PantherLotus said:
I think I found the offending post.
THIS IS PATENTLY WRONG. SALES DON'T WORK LIKE THAT JIMBO.
Hey Panther I was really starting to like you. I thought we had a thing going there man. Ah well, it was fun while it lasted.
So I guess I need to remind you of your post from last week?
PantherLotus said:
I'm not sure, but I'll make a killer prediction for this week's 360 sales:
.5k-6k.
you can bank it.
:lol Yeah? I would have been a richer man and laughed all the way to the bank. I'm ok with just the laughing though.
Honestly, with you handling the charts I figured you would have noticed by now the 360 trend that has been going on. I was surprised when you made that prediction.
Look believe me when I say, I know what it feels like to go against the grain, especially in this tough forum. You lose popularity, you get personally insulted(which you seem to like taking a part of yourself), you risk pissing off people....but really there's nothing wrong with pointing out things that may not make everyone happy to hear .
Look at your charts. Pay attention to what was happening prior to ToV. Factor in the price drop. The games that just got released. Factor in the holiday season, The Last Remnant and the upcoming SO4, plus the momentum and positive publicity and believe me.....
you will come to the same conclusion. That is how sales work: Price, demand, interest, publicity, holiday season competition(or lack off) all help increase videogame sales. The 360 has all of those things going for it right now.
This isn't an accident. I am not surprised with these results. Everyone should have been able to see this coming about a month ago.
But no this is just typical MC. The 360
has to suck in Japan or else we don't know how to handle the situation.
Yeah, for now, for a couple reasons.
1. How many times can I say "Wii = 30k-60k, PS3 = 7k-16k, 360 = 1.5k-5k?" I mean, I can claim to be extremely accurate but how hard is it? Here's how:
2. Look at the past 12 weeks of data, compare to the previous year, adjust for big titles/accessories/SKUs. It's a solid method when we get data week to week, while it would never work in the NPD threads.
3. I might someday go back to it, probably when I'm bored. What I hope to create through my charts is an ability for ALL users (not just me) to see what is happening and make the same predictions for themselves.
4. Sales-Age is always looking for new brethren. Why not pick up the mantle using the method I described above? Just be honest about your results and you could have a nice little following
.
Seriously, you should take your own advice. Predicting the norm takes no skill and is boring. Predicting changes takes guts and balls, and I understand not everyone likes that because there is always the posibility of being WRONG and having people point it out. You also rarely get any credit when you do predict right. But that's how the world revolves, and me? I wouldn't have it any other way.
Also if there's one thing I learned is that sales data, and charts of the past year give you a good idea of what happened IN THE PAST, and while they can paint a general picture, such as where the lull period starts and how sales increase over the holidays....they do NOT predict the future.
If they did, we would never have meltdowns. What's going on NOW in the industry and in the near future, ALONG with previous data does give you a great guessing tool. But previous history alone is not enough. There are many factors that need to be accounted for at ANY point in time. That's why you can't even possibly put your finger on next week's hardware results. Believe me, I don't pull my guesses out of my ass and they are not based on optimism alone. I look at the same stuff you do, and I also look at what's happening.
But that's what I love about GAF. Sometimes the crowd in here get so hard headed and get stuck in that follower mentality, that it's always fun being around for weeks like this.