with a fixed lead sleeve in your pants pocket is a good way to get unexpectedly jabbed in exactly the kind of place you don't want to be unexpectedly jabbed in.


Additionally, I've lost a healthy number of pencils after a drop from a tabletop bent/smashed/otherwise damaged the lead sleeve.



I'll go ahead and say, if you want one pencil recommendation from me, this is it - the Pentel Technica-X (0.5 mm). I've had this one for over a decade (you can see the wear) and clicking it is still like working the bolt on a rifle. It's just flawless.

They've become harder to find, so I grabbed several extras a few months back.
($5)

Some pencils with retractable tips:


Pentel Vicuña multipen (0.5) - the only pencil I own named after a relative of the llama.
Pentel Technica-X (0.5)
Paper Mate Apex (0.7)
Paper Mate PhD (0.7)
Pentech Syntech (0.7)
Paper Mate (unknown) (0.5)
Pilot Del Ful (0.5)


Some retractables have a lead sleeve (the pointy bit at the end) while others don't

Technica-X (top) vs.
Platinum OLEeNU

The cheap Bic Click Master has a retractable tip, surprisingly.


2.) Nicer materials.

Finding a non-plastic mechanical pencil is one of the things that makes modern life so great. I'd put it a notch ahead of not having small pox and a notch behind not having to drink from water that the rest of my village poops in.

The real standout here is wood (again, keep those giggles down, plz). My absolute favorite pencil I own is the Pilot Just Meet Slim, with a body made from ash trees reserved for the production of baseball bats. For realsies. It's great looking pencil, but the real joy is in using it to write. It is absolutely wonderful. You used to be able to buy these things for around $10, and I gave away tons of them to friends and family interested in better writing tools. Unfortunately, I can't find them anywhere any more and I'm kicking myself for not buying a crate or two when I could.

If you can find these, I'll offer some kind of ridiculous bounty for them. Note that the multipen version is garbage. You want the "slim" 0.5 mm pencil. I'm sure the ballpoint pen is fine, if you have no self respect. Can you still find them in Japan? Please?
The lesson here is that, outside of high-end product lines (Rotring metal hex-body pens and pencils, for example) or very low-end product lines (disposable bic's), manufacturers are constantly phasing in and out different models. If you find something you like, consider buying at least one more to save bitter tears if it breaks or is stolen!


Here is my most expensive pencil, the Faber-Castell E-Motion, in chrome-trimmed pearwood. Also available in maple. ($60)


This comes in unusual 1.4 mm mega-lead. You advance the lead by twisting the rear cap (which does hold a nice eraser). Extra leads are stored in little slots accessed under the front cap.

It feels positively wonderful in your hand and looks classy as balls. Unfortunately, 1.4 mm lead is a tad broad for me and the pencil weighs enough (and I tend to like heavier pencils) that it comes with a 100% hand cramp guarantee (if you do not get a hand cramp after one hour of writing, Count Faber-Castell himself will personally arrange for one of his carriages to run that hand over as he speeds past on the way to hunt pheasants! Truly an honor!)


5993.jpg

Maple

You can find this maple-bodied pencil still available at Jetpens. I'm tempted to order mine before posting this, as it seems like they're running out (there used to be a few more choices...).

It's a bit tricky with mechanical pencils, as the workings tend to add a bit of weight. Adding a wooden or metal body is going to result in something on the heavy side. This is fine for some people, but it may drive you crazy and/or destroy your hand.


3.) Decent erasers

If you're buying a pencil in hopes of getting a nice eraser out of the deal, you're going to be disappointed. There are exceptions, but even the nicest pencils are often going to have teeny-tiny erasers tucked under a cap - fine for erasing a stray line, but not really up to erasing that Pokemon fan art you've just discovered you doodled on a key page in your will. Nice wooden pencils generally lack erasers as they'd just add cost and change the balance, and anyone serious enough to buy a decent pencil has almost certainly put down an extra buck or two for a quality eraser.

30562.jpg

Staedler Mars Plastic $1.25

Having said that, you can find some decent erasers stuck to mechanical pencils.


Usual mechanical pencil eraser (Pentel P209)
Small cross-section, but advances when you twist it (Paper Mate Apex)
Full size eraser; advances when you twist it (Paper Mate PhD)
Full Size eraser (Faber-Castell E-Motion)


4.) Different mechanisms

Mechanical pencils are hands down the top choice for writers who can't help fiddling with crap. There's no ink to get all over yourself, they have buttons to press, you can jab yourself in the leg with a sharp lead if you're falling asleep in class, and you can annoy the shit out of everyone in the library with the clicking noise.


