• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Media Create Sales 11/19 - 11/25 2007

apujanata

Member
cvxfreak said:
Resident Evil 4 is better than any Fire Emblem, sales-wise and review-wise.

I have to disagree with you there. FE:Radiant Dawn is THE best Fire Emblem, ever. Reminded of the first time I play FE3 on SNES. RE4 is very good, but NOT that good.

I am now in Part 4, Chapter 1. Very near the end.
 

apujanata

Member
Vinnk said:
On my way home from work (I just got home), I stopped at Best Denki and Wanpaku looking for WiiFit. They told me they have been sold out since saturday.

So that makes 4 stores sold out. The other 2 are Yamada Denki and Famicom Dojo that I went to yesterday. Yamada, Best and Wanpaku are the biggest game stores in my town so I don't think it would be unfair to predict that it's totally sold out in my city.

I don't know who I should blame for game only lasting ONE DAY. Nintendo, Retailers or buyers. I was thinking that as casual game, sell out in one day is improbable, but Wii Fit prove me wrong.

I blame Wii Fit for my prediction error.
 

donny2112

Member
Vinnk, Can you check out this site? http://ex23.2ch.net/test/read.cgi/ghard/1196792693/

From my understanding, this is the place where we normally get the early Famitsu data.

Edit:
In fact, I'm just not going to even post this data. It lacks Basara 2 and has Ratchet, so it is almost assuredly wrong.

This might just be some random posters predictions, so if you could check it out, Vinnk or another Japanese reader, it'd be good. Thanks! :)
 

cvxfreak

Member
apujanata said:
I have to disagree with you there. FE:Radiant Dawn is THE best Fire Emblem, ever. Reminded of the first time I play FE3 on SNES. RE4 is very good, but NOT that good.

I am now in Part 4, Chapter 1. Very near the end.

But RE4 factually received the better reviews. Therefore my statement is factually correct. :lol
 

donny2112

Member
sp0rsk said:
if you can't read it, don't post it.

I can read the Google translation of it. There's no identifying statements around it that say it's a prediction, but it just seems too off.

cvxfreak said:
But RE4 factually received the better reviews. Therefore my statement is factually correct. :lol

"You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means."
 
Big post for a biiiiiiig update. Since I already had most of the Famitsu weekly info from recent years gathered up from when doing DS/PSP/PS3/Wii data, I decided to do the rest of the other systems in one go. PS2, GBA, GCN, Xbox, and X360 from 2004-present. Over 1000 new games, and the amount of weekly data increased by about 50%.

This is a Good Thing, but the data also isn't perfect. From the combination of Famitsu's bungles (sometimes listing the incorrect platform or release year), errors of omission from old GAF translations of Top lists (occasionally missing an "Ultimate Hits" label or whatnot), and my errors from putting it together (I once had a game and its Prologue-like predecessor as one entity), there are probably many more oddities that I just didn't notice. If you see something off, give me a shout.

The titles are also pretty goofy. If I didn't recognize its proper title right away or there wasn't one given in a Top 500 list, it pretty much got the goofy Babelfish name. If anyone wants to help fix titles, that'd be groovy. Maybe pick a series you're familiar with. I know Namco's Taiko games ended up with some goofy "drum blimey" titles, and Harvest Moon doesn't Babelfish into anything like Harvest Moon at all. If you see a title you can make correct, the simplest way would be to put its Game ID followed by a comma, then the correct name, and send the bunch to me. Like so:
543, The Legend of Translation
1433, The Legend of Translation (Babelfish the Best)
1500, The Legend of Translation II: Romanizing

Though to be honest, I'd be perfectly happy leaving some of these fun names. I think the world is a little better place for having "Davy takes four Derby horses to conceive!"

If you've got a fix on a publisher, price, or whatever else formatting it the same way would be best; just group them apart so we don't get a game called 5800. I can take it from there.


This nearly fills in the present and recent systems that we can get a pretty complete picture of. I've got some X360 monthly data by way of donny by way of Dalthien (I think) that I haven't gotten to yet, but that's about it. Older systems go back far enough that I wouldn't be able to get a complete picture, except for maybe WonderSwan. Maybe I'll want to go back and put in such data for at least PS2 launch and on, so at least there won't be gaps in the weekly rankings.