Here's the big downside to mechanical pencils - in a tense, test-taking environment, the sounds of *click click click* *snap* *click click click* *snap* as you advance and bust your leads, can earn you a swift beating.

Japanese manufacturers have taken this to the next level with the shaker mechanism - a weight and clutch inside the pencil advances the lead when you shake it up and down. Why on Earth anyone would seek this out is beyond me, but there you go.


"Bad Boy," with engrish text: "I pass a gentle timbre..." (0.5)
Pilot Del Ful (0.5)
Uni alpha-gel (o.5)

You can just use the lead advance like a normal person with every shaker pencil I've ever owned. The shaking mechanism is only apparent if you try to engage it, so its presence shouldn't dissuade you from an excellent pencil like the Uni alpha-gel.

This particular pencil is interesting ("interesting") because the shaker mechanism does not engage unless you click the lead advance button all the way down.

Press to advance

Shake

It's all part of the full HD experience that Uni offers, no doubt.

The venerable Pentel Quicker Clicker is the first mechanical pencil I ever owned. Some people really dig the unique side-mounted lead advance.

PD345A_1_1_1.png


You don't see this copied much, actually.

The cheapo Bic Click Master lets you use either the eraser at the back, or two small buttons, which you squeeze towards each other, that presumably fit right beneath other people's thumb and first finger.

You can find a few pencils that use a twist to advance mechanism (like the Faber-Castell E-motion)



Your questions answered!

1. Bagels, that was informative and delightful.


Thank you, Bagels!

2. Do you really think that the pencil you use matters less than the lead? Really?

I used to have three Pilot Just Meet pencils, differing only in the stain applied to the body. I gave one to a dear friend and I'm still in mourning. What do you think?

3. I tend to snap the leads in my pencils. How do I prevent that?

I do too. Pencils with lead sleeves are better if you press really hard. Spending a few bucks on better leads is also key. They're made to snap less.

4. 'Hey, I should ignore the topic and post a picture of my favorite rollerball, like an idiot! Or just say "bic ballpoint atw."'

Please fall down a well. It's a topic specifically about mechanical pencils! Go make your own topic, you moron!

5. If I've never cared about pencils before, what really makes one mechanical pencil better than another? What am I really looking at here?

I'll admit to writing things by hand more than most people, so I spend more time thinking about this stuff. If you write a lot, you will notice things over time - weight, balance, how different materials feel in your hand. It can all be subtle at first, but the end result is that I find myself writing more simply because my Pilot Just Meets just feel so damn good to hold and use. It's a nice incentive to improve your writing.

There are 3 basic types of things to pay attention to:

1) Feel. This is the most utilitarian part. Most people prefer 0.5 mm or 0.7 mm lead. Some people like a really light pencil while others want a brick that can hold a piece of lead. Some people find a plastic grip gross, some prefer a gel grip, some want rubber, and so on. A pencil can be front-heavy, back-heavy, or neutral. Some things are just nice to write with, you know? In the same way that people prefer different switches in their mechanical keyboards, certain things will just feel good to write with.

2.) Features. Some people have to have a good eraser. Some people really want something that won't jab them in the bits if they carry it in their trousers. There are pencils that will automatically rotate the lead as you write, if you're really insufferable.

3.) Aesthetics. Some pens and pencils are just really beautiful.

I'm not going to tell you that a cool pencil is going to help you pick up chicks (even if that's TOTALLY TRUE), but I've had a surprising number of conversations start because someone noticed my pencil (WINK WINK!), told me it was cool, and wanted to know where I got it. Those conversations obviously ended abruptly when I launched into my description of how the earliest mechanical pencil was found in the wreckage of HMS Pandora, which sank in 1791...but it was fun while it lasted.

Why not use things that look nice, given the choice?

6.) Can we expect more of these write-ups?


Possibly? People seem to enjoy them, and they're fun to write, if time-consuming.

People wanted some thoughts on paper, which is the other big part in the writing equation. There are a zillion considerations there and I'm not in any way an artist or professional. Rhodia makes all sorts of different pads, the paper is great, and their products are pretty easy to find.

My incredible "Leonard Visits Space" sketchbook, which features as my photo backdrop, is from Ex Libris Anonymous. They make notebooks out of vintage books. They mix a few of the pages from the original book in with new, acid-free paper. Highly recommended!


---------------------
Finally, just a bunch of different pencils in the next post! Pictures should link to a place to find them (usually jetpens, which is where I like to shop. Browse around the web for deals!). I'll call out pencils with retractable tips (RT), unusually good erasers (E), shaker mechanisms (S), and other random stuff.

----------------------
Post your favorite mechanical pencils!

Just to be clear,
 

Bagels

You got Moxie, kid!
All images should be links
(click around for different sizes/grades)

$3.30

$3.30

$3.30

$3.30

$2


RT $5.50 RECOMMENDED

twisty eraser RT $10 RECOMMENDED


RT $16.50

(auto lead rotation) decent eraser $16.50


$33


$13.50


S $10

RT (automatically extends the lead as you write) $49.50

$19.50

$5

Multipen (red/black/0.5 pencil) $16.50 RECOMMENDED

RT S $8.25

0.3mm lead

0.9mm lead $39.00

RT (Lamy Safari) $22.50

RT $4.60

RT S $3.30

RT $31.00

RT $3.30

RT $16.50

(side lead advance) $3.80

$1.65

RT $10.00

$9/24 :(

Twist lead advance $3.50/12 :(

Can select between hard and soft lead-cushioning settings $24

$300. Guaranteed to roll under your sofa and never be seen again.

RT $39
 
Look I know this is a pencil thread but


If you guys have never used one of these go buy one, just scribble some stuff, and erase it. If you've only ever used a back-of-pencil pink eraser, your mind will be blown by how amazing your erasing experience is.
 

Verdre

Unconfirmed Member
Hey, one of your awesome threads that I can actually participate in. I've always loved mechanical pencils, but 99% of my experience with them was based on the cheap kind of thing you get at walmart.

I got lucky a few years ago and was given a really old Cross classic century that uses 0.9 mm lead and I love it. Very lucky I was given it as I'd never have paid the price to actually buy one and apparently the modern ones don't have of the build quality of the old ones. Another favorite (if just because I find it neat) is the Kuru Toga, which has a mechanism that slowly rotates the lead as you write, which makes for very uniform lines.

 

MikeDip

God bless all my old friends/And god bless me too, why pretend?
Well, I know what I'm buying this weekend. (Mechanical pencils)
 

RS4-

Member
I will never go back to mechanical; every time I've used one in school, just a pain in the ass. But these pencil threads of yours are great.
 

adelante

Member
Thanks for this thread!! I've recently picked up sketching again (after not having time away from graphic design to do so, at least for leisure and practice purposes) and was looking into getting carbon leads. I don't know if they'll produce blacks just as intense as its wood-cased counterparts. Gonna go stationary shopping this weekend!!

Here's something I finished a couple days ago, with a couple of mechanical pencils (Pentel Graphgear 500 HB and a Moleskine mechanical pencil 2B):

 

Goldrush

Member
Ugh...Mechanical Pencils are the worst. It's a pencil that you have to treat like a pen. Any doodling will apply too much pressure and you'll be left with a feeling of shame.

Edit: The above is quite impressive, though.
 
Any good 0.9mm recommendations? I've got a few 0.7mm and 1.3mm pencils and they are slightly too thin and too broad, respectively. They're strangely rare.
 
I much, much prefer to write with a mechanical pencil than a wooden one. I enjoy writing very fine, and hate how fat the letters look as a wooden pencil wears down. Fine point pen or mechanical pencil for life.
 
Thanks for this thread!! I've recently picked up sketching again (after not having time away from graphic design to do so, at least for leisure and practice purposes) and was looking into getting carbon leads. I don't know if they'll produce blacks just as intense as its wood-cased counterparts. Gonna go stationary shopping this weekend!!

Here's something I finished a couple days ago, with a couple of mechanical pencils (Pentel Graphgear 500 HB and a Moleskine mechanical pencil 2B):
Very jealous of you artist types. I could literally never create that.
 

mdphilli

Member
I'm pretty sure I said this about your previous threads...But I change my mind and THIS is the greatest post I've ever read.
 

Bagels

You got Moxie, kid!
was waiting for this thread.

great work bagels.

why no inclusion of:

MechanischeStifte_582.jpg

I've never used one! Looks nice!

Thank you for this. I am very picky about how my mechanical pencil looks and I will definitely look into these. I haven't really researched much, but I have this one, http://www.staedtler.com/en/product...al-pencils/graphite-925-25-mechanical-pencil/. What are your thoughts on it if any

My engineer buddy has one (Technica-X's always get comments from engineers, I've found). It's a little too..file-like for me. The grip is kinda sharp. He loves his, but it didn't do it for me. They're really well made, though.