There are still things that sites like Japan-GameCharts have that my data is missing, though. He tries to give the best view of the present, I try to give the best view of an arbitrary point in the past. Topical example: Super Mario Sunshine. According to my data, it makes it all the way up to 677,440. According to the latest Famitsu info on J-GC, it's up to at least 789,989. It never reappeared in the Top 30 after 2002, and didn't sell enough to make it into the Top 100 for 2003 or later, so it's slipped under my radar. Some day we'll get more comprehensive data for earlier years, though.


Just a few interesting tidbits from this mass of data.

I was having a problem with inconsistent dates for the release of Hot Shots Golf 4 (PlayStation 2 the Best). As it turns out, it was counting separately for a 3800 yen release in 2004, and a 2800 yen release in 2005. All added up, the three versions of Hot Shots Golf 4 at least pass 1.5 million.

Fire Emblem: GCN vs Wii vs PS2, including Berwick Saga. I believe the first Tear Ring Saga on PS1 did much better than any of these games, buuuut it's not in the database.

Mario Party 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, Advance, DS

Super Mario Advance 1, 2, 3, 4 through 2 years

Sonic Adventure 2 Battle, Adventure DX, Heroes (GCN), and Secret Rings

Halo 1, 2, 3


I know you don't all have the URLs to my various things always at hand, so here are the few most important for finding/using this software data.
Game Search
Japanese Software Sales Line Graph Generator

Weekly data from week of 2004-12-27, modify the week in the URL to get other weeks
Total PS2 software through the week of 2001-02-19, modify the platform and week in the URL to get what you want.
 

Vinnk

Member
donny2112 said:
Vinnk, Can you check out this site? http://ex23.2ch.net/test/read.cgi/ghard/1196792693/

From my understanding, this is the place where we normally get the early Famitsu data.

Edit:
In fact, I'm just not going to even post this data. It lacks Basara 2 and has Ratchet, so it is almost assuredly wrong.

This might just be some random posters predictions, so if you could check it out, Vinnk or another Japanese reader, it'd be good. Thanks! :)

2ch is blocked at my work also. Sorry. I could read it when I get home, but by that time, someone else will probably have it translated.
 

donny2112

Member
Vinnk said:
2ch is blocked at my work also.

Thanks, anyways. The normal posters of the early Famitsu numbers should be here soon.

JoshuaJSlone said:
Big post for a biiiiiiig update.

Nice. Good work! :D

JoshuaJSlone said:
From the combination of Famitsu's bungles (sometimes listing the incorrect platform or release year),

That was fun. The Famicom Mini games were particularly troublesome, and the PS2 and GBA sometimes switched randomly. :lol

JoshuaJSlone said:
I think the world is a little better place for having "Davy takes four Derby horses to conceive!"

http://www.*************/console/ps2/data/924772.html

I think it could also be called "Let's Make a Derby Horse 4," but I usually go with the GameFAQs translation for the older stuff.

JoshuaJSlone said:
I've got some X360 monthly data by way of donny by way of Dalthien (I think)

januswon

JoshuaJSlone said:
I was having a problem with inconsistent dates for the release of Hot Shots Golf 4 (PlayStation 2 the Best). As it turns out, it was counting separately for a 3800 yen release in 2004, and a 2800 yen release in 2005.

Yeah. Just going by the Japanese name, Famitsu doesn't distinguish the two. I just manually labelled the second one as (BEST Reprint) since I don't keep track of the price info. I'm glad you were able to keep them straight! :)

JoshuaJSlone said:
I believe the first Tear Ring Saga on PS1 did much better than any of these games, buuuut it's not in the database.

Code:
20010527	PS1	TearRing Saga  230489	NEW
20010603	PS1	TearRing Saga   53330	283819
20010610	PS1	TearRing Saga   23259	307077
20010617	PS1	TearRing Saga   14873	321950
20010624	PS1	TearRing Saga   10777	332727
20010701	PS1	TearRing Saga    7970	340697
20010708	PS1	TearRing Saga    4734	345430
20010715	PS1	TearRing Saga    3929	349360
20011230	PS1	TearRing Saga        	366142
JoshuaJSlone said:
I know you don't all have the URLs to my various things always at hand, so here are the few most important for finding/using this software data.
Game Search
Japanese Software Sales Line Graph Generator

Always useful. Thanks! :)
 

creamsugar

Member
Famitsu

DSL 126000
PSP 78000
PS2 15000
PS3 41000
Wii 71000
360 5200

1-10
1.Layton2 308000
2.Wii Fit 254000
3.SD Gundam ggene spirits (PS2) 231000
4.DQ4 132000(734000)
5.BASARA2 Heroes PS2 94000
6.WE2008PS2 89000(395000)
7.Mario Party DS 57000(521000)
8.Mario & Sonic 42000(109000)
9.Yugioh wcs2008 (DS) 39000
10.SMG 36000(452000)
 

Defuser

Member
creamsugar said:
Famitsu

DSL 126000
PSP 78000
PS2 15000
PS3 41000
Wii 71000
360 5200

1-10
1.Layton2 308000
2.WiiFit 254000
3.Gジェネ 231000
4.DQ4 132000(73400)
5.BASARA PS2 94000
6.WE2008PS2 89000(395000)
7.MarioPartyDS 57000(521000)
8.Mario & Sonic 42000(109000)
9.遊戯王 39000
10.SMG 36000(452000)
What the hell is 10?

So Wiifit isn't sold out...but good nonetheless.
So where is basara 2 heroes Wii?
 

gconsole

Member
apujanata said:
I have to disagree with you there. FE:Radiant Dawn is THE best Fire Emblem, ever. Reminded of the first time I play FE3 on SNES. RE4 is very good, but NOT that good.

I am now in Part 4, Chapter 1. Very near the end.

Personal point of view is different. But we are in general talking about the sales and review score from the public, aren't we?
 
Go Layton. <3 And better come fast to NA or Europe.

And Mario & Sonic has a surprisingly strong second week. First day sales were around 15.000, so the LTD will end up 10 times bigger than that. Pretty unique.
 
tide_turning_lol.jpg
 

CoolS

Member
creamsugar said:
Famitsu

DSL 126000
PSP 78000
PS2 15000
PS3 41000
Wii 71000
360 5200

1-10
1.Layton2&#12288;308000
2.WiiFit&#12288;254000
3.G&#12472;&#12455;&#12493;&#12288;231000
4.DQ4&#12288;132000&#65288;734000&#65289;
5.BASARA PS2&#12288;94000
6.WE2008PS2&#12288;89000&#65288;395000&#65289;
7.MarioPartyDS&#12288;57000&#65288;521000&#65289;
8.Mario & Sonic&#12288;42000&#65288;109000&#65289;
9.Yugioh&#12288;39000
10.SMG&#12288;36000&#65288;452000&#65289;

Wow @ DS, it really never will stop selling.
Wii got a really nice bump, as expected from Wii Fit.

Software:
Seriously WOW @ Layton 2. Really nice numbers, can we expect it to keep selling like the first one?
Wii Fit did also nicely, I bet it will keep selling really nice. Man I want to try that thing.
DQ4 looks like it could easily achieve the same number like the PS remake. Is the game supply constrained? it will also be interisting to watch how it will do in the coming weeks.

I'm also suprises Mario& Sonic still sells good, I thought it would drop out of Top10.

And yay @ SMG. It definitely seems to have legs and I believe it didn't drop that much since last week.
 

swerve

Member
Defuser said:
So Wiifit isn't sold out...
It didn't sell out within its launch 48 hrs (this chart). It does appear to have sold out since. I'm just back from the store and it's not available round here.
 
Wow, Mario & Sonic may be showing early signs of legs. Super Mario Galaxy is definitely showing signs of legs. Wii Fit did far better than I expected (one day of sales!). DQIV seems to be going to the same school of hard knocks as other hotly demanded SE titles on the DS.

Last but not least, congrats to Level 5 on Layton. Excellent opening numbers.
 

Hesemonni

Banned
creamsugar said:
Famitsu

DSL 126000
PSP 78000
PS2 15000
PS3 41000
Wii 71000
360 5200

1-10
1.Layton2&#12288;308000
2.Wii Fit&#12288;254000
3.SD Gundam ggene spirits (PS2)&#12288;231000
4.DQ4&#12288;132000&#65288;734000&#65289;
5.BASARA2 Heroes PS2&#12288;94000
6.WE2008PS2&#12288;89000&#65288;395000&#65289;
7.Mario Party DS&#12288;57000&#65288;521000&#65289;
8.Mario & Sonic&#12288;42000&#65288;109000&#65289;
9.Yugioh wcs2008 (DS)&#12288;39000
10.SMG&#12288;36000&#65288;452000&#65289;
Btw. Why are Famitsu sales always posted in such a crappy ass format? A space or two in there would make it alot more readable.
 

marc^o^

Nintendo's Pro Bono PR Firm
Wii sales should be great this December and Smash Bros is released early January.
I think will see such numbers for weeks to come.
 

jgwhiteus

Member
I think those WiiFit numbers are really good - only 2 days of sales vs. the traditional 4 for all the other opening week titles like Layton, right? And didn't SMG open with around 250,000 as well? So WiiFit matched SMG's opening week in half the time...I won't comment on my feelings on that :/ (though I'm not a WiiFit troll - I plan on getting it myself).

And the 300,000 retail shipment was just a rumor, wasn't it? In any case, ~85% of the shipment in 2 days is pretty amazing, and it makes it seem likely that the first shipment was sold out by now.
 

SovanJedi

provides useful feedback
I think this is the best of both worlds here - Wii Fit definitely did the big numbers for its 2-day debut, but it still didn't take the number 1 slot from a very deserving sequel to a promising IP. In other words, gaming is FAR from dead. :D

Nice hardware numbers too... But I wonder what they will be like after the not-holiday-but-numbers-still-go-up-anyway season?
 

iidesuyo

Member
My prediction was 240k for WiiFit, so I'm not far off :D Wii gets a significant bump, PS3 steadily keeps above 40k. The revision seems to have done nothing for the PS2, 20m is probably the saturation point for home consoles in Japan. The software still sells though (over 400k software sales for PS2).
 

creamsugar

Member
Others
12.WE2008 PS3&#12288;31000&#65288;176000&#65289;
14.Wii Sports&#12288;27000&#65288;2162000&#65289;
15.Wii Play&#12288;26000&#65288;1707000&#65289;
18.Musou5 PS3&#12288;15000&#65288;295000&#65289;
19.&#12364;&#12435;&#12400;&#12427;&#31169;&#12398;&#23478;&#35336;&#12480;&#12452;&#12450;&#12522;&#12540; (DS)&#12288;14000&#65288;310000&#65289;
21.REUC&#12288;13000&#65288;147000&#65289;
22.Mario Kart DS&#12288;13000&#65288;2566000&#65289;
24.Layton1&#12288;12000&#65288;696000&#65289;
26.Pokemon dungeon &#12288;12000&#65288;1076000&#65289;
27.MHP2&#12288;11000&#65288;1387000&#65289;

New Games
11.Assassins Creed&#12288;34000
16.Natuto2 Wii&#12288;20000
17.Disgaea PSP&#12288;17000
25.Precure5 DS&#12288;12000
&#22806;.BASARA2 Heroes Wii&#12288;8600
&#22806;.Izuna2&#12288;6500
&#22806;.Super Swing Golf Season 2&#12288;6500
&#22806;.GUILTY GEAR 2 -OVERTURE-&#12288;5300
&#22806;.Another Century's Episode 2 Special Vocal Version&#12288;4900
&#22806;.Kabutore Next&#12288;3400
&#22806;.Tony Hawk's Project 8 PS3&#12288;1800
&#22806;.Tony Hawk's Project 8 360&#12288;1100
 

iidesuyo

Member
BASARA2 Heroes PS2&#12288;94000
BASARA2 Heroes Wii&#12288;8600

I have no clue what this game is about, but Wii has a HUGE problem when it comes to multiplatform releases. Was the PS2 version cheaper?
 
- nice sales for layton 2! i hope it beats mario party ds, that would be a very good signal to third parties on nintendo platforms.
- wiifit's next 2-3 weeks will be decisive, if it drops below 100-150k it's not gonna be the hit everybody thought it would be.
- 41k ps3s, probably even lower on media create... gt5p, we need u!
 

CoolS

Member
iidesuyo said:
BASARA2 Heroes PS2&#12288;94000
BASARA2 Heroes Wii&#12288;8600

I have no clue what this game is about, but Wii has a HUGE problem when it comes to multiplatform releases. Was the PS2 version cheaper?

It actually was but I don't think that's the single reason y the PS2 version sells better ...
 

Kazenone

Member
iidesuyo said:
BASARA2 Heroes PS2&#12288;94000
BASARA2 Heroes Wii&#12288;8600

I have no clue what this game is about, but Wii has a HUGE problem when it comes to multiplatform releases. Was the PS2 version cheaper?

The Wii version was a bit more expensive because it came packed with the original
 
ShmarthurShmooner said:
- nice sales for layton 2! i hope it beats mario party ds, that would be a very good signal to third parties on nintendo platforms.
- wiifit's next 2-3 weeks will be decisive, if it drops below 100-150k it's not gonna be the hit everybody thought it would be.
- 41k ps3s, probably even lower on media create... gt5p, we need u!

Let's not forget Wii Sports did it by selling merely 30-40k a week.
 
Famitsu

DSL 126000
PSP 78000
PS2 15000
PS3 41000
Wii 71000
360 5200

1-10
1. Layton 2 - &#12288;308,000
2. Wii Fit&#12288; - 254,000
3. SD Gundam Ggene Spirits (PS2)&#12288; - 231,000
4. Dragon Quest 4 - 132,000 &#65288;734,000&#65289;
5. BASARA2 Heroes PS2&#12288; - 94,000
6. WE2008 (PS2) - &#12288;89,000 &#65288;395,000&#65289;
7. Mario Party DS&#12288; - 57,000 &#65288;521,000&#65289;
8. Mario & Sonic&#12288; - 42,000 &#65288;109,000&#65289;
9. Yugioh Wcs2008 (DS)&#12288; - 39,000
10. Super Mario Galaxy - &#12288;36,000 &#65288;452,000)

Spaces work some fucking wonders people.
 

Ydahs

Member
Great Wiifit numbers and nice to see the Wii getting a healthy boost.. Are Famitsu numbers normally the same as Media Create?
 

loosus

Banned
In the top ten is "legs"? Geez, if these are the expectations we have for true Mario games now, I reckon we can now call Mario Galaxy among the best-selling games of all time in Japan -- just with the caveat that we have zero expectations.
 

Crusade

Member
Good SMG numbers. It'll have good legs if it stays around there. And somebody said Mario and Sonic might be the next game to buy with Wii, instead of Wii Sports. They may have been on to something
 
GreenNight said:
Famitsu

DSL 126000
PSP 78000
PS2 15000
PS3 41000
Wii 71000
360 5200

1-10
1. Layton 2 - &#12288;308000
2. Wii Fit&#12288; - 254000
3. SD Gundam Ggene Spirits (PS2)&#12288; - 231000
4. Dragon Quest 4 - 132000 &#65288;734000&#65289;
5. BASARA2 Heroes PS2&#12288; - 94000
6. WE2008 (PS2) - &#12288;89000 &#65288;395000&#65289;
7. Mario Party DS&#12288; - 57000 &#65288;521000&#65289;
8. Mario & Sonic&#12288; - 42000 &#65288;109000&#65289;
9. Yugioh Wcs2008 (DS)&#12288; - 39000
10. Super Mario Galaxy - &#12288;36000 &#65288;452000)

Spaces work some fucking wonders people.
Fixed.

loosus said:
In the top ten is "legs"? Geez, if these are the expectations we have for true Mario games now, I reckon we can now call Mario Galaxy among the best-selling games of all time in Japan -- just with the caveat that we have zero expectations.
No. Doing between 30-40k for the past few weeks are "legs".
 

Crusade

Member
Ydahs said:
Great Wiifit numbers and nice to see the Wii getting a healthy boost.. Are Famitsu numbers normally the same as Media Create?
They've been a bit different for the past few weeks, so it'll probably be the same trend this week
 

jgwhiteus

Member
loosus said:
In the top ten is "legs"? Geez, if these are the expectations we have for true Mario games now, I reckon we can now call Mario Galaxy among the best-selling games of all time in Japan -- just with the caveat that we have zero expectations.

To be fair, I think everyone's expectations were dashed with SMG's second week numbers, so now it's a matter of, "I hope it at least matches SMS in Japan" (doesn't seem to be a problem in the US, though) - because it deserves it.
 

CoolS

Member
loosus said:
In the top ten is "legs"? Geez, if these are the expectations we have for true Mario games now, I reckon we can now call Mario Galaxy among the best-selling games of all time in Japan -- just with the caveat that we have zero expectations.
Barely loosing sales compared to last week is legs to me
 
Top Bottom