Any good 0.9mm recommendations? I've got a few 0.7mm and 1.3mm pencils and they are slightly too thin and too broad, respectively. They're strangely rare.

The one I use is a Pentel P209. You can select 0.9 mm pencils from the options on jetpens, too.
 
Dude, I didn't even know that writing utensil GAF was a thing. I've been collecting pens, pencils, markers and that junk since 2004 when I first started pen spinning.
Here is my collection as of like... 4 years ago and I haven't taken any updated pictures since then.


My go-to writing utensil is a modification of the Zebra M-301. I took two of the pencil's barrels to extend the pencil to make it longer and easier to spin with. Then I stuck a Dong-A Anyball/Papermate Profile grip for comfort.
Pictures upon request.
 

jb1234

Member
I used to have three Pilot Just Meet pencils, differing only in the stain applied to the body. I gave one to a dear friend and I'm still in mourning.

I want to take this time to point out that I'm the dear friend. THAT'S RIGHT, I HAVE A JUST MEET! IN YOUR FACES!

...

*ahem*

Anyway. Oh, yeah. I'll agree with the whole "get a Staedtler" eraser. Things are fucking amazing. I'll never go back to a regular "on the back on a pencil" eraser. Never. You'll have to make me.
 

LeleSocho

Banned
Ah the good old Staedtler eraser... everyone had one in school. When you bought one you were super careful with it and never let others use it.
Tomorrow i might buy some stuff for drawing thanks to this thread.
 

pizza dog

Banned
Dear OP, I read your whole post and adore your style.

Alas, I ain't got shit to say about mechanical pencils.

Very Truly Yours,
Pizza Dog
 
A few of mine that I use at home; most of the others are at the office (I'm a graphic designer and I HAVE to draw everything before I even think about touching a PC). I prefer mechanicals to lead holders, but I have quite a few at work. Most of them are duplicates though.

Mechanicals (my favorite is the Kuro Toga High Grade, not pictured it's at work).

Lead Holders (I primarily use the red capped black Caran d'Arch; I take it EVERYWHERE)

Inks (I swear the Uni Ball Signo is the whitest white EVA!)

Erasers (I order these in bulk via Jetpens)

Markers

Lead
 
Bagels makes the best threads EVER.

I use a Kuro Toga pencil for my light sketching and works super well. Also, it's light blue and that's just nice.
 

Feep

Banned
I love these threads, and I'm not sure why. I think it's just the general presentation and care put into the OP.
 

Wilsongt

Member
That's our Bagels.

Nothing is better than writing with a sturdy, yet comfortable, mechanical pencil.

Except a sturdy, robust, and comfortable ink pen. =D
 
I've got a Kuru Toga, myself. I've become pretty enamored by the super consistent line it gives. Even the cheap-ish $8 one makes a pretty nice mark. I like the lead they come with, too.

That said, I get down with a Bic Matic pretty frequently, too. I know they suck. Don't care. They just feel really natural to use. Probably nostalgia. You can't beat the price, though.
 

jb1234

Member
"7 minutes in heaven? How about 3 and 1/2 in the back seat of a living saint's used Toyota Camry, baby?" is one of my favorite things I've ever written. No one seemed to find that funny!

I'm not sure 3 and a half minutes in the back of a car is something to be proud of, big guy. ;)
 
I was the type of kid who was always sharpening his pencil when it got the slightest bit dull, so a mechanical pencil solved that. I got my daughter some "shaker" pencils from jetpens. She thinks they're neat, though I notice they break pretty easily. We've been trying some of the weirder erasers from Japan, too.

Thanks for these threads, Bagels!
 
My original favorite mechanical pencil was the Pilot Dr. Grip (and it's "improved" Limited one), but I've been using the Papermate Ph.D. It is still the best after all these years - excellent grip, great eraser, plus it looks nice in black. It's older brother, the Ph.D Ultra aboslutely sucks. I wouldn't even bother with it.

I've used the Staedler Mars eraser for years now and it is also the best.
 
Love mechanical pencils. So practical. I don't remember which of the nicer ones I had, but I'll probably look them up later.

Funnily enough, all the engineers I've met somehow are inept at using these devices. They extend the lead way too far, only to press down at an angle and break them. I'm not sure if they're doing it on purpose or if they're completely oblivious to how these things work.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